So kids in immersion of any kind don’t get a whack at “enriched literacy curriculum” unless they go to CES? Bummer if true |
That is correct. |
Immersion programs have to source a bunch of their own curricular material. If supported, they can come up and employ with rough equivalents to ELC. If supported. |
Not missing much. Elc isn’t great |
https://www.montgomeryschoolsmd.org/curriculum/enriched/programs/elc/ CES is very freeform "whatever the teacher wants to do", not a "curriculum" that is used across schools. |
Their literacy curriculum is enriched by the foreign language. |
That’s not true. There’s a very specific and detailed curriculum. Teachers adhere to it more or less. My kids 4th grade teacher insisted on doing everything which meant a very heavy workload. |
That wasn't true when my kids went through the program. In fact, it seemed downright rigid. |
| Interesting. This not our experience. My daughter is currently enrolled and loves it. Feels less rigid than her home school curriculum and that is partly what she loves about it. |
I think this is true, and as the parent of an immersion kid I'm not complaining, but want to point out that the "Academy" kids in one-way immersion don't have access to the ELC either. So, if you are an English language kid in a school that houses a OWI program, you don't currently have access to ELC. Hopefully that changes next year. |
These kids are already getting access to special programming not available to everyone. |
We haven’t found this to be true. ELC has been great for mine and several other kids I know in the class. |
That is one form of enrichment, but not one directed at the need for complexity/depth that is the aim of CES. |
Seems like not all schools with immersion are the same. There is ELC for non- immersion at our school. One way immersion is a special program with the enrichment and challenge of learning in a language that is not our kid’s first language. I’d pick it for my kid over ELC or CES- that’s why we applied and plan to stick with it through middle school. That being said, Im glad there are other options and ELC is also available in non- immersion classes at immersion schools. If we hadn’t gotten immersion in the lottery in K, it would have been important to us. |
This sounds like what I got in school, and it was awesome. |