
I think there’s a lot of projection involved in ascribing those characteristics to the recently admitted classes, given that there’s so little in the new process to bring them to the forefront, but I guess it sounds better than just saying TJ now has less well prepared entering classes. |
I know they've done an amazing job improving the process and detoxifying TJ. |
The actual data tells another story... The bottom line is they're selecting the very top kids before they were simply picking those who could afford to buy test answers. |
This is false. TJ needed to offer universal tutoring to the first class admitted with the new standards. |
You mean prep > IQ |
Yes, the new admissions has resulted in a much stronger cohort. Sure, a few kids weren't Algerbra 2 or prepped out the gills but they were overall much brighter than many who were only able to sneak in because the extensive prep made them present as gifted when in fact they were average kids. At least with the new system you get the top kids from each school instead of 3rd rate preppers from wealthy areas. |
Puhlease. Top kids from each school does not equal top kids in the county. Oh, and it’s top kids from each school who apply, not all top kids. |
They wouldn’t have the data yet to tell a story, which indicates that you’re invested in a specific narrative without regard to the facts. |
dog whistle for lowering the percentage of Asians. So much hate. |
#backdoorKaren |
If these kids were average, then why TJ consistently ranked # 1 in nation? |
Who is it that’s hating on the asians? |
You mean cheating and prep > IQ |
I’m the PP you’re responding to. Yes, I think prep is less of a problem with essays. Good writing is a combination of talent and practice—it’s not something that can be learned overnight through a prep class. And if anything, I think prep classes for writing can be counterproductive. Whoever is screening the essays probably has to read hundreds of them (assuming multiple people screen the thousands of essays that are submitted). Out of that pile, you’ve got to find the essays that stand out in a good way. And there will be some that will stand out. The problem with prep classes is that they teach people to write in the same way (“follow our four-step approach to this essay problem”)—which means that the essays all look the same. If your goal is to stand out, it doesn’t make sense to write in a formulaic way that looks just like everyone else’s essay based on what you learned in a class. |
Different poster. I have a child that can write in the most beautiful and intricate of ways. Writing helps anyone, but this is a stem school. |