Why so many human development indices favor Scandinavian countries?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Scandinavians have amazing social services. They don't worry about healthcare, retirement or college costs.

That is because of the homogenous society - shared values, shared culture, everyone pays into the system.
A country cannot have these nice things if there is unlimited illegal immigration, people that do not pay into the system and divergent cultures.
I know that vexes a lot of progressives, but there a lot to be said about homogeneity.

Where do you get this weird notion that immigrants to Scandinavia aren't paying in?

A lot of them are recent refugees and have no money. They’ve also brought crime, at least in Sweden.

Sweden went from one of the lowest rates of gun violence in Europe to one of the highest, and something like 90% of suspects in shootings have an immigrant background.

https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/11/17/even-sweden-doesnt-want-migrants-anymore-syria-iraq-belarus/

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Scandinavians have amazing social services. They don't worry about healthcare, retirement or college costs.

That is because of the homogenous society - shared values, shared culture, everyone pays into the system.
A country cannot have these nice things if there is unlimited illegal immigration, people that do not pay into the system and divergent cultures.
I know that vexes a lot of progressives, but there a lot to be said about homogeneity.

Where do you get this weird notion that immigrants to Scandinavia aren't paying in?

A lot of them are recent refugees and have no money. They’ve also brought crime, at least in Sweden.

Sweden went from one of the lowest rates of gun violence in Europe to one of the highest, and something like 90% of suspects in shootings have an immigrant background.

https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/11/17/even-sweden-doesnt-want-migrants-anymore-syria-iraq-belarus/

Refugees are treated well, educated, and assimilated into the society. If you pay any attention to Scandinavian life, they are included everywhere.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Scandinavians have amazing social services. They don't worry about healthcare, retirement or college costs.

That is because of the homogenous society - shared values, shared culture, everyone pays into the system.
A country cannot have these nice things if there is unlimited illegal immigration, people that do not pay into the system and divergent cultures.
I know that vexes a lot of progressives, but there a lot to be said about homogeneity.

Where do you get this weird notion that immigrants to Scandinavia aren't paying in?

All four of them? Maybe they are.

Since Biden the US has had more illegal immigrants flooding in than most of the total population of some of these countries. And I know for a fact that those immigrants have not paid into the system and are getting US tax dollar resources.

And that is why we cannot have nice things for our society.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I really don't think this is a difficult analysis. A strong social safety net including universal healthcare and a guaranteed pension, plus strong worker's rights including guaranteed sick leave, vacation leave, parental leave, etc. And generally high government standards against corruption couple with a belief that government is in existence to work for the people.

Homogeneity definitely helps, but the issue with immigrants isn't just that they look different. It's that many of them don't want to assimilate and embrace the culture of their adopted country.

It's funny how Americans are so quick to jump to "they don't want to assimilate and embrace the culture of their adopted country" while forgetting that they probably have an immigrant Italian nonna who came to America at 20 years old yet went to the grave at 80 still barely speaking a lick of English. They forget that in the 1920s most of the major cities in America had newspapers that were published in German, or Italian, or Polish, or a number of other languages, reflecting the language and culture of the immigrants. Assimilation doesn't happen overnight. It didn't for your own ancestors, either.

Around 1920 they passed laws that cut immigration, giving room for assimilation.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Scandinavians have amazing social services. They don't worry about healthcare, retirement or college costs.

That is because of the homogenous society - shared values, shared culture, everyone pays into the system.
A country cannot have these nice things if there is unlimited illegal immigration, people that do not pay into the system and divergent cultures.
I know that vexes a lot of progressives, but there a lot to be said about homogeneity.

Where do you get this weird notion that immigrants to Scandinavia aren't paying in?

A lot of them are recent refugees and have no money. They’ve also brought crime, at least in Sweden.

Sweden went from one of the lowest rates of gun violence in Europe to one of the highest, and something like 90% of suspects in shootings have an immigrant background.

https://foreignpolicy.com/2021/11/17/even-sweden-doesnt-want-migrants-anymore-syria-iraq-belarus/

Refugees are treated well, educated, and assimilated into the society. If you pay any attention to Scandinavian life, they are included everywhere.

