I lived in Arlington in my early 20s. The supply of housing has not kept up with population growth. We need more housing. This is a way to get it. |
I don’t think this will happen. I think people will continue to want Arlington for their commutes, or being near amenities, etc. Many of us may go private (like our family). But Arlington is still going to be desirable. |
I did too …in an apartment! Then I worked hard to buy my first small house, worked even longer and harder, sold that house and bought a bigger one. I was not entitled and thought I deserved to be able to buy a house when I was 20 something in Arlington. Can you imagine 20 something struggling actors thinking they should be able to buy a home in Beverly Hills? Some people have really lost touch. |
For many people, the dream of owning a SFH is about being on a quiet, peaceful street relatively free of density, not one clogged with cars and people. If people want density, they choose a townhouse or condo. Make no mistake, many people's property values will be negatively impacted. It's like when you're considering buying a house, but the one next door has all the hallmarks of being inhabited by a hoarder (stuff all over the lawn and backyard, poorly cared for) -- you take a pass and wait for something better to come along. No different here. |
NP here. I wish the units weren’t inevitably going to end up rentals, but I’m also excited to get something other than ridiculously oversized $2m+ McMansions. Honestly, these giant 6+ bedroom homes are just hideous and I don’t want all my neighbors to be big law partners. Tearing down all the old housing stock and replacing it with homes larger than the average household needs is also just not sustainable nor a good use of limited land. I would have liked MM to be a bit more tailored (no more than a triplex to avoid ending up with a glut of 1-2 bedroom rentals) and maybe even a limit on renting it for the first decade so that it has to go to an owner occupant. I’d love for there to be more starter homes around me for young families. |
Yesterday I literally had someone tell me they chose a SFH in Arlington bc it reminded them of a “city.” The home buying demographic is changing. People are valuing different things. |
Is this actually true? My friend was apartment hunting in Arlington recently, and there were tons of available units in every building. And it seems like there are more giant apartment buildings still getting built. However, the prices for many of these units are probably out of reach to many people. Not clear that it will be any better with this 6-plexes. They're not rent controlled. |
Anyone who bought a SFH in Arlington for a quiet, peaceful street free from density was delusional. I bought a SFH here (N Arlington) in 2018 and have always known that the county wanted more density. The density is part of what gets us all the amenities around here. If you want quiet and no cars/people on the streets, move outside the beltway. |
Yes, I am an owner. I will address your points in turn. (1) Property value growth: I don't see how this decreases my property value. My house likely will be a teardown in any event (it's a perfectly nice house, that's just the way the wind is blowing). A developer will pay more to build more. And if I time the sale when a next-door neighbor sells, even better. (2) Cars, children, dogs: Many of my current neighbors have more cars than people living in the house, despite the fact that my house is near public transportation. By contrast, a young couple who just moved into the neighborhood share a car. Young couples are the likelier demographic for multi-family, so I don't see there being vastly more cars. Only time will tell how Gen Z approaches parenthood (I can see 2 of my 3 children choosing to forgo parenthood), so the children aspect is a question mark. There will definitely be more dogs. |
And sometimes you buy a house and then a hoarder moves next door. Neighborhoods aren’t frozen in time. |
Agree. I’m a McMansion owner, I guess. I don’t think it’s my right to live in a major metropolitan area, next to our nation’s capitol, and walkable to transit (most if not all neighborhoods are near a bus line) without neighbors in multi-family housing. I would prefer these units to be owner-occupied, but that outcome can’t be legislated. So here we are. |
I bought a SFH in Arlington in 2008 because it was more urban than other nearby areas. I wanted something walkable and near transit. I actually don't know many people who moved to Arlington for "quiet." People looking for quiet and privacy tend to move further out IME. I would love it if increased density led to better restaurants and shopping on Langston Blvd in Cherrydale. Fingers crossed. |
Neither of my Arlington-raised 20- something children own cars. I agree that the priorities of young people have changed. |
I like you. I hope I know you IRL. 🙂 |
Some of us built these homes because that was what the code incentivized as the maximum way to make a profit. And that’s what the MM developers will do. I just wanted to point that out. The McMansion is a natural result of the former code and the EHO changes will also lead to people maximizing profit on a particular parcel. There’s nothing immoral about a McMansion and the EHOs will look the same, scale-wise. |