Favorite Jane Austen?

[Anonymous]

Agree with other that Persuasion is the best one. Though I actually have a soft spot for Mansfield Park and I kind of adore Emma for her deep flaws and sometimes lack of self-awareness. It's easy for me to see why that one got adapted for Clueless. I also like the Gwyneth Paltrow version. The more recent film was to slow with its pacing, and I think poorly cast, though I like Anna Taylor-Joy in Queen's Gambit.

[Anonymous]

Wow so much love for persuasion! The only two I really love are Pride and Prejudice (fav) and Emma.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I just finished the Jane Austen Book Club and there is so much discussion about this! Did anyone else read that?

I would start with Pride & Prejudice and see what you think.

I have read it but a while ago! Did you like it? I remember finding a couple characters very frustrating.

[Anonymous]

I think Sense and Sensibility is my favorite.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Persuasion. It's also the best movie adaptation.

Persuasion is the best by far IMO. But I have the opposite opinion on the movie adaptations. I hate them all, and I’m hoping I’ll get one good one before I die.

Even the Ang Lee Sense and Sensibility? That was so well done.

I loved that film. His direction and Emma Thomason’s script were both close to perfect, I thought.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I love Sense and Sensibility. It's the most explicitly anti sentimental of her novels.

Yes!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Persuasion. It's also the best movie adaptation.

Persuasion is the best by far IMO. But I have the opposite opinion on the movie adaptations. I hate them all, and I’m hoping I’ll get one good one before I die.

You didn’t like the 1995 movie? I thought it was pretty good.

https://youtu.be/lYSHAyODiGs

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Persuasion. It's also the best movie adaptation.

Persuasion is the best by far IMO. But I have the opposite opinion on the movie adaptations. I hate them all, and I’m hoping I’ll get one good one before I die.

You didn’t like the 1995 movie? I thought it was pretty good.

https://youtu.be/lYSHAyODiGs

Nope, didn’t love it.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I just finished the Jane Austen Book Club and there is so much discussion about this! Did anyone else read that?

I would start with Pride & Prejudice and see what you think.

I have read it but a while ago! Did you like it? I remember finding a couple characters very frustrating.

That's the point! Most of her characters are a pain in the ass in some way. The payoff of her books is when the characters find true love despite being a PITA!

[Anonymous]

Austen isn’t really my cup of tea, but I have a soft spot for Persuasion.

[Anonymous]

Pride & Prejudice then Sense & Sensibility

[Anonymous]

2007 Persuasion movie is great.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:2007 Persuasion movie is great.

The one with the worst movie kiss of all time?! Sally Hawkins went in teeth first at a snail’s pace…oh, I cringe every time I see it. But I do like Anthony Head as Sir Walter.

[Anonymous]

In order:

P&P - most accessible
Persuasion - short, good if you got married on the later side
Emma - long, good if you like mysteries
Mansfield Park - long, hero and heroine are boring but the Crawford siblings are awesome
Northanger Abbey - not bad, but somewhat immature
S&S - melodramatic