Some, for sure, but not all of them. Sweden is having problems.

There is a tension there that wasn’t there before. Something like 100 policemen were injured in riots last year, and politicians this year have started burning Qurans to make a statement. Even the PM had acknowledged that integration has failed and that crime is up.

Where Sweden goes from here I don’t know, but it does seem to indicate running the country was easier when the country was more homogeneous.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I really don't think this is a difficult analysis. A strong social safety net including universal healthcare and a guaranteed pension, plus strong worker's rights including guaranteed sick leave, vacation leave, parental leave, etc. And generally high government standards against corruption couple with a belief that government is in existence to work for the people.

Homogeneity definitely helps, but the issue with immigrants isn't just that they look different. It's that many of them don't want to assimilate and embrace the culture of their adopted country.

It's funny how Americans are so quick to jump to "they don't want to assimilate and embrace the culture of their adopted country" while forgetting that they probably have an immigrant Italian nonna who came to America at 20 years old yet went to the grave at 80 still barely speaking a lick of English. They forget that in the 1920s most of the major cities in America had newspapers that were published in German, or Italian, or Polish, or a number of other languages, reflecting the language and culture of the immigrants. Assimilation doesn't happen overnight. It didn't for your own ancestors, either.

Not really. Very few immigrants in the early 20th century failed to learn at least spoken English. Relatively few passed their native tongue to the next generation.

My German ancestors spoke German here in the states for 3 generations. Gave it up because of anti-German sentiment during WWI.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Scandinavians have amazing social services. They don't worry about healthcare, retirement or college costs.

That is because of the homogenous society - shared values, shared culture, everyone pays into the system.
A country cannot have these nice things if there is unlimited illegal immigration, people that do not pay into the system and divergent cultures.
I know that vexes a lot of progressives, but there a lot to be said about homogeneity. [/quote

The US has never been homogeneous in the way you describe it.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I really don't think this is a difficult analysis. A strong social safety net including universal healthcare and a guaranteed pension, plus strong worker's rights including guaranteed sick leave, vacation leave, parental leave, etc. And generally high government standards against corruption couple with a belief that government is in existence to work for the people.

Homogeneity definitely helps, but the issue with immigrants isn't just that they look different. It's that many of them don't want to assimilate and embrace the culture of their adopted country.

It's funny how Americans are so quick to jump to "they don't want to assimilate and embrace the culture of their adopted country" while forgetting that they probably have an immigrant Italian nonna who came to America at 20 years old yet went to the grave at 80 still barely speaking a lick of English. They forget that in the 1920s most of the major cities in America had newspapers that were published in German, or Italian, or Polish, or a number of other languages, reflecting the language and culture of the immigrants. Assimilation doesn't happen overnight. It didn't for your own ancestors, either.

Not really. Very few immigrants in the early 20th century failed to learn at least spoken English. Relatively few passed their native tongue to the next generation.

According to this, those German and Polish immigrants have passed down their language:

Did you even look at that map? Italian and German and Polish immigrants were concentrated in the NE cities. Those areas on the map are not showing that European immigrants kept their language.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Scandinavians have amazing social services. They don't worry about healthcare, retirement or college costs.

That is because of the homogenous society - shared values, shared culture, everyone pays into the system.
A country cannot have these nice things if there is unlimited illegal immigration, people that do not pay into the system and divergent cultures.
I know that vexes a lot of progressives, but there a lot to be said about homogeneity.

Where do you get this weird notion that immigrants to Scandinavia aren't paying in?

All four of them? Maybe they are.

Since Biden the US has had more illegal immigrants flooding in than most of the total population of some of these countries. And I know for a fact that those immigrants have not paid into the system and are getting US tax dollar resources.

And that is why we cannot have nice things for our society.

Can you read, honey? Because I posted above that Norway has had about a million immigrants in the last ten years and their total population is 5.6 million. So that’s not “four” immigrants, is it?

We can’t have nice things for our society because billionaires have everything in our society and you’re dumb enough to fight the poorest, most desperate people for the scraps when your own ancestors were those poor, desperate people not that long ago.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Scandinavians have amazing social services. They don't worry about healthcare, retirement or college costs.

