Well...yes they are. I don't know how you are defining "National Recognition". They are not awarded by specific regions or districts but on a National basis. They aren't anything special, but they are in fact National awards. |
It’s not a question of defining national. It is specifically the CB’s National Recognition Awards. It’s a specific, named program. https://bigfuture.collegeboard.org/help-center/what-are-eligibility-requirements-national-recognition-program |
| Seems like they set the bar too low. A B+ GPA is low for high school and top 10% of psat is also not noteworthy. Basically, everyone who is an NMS commended person should qualify for the National Recognition Award. |
NP at our private school, we have no records on grandparent ethnicity. We self report on college board and then counselor will ask kid to confirm. that's it. what kind of proof would a kid even have? half the time the grandparents are dead. and also the grandparent doesnt have to be born in a different country to be AA or Hispanic. |
| I always though that if you identified as Hispanic (it is an ethnicity, after all) you can call yourself Hispanic? |
Yep. That was my take as well. It may help bright kids who are FGLI, from rural areas, or from lower achieving high schools, with PSAT scores below the commended threshold but still relatively strong. It will do nothing for the kids who are already getting NMSF or commended awards or who are attending an average to high SES school. My kid qualified for the school based recognition award. She's also going to earn NMSF. She's filling out the paperwork because there's no reason not to do so, but it's unlikely that this award will be useable in any way. |
| A hispanic can be of any race. white, black, indigenous, even Asian (think Brazil, Peru, some Caribbean nations with notable asian immigrant communities) |
| How do you know what the top 10% of psat scores are?? My child has no idea if that’s what qualified her. |
this. nobody asks for "proof" |
| Low bar for grades and getting a 3 on an AP point to nothing more than a data grab, fill out your profile in time for us to sell your data for the next admissions cycle. |
I’m assuming my daughter qualified because of her PSAT score. Her FCPS school (one routinely bashed on here) is an IB school so she has not taken any AP classes. |
|
DD is up for school recognition award? What does that mean? No idea if she is in top 10% of PSAT (didn’t prep for it and not a national merit candidate) but did get 5s on 3 APs taken in 9th and 10th.
Does the school get to pick who wins the award(s)? Is it more than one per school? Won’t the national merit scholars just win everything (at our W school at least)? |
But why do you need to fill this out - in the past it was on the college board website |
| The fact that you need to "Claim Your Award" by June 27th - is evidence that this is intended as a data grab for college board to sell you data |
The criteria for getting the School Recognition Award is on their website. Your DD qualified by getting the 5s on 3 APs and possibly also being in the top 10% of PSAT (college board has all the data on both). There's no "winner" - literally everyone in the top 10% of psat takers at your kids' school AND everyone who took 2 or more APs by end of soph year is getting the same award. That's why it's a meaningless recognition since your kid will be compared to other kids at their school. |