Ah, the fallacy of relative privation. |
Bit of a difference, don't you think? The athletes aren't characters in a story that may or may not be relatable to you. The whole reason we are seeing more stories with gays, lesbians, etc. is because of a lack of representation in the past. But the converse of that is that a straight, married man might not find those characters to be relatable. That's not bigotry. It's entertainment and it doesn't interest him because he can't relate. That's all. |
Most of the network drama shows have been absolutely bending over backwards to write whatever the latest identity/left wing politics into their plots, often in just cringy ways. Shows like Seinfeld were huge successes because of the strength of their writers and cast, but could never be cast today. (Or for that matter written...) Just imagine trying to pitch a show about a group of straight white friends in NYC. ...but the average American could relate and got the humor. |
+1 Does he have a problem with the same scenarios in real life? When it’s not about just white men? Omg disgusting. |
It isn't just a question of whether audiences can relate, though that is certainly a part of it. Every casting decision, every plot line, everything single thing is now being scrutinized for conformity with political correctness. Sorry, but that just doesn't promote good writing, nor the best acting. |
Even so, can you not just roll with it? Maybe she's only now starting to put it together in her head that the problem is values-related and her writing reflects that. Maybe she posted right after it happened so was still agitated when she wrote. Can you just presume that the writing is a reflection of her confusion about this and that's why she's seeking advice? |
Well, no. That's not true at all. What a strange take. (I'm the pp who says it's understandable that a straight white man not relate to lesbian characters, but this notion that every Hollywood decision is contorted for political correctness is baseless). |
It's not about being racist or white. She is just blaming him and using any excuse she can to make it stick. Playing the race card is pathetic. |
I can't watch tv with my husband because he's in prison. Try that. |
Maybe she is just realizing she is a lesbian? It’s happens. She is drawn to these types of shows because they represent what she has repressed for so many years. This is why she identifies so intensely with the show and characters? Her husband’s rejection of the show is a rejection of herself. |
Some shows are better than others with this. They include diverse characters without making a fuss about it. (No particular rhyme or reason, but one that came to mind was Deadpool 2.) Others have more of a HEY LOOK AT US BEING DIVERSE vibe. |
Well, my husband is dead! Clearly I win the false equivalency award. But I do think he'd enjoy watching 'Bosch' with me. There's enough butch straight-guy stuff like banging hot young women and shoot-outs, along with lesbian cops, black people in positions of power and young male hustlers to make it sizzle. |
If you're gay or a person of color, it also gets old pretty quickly to watch shows about straight white people all the time. Minorities are not existing at you. The fact that you take their presence in a show as "being lectured" speaks volumes about you. |
The demographics of America have changed significantly since the early 90s. The white population is in decline. These showrunners know what's up, even if you don't. |
The fact that diverse characters ste present doesn’t make me feel lectured to. Will and Grace may have been mostly about white people, but they definitely weren’t all straight, and it didn’t feel like a lecture. They were characters who happened to be gay, but the show was just about them living their lives. Sense8 was a great show that was just about a bunch of people, who happened to be very diverse (and celebrated that diversity), in a premise which may have been a nightmare for the characters, but was entertaining for the audience. Compare a show like Girlfriends to Different Strokes. Different Strokes is more the type to lecture about diversity (but at least it was designed with that goal in mind), while Girlfriends was an entertaining show with a diverse cast. While I enjoyed Different Strokes and afternoon specials back in the day when I’d come home after school as a kid and watch TV, as an adult, if I’m looking for a mystery, comedy, drama, thriller, etc., I want the plot and characters to be focused on the story and not interrupting the flow to raise my awareness. Just having a storyline promoting tolerance does not equate to good writing. I don’t care as much about their ethnicity, orientation, religion, species (vampires, aliens, etc.), I’m looking to be entertained. If I want to be educated, I’ll seek out a documentary, or maybe just revisit those afterschool specials, where the lectures were at least at intrinsic part of the story and not just a distraction tacked onto the side. |