That is because of the homogenous society - shared values, shared culture, everyone pays into the system.
A country cannot have these nice things if there is unlimited illegal immigration, people that do not pay into the system and divergent cultures.
I know that vexes a lot of progressives, but there a lot to be said about homogeneity.

Where do you get this weird notion that immigrants to Scandinavia aren't paying in?

All four of them? Maybe they are.

Since Biden the US has had more illegal immigrants flooding in than most of the total population of some of these countries. And I know for a fact that those immigrants have not paid into the system and are getting US tax dollar resources.

And that is why we cannot have nice things for our society.

Please cite your sources.

[Anonymous]

Diversity is the most important factor in any country’s economic success. Look at postwar Japan and Germany and present day Korea and China and Taiwan. So, so diverse. Just oozing multiculturalism.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Diversity is the most important factor in any country’s economic success. Look at postwar Japan and Germany and present day Korea and China and Taiwan. So, so diverse. Just oozing multiculturalism.

Or the US which has been mongrel since its founding.

[Anonymous]

Contrary to popular belief, America’s melting pot fostered a truly diverse country—beyond race or ethnicity to include religion, free speech, rule of law, human rights, and less rigid societal norms. While we aren’t perfect, we are better than the rest when it comes to living in a diverse society.

European and Scandinavian countries simple aren’t. And it’s widely known they are struggling with even minimal immigration. They’ve literally acknowledged it.

Their awesome safety net and social benefits only work when you have a set number of people who are equipped to work and fully participate in their well-oiled machine. Long story short: not all refugees or immigrants can plug into that system…and some don’t want to. Because they aren’t used to diversity (particularly in terms of religion or societal norms…including equality and more specifically gender equality), they really struggle.

Like it or not, America already went through a racial reckoning during the civil rights era. And the constant flow of immigrants to our nation fueled noticeable diversity for generations. Simply put: most of us grew up in diverse areas and are used to it. NBD.

But even America isn’t a monolith. While the DC metro area is super diverse…and most of us think it’s weird to be someplace that is 100% white…large swaths of our country are only really seeing measurable diversity now. Ever popped into a Walmart in rural Delaware and noticed the large uptick in Latinos? Know anyone in DE…black or white…who laments the noticeable change? It’s a thing. Towns like that are just beginning their growing pains/reckoning with their new normal.

The open racism abroad is something that Americans don’t realize.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Scandinavians have amazing social services. They don't worry about healthcare, retirement or college costs.

That is because of the homogenous society - shared values, shared culture, everyone pays into the system.
A country cannot have these nice things if there is unlimited illegal immigration, people that do not pay into the system and divergent cultures.
I know that vexes a lot of progressives, but there a lot to be said about homogeneity.

Where do you get this weird notion that immigrants to Scandinavia aren't paying in?

All four of them? Maybe they are.

Since Biden the US has had more illegal immigrants flooding in than most of the total population of some of these countries. And I know for a fact that those immigrants have not paid into the system and are getting US tax dollar resources.

And that is why we cannot have nice things for our society.

Please cite your sources.

If you're here illegally, how can you legally pay into the system without a work permit?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Scandinavians have amazing social services. They don't worry about healthcare, retirement or college costs.

That is because of the homogenous society - shared values, shared culture, everyone pays into the system.
A country cannot have these nice things if there is unlimited illegal immigration, people that do not pay into the system and divergent cultures.
I know that vexes a lot of progressives, but there a lot to be said about homogeneity.

Where do you get this weird notion that immigrants to Scandinavia aren't paying in?

All four of them? Maybe they are.

Since Biden the US has had more illegal immigrants flooding in than most of the total population of some of these countries. And I know for a fact that those immigrants have not paid into the system and are getting US tax dollar resources.

And that is why we cannot have nice things for our society.

Please cite your sources.

If you're here illegally, how can you legally pay into the system without a work permit?

DP. Answer the PP's question. Nobody here is interested in your random opinion. Cite an actual source showing specific details of how many are in Sweden illegally and what percentage are paying in.