How much time should a 2nd grader spend on homework?
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
|
I find our 2nd grader has a minimum of of 90 minutes of homework daily. I'm tired of it. She's exhausted and it really cuts into our family time in the evenings -- not to mention all of the friction.
How much homework does your 2nd grader have? |
Anonymous
| 5 minutes on a math worksheet and 20 minutes of reading Mon - Thurs. |
Anonymous
| Which school? We only do weekly homework that takes an hour to complete if you do it all together once a week. |
Anonymous
| OP here. She gets 3 math worksheets per night and one worksheet of language arts per night. Plus we are supposed to spend 20 minutes per night on reading. At night she's tired and it takes forever to get the work done. We spend an hour coaxing and coaching. It is ridiculous. |
Anonymous
Reading should be for pleasure. Don't have her do it as homework. Make it part of your bedtime ritual, where you read together with lots of cuddling. |
Anonymous
| 20 minutes of reading, math that can be banged out in less than 5 minutes, and language arts notebook. Depending on whether there is a writing assignment for the notebook or any worksheets in addition to the math, homework takes anywhere from 30 minutes to an hour. That includes reading. The hour days are generally the days when DS is dragging his feet in completing a writing assignment or he wants to complete the entire week's packet in one sitting to get it done. He also brings home an optional math enrichment packet once a month with logic puzzles and more challenging problems than the curriculum provides. It is about 10 pages and he takes about an additional hour over the month to complete that. |
Anonymous
| OP, what school or school system is your child at? |
Anonymous
| reading, maybe 1-3 math worksheets a week that take about 5 minutes. Occasional (rarely) test study and optional word study homework. |
Anonymous
| We are in Fairfax at an elementary school. I'd prefer not to mention the specific school as I'm trying to get the teacher to change the expectation. |
Anonymous
We do this, but my child is dyslexic, so it is hard for her. |
Anonymous
That's outrageous. Parents need to complain and make this type of thing stop. So damaging. If more parents and teachers got together, armed with all the research about how ridiculous it is for a second grader to be doing homework like this, things could change. My husband is a professor of education, and in a very nice, disarming, cooperative way, basically said, we're not having our first grader do these piles of crap worksheets all week. No one advocating that it's a good idea for your daughter to spend her time this way has a leg to stand on. Sometimes it's actually this vicious cycle of teachers needing to give more homework to placate parents who think more homework equals more learning, more hard work, and more discipline. It's just wrong. |
Anonymous
| My 2nd graders is in APS and his teacher said no more than 20 minutes. If it takes longer than that, stop. He usually has 1 math worksheet and word study. Word study changes each night - one night it is writing sentences using the words, one night it is drawing pictures using the words, one night it is putting the words on a worksheet in the correct column based on vowel sound, etc. |
Anonymous
|
We have 5 minutes spelling and 25 min reading each evening. math HW and reading report once a week.
I feel we have too little math so I send my DC to Kumon this month. |
Anonymous
OP here. I would be fine if this were the policy. But, my child gets penalized the next day. She will have to do the work before she can go to recess or they will withhold some other privilege. I'm a little afraid to complain as there may be retaliation. This doesn't sit well with me and honestly I'm pretty uncomfortable with the teacher. |
Anonymous
| I believe FCPS has a general policy of no more than about 10 minutes per grade level. Of course, that could vary by child. |