I was the teacher who had the issue with the parent. Not the prior PP in bold.I was posting after day drinking. Sorry, I don’t do that during the school year. We just got really good health news yesterday. The student never completed at least 50% of homework. All the homework grades were zero. Homework is set at 10% by my department head. I can’t change that. I can’t give 50% for homework that is 20% attempted. I’d actually rather put in all of the 20 and 30% grades than zeroes. I’m not allowed to. I think a student who has a non-homework average of a low C would probably benefit from completing homework. I’m a career changer and was not an education major. Even in college, my freshman year classes required homework and lab reports that had to be completed or it dinged you grade by 10-20%. In my first Econ course, you read two chapters a night and took the chapter quizzes on a scantron that you turnedcin the next lecture. Those were worth 25% of the semester grade. Another 25% was two papers. Then there was a midterm and a final. If you were happy with a C tops, you could blow all the homework off. |
OK, but then you did use the 50%-rule as an excuse to actually harm the student's grade. Even if it didn't make a difference in letter grade, I don't blame the parent for making the conversation difficult, since your grading sounds capricious. By your account, the student turned in maybe half the assignments at 20-30% complete, so under regular averaging that would be a homework grade of 25%*0.5 + 0%*0.5 = 12.5%. But you didn't want the 50% rule to be invoked on the partially completed assignments, so you entered 0s for all homework. But even with the 50%-rule the homework grade would be 50%*0.5 + 0%*0.5 = 25%. Homework is 10% of the final grade, so the three options are add 0%, 1.25% or 2.5% to the final grade. You agree, that the middle option is correct, but you'd rather see a student docked a percentage point they earned, than see them gifted a percentage point. That seems unnecessarily petty, especially given the other 90% of the grade was in the C range, I sure hope the additional 1.25% wasn't enough to hold the grade at C. Thanks for clarifying that you're a different poster. It still seems to me, that if the goal of grades is to quantify progress toward mastery of the course material, this student pretty much demonstrated C level work. If a 25% for the homework grade, knocked things down to a D fair enough, but I see no reason to take a stand against the 50%-rule when the kid is already shooting themself in the foot. Your attitude seems to be this student would do better if they finished their homework, so why can't I make the homework grade even more damaging? |
| Test |
Quantification of mediocracy and rewards for little effort. Oh yeah sure, students not doing work or completing assignments are rocking finals because.....oh right there are no final exams anymore! |
The 50% rule is mean to be applied to assignments that were at least 50% completed. If a student attempted 5 out of 10 items, he could get 50% whether all 5 were correct or not. If he completed 3 out of 10, the student earns 0 under the MCPS grading policy. The policy was meant to encourage students at least make a reasonable attempt. Gradebook already rounds up. 69.5 is a C. If teachers are overriding grades by hand, that opens up issues of favoritism. Which students are getting that hand up? Is there undue influence behind it? It makes both student and teacher vulnerable. |
I am fine with that. |
We are told in my school that any attempt at all on the assignment will earn 50% - it could be that they only tried the very first question out of 10 and it is still 50% |
The principal intern, Kiera Butler, has been assigned as an assistant principal at a middle school. |