Yes. Very likely. Sad. Terrifying. |
+100000 I'm American Chinese and can confirm that in China - you have to be well educated to get a seat in government. Government is considered a respectable form of service - it's culturally 180 from US where people don't think twice about anyone working in govt, more that they hold in high esteem politically high offices. In China, you can be a low rung on the ladder in govt and that's still considered respectable but here, unless you are well regarded politically as a high visibility Senator or Cabinet member, whatever. Americans are culturally, collectively idiots. American strength is in innovation, marketing/sales to an extent, entrepreneurship - all things highlighting individuality v community. So while certain individuals may lean to awesomeness, the collective stays unimpressive. There's a lot of talk about equality and inclusiveness but in reality, American culture is about a focus on independence and "power" in the context of winning - without actually understanding the definition of winning that is. |
They’ll end up with more sycophants who can’t navigate their way out of a paper bag much less navigate international Diplomacy. It’ll be the equivalent of their disastrous economic policy. |
Some people are trying to learn. What does a FSO do that's so special they need their own test? For foreign adoptions? Do they make sure the kid really is an orphan, if you know what I mean... |
The FSO process is rigorous. Multiple choice test. If you pass, written essays. If you pass, in-person group test to observe dynamics etc. if you pass, then you go Thru clearance process. Then after all of that, you MAY get invited to a training class called A-100 assuming there is funding. Took about 18 months from the time I took first test to getting an a-100 offer. (Turned it down for family reasons). Met a lot of interesting people at all phases of their careers and with different backgrounds and politics aiming for it. TBH we should bring back the civil service exam more broadly. Get rid of the DEI veterans preference. |
What do they do? There are 5 major cones and you determine at outset which cone you plan to apply for Consular: Focuses on assisting U.S. citizens abroad with issues like passports, visas, and emergencies, according to the American Foreign Service Association. Economic: Works on economic issues, trade, and development, as explained by the U.S. State Department. Management: Handles the internal affairs of an embassy or consulate, including personnel, budgets, and contracts Political: Deals with foreign policy and diplomacy, including relations with foreign governments. Public Diplomacy: Communicates the U.S. government's messages and engages with the public in host countries. |
Need to offer more opportunities for CS experts to work on FS roles, perhaps in long term LNA arrangements. |
I was hoping for FS uniforms. I’d look cute. |
CS experts ate not known for their people skills. All FSO positions are public facing. That's why we have the NSA. |
How many of those jobs sound like something you need to pass the Gom Jabbar to get? Maybe one if I'm being generous. The rest is pretty interchangeable while collar work. |
Which is why folks in CS usually have to come in and clean up messes like post-managed projects for construction when things go south (and they usually do). |
True but Posts shouldn't be constructing any of their IT systems. Management and DS should both be required to pass some network training classes. But that's not a reason to eliminate AF and the Foreign Service Exam. |
The is a type that does really well as an FSO. And there is a type that makes a career of being an FSO. The first is much more rare. That is what they hope to recruit and retain. At least it has been.
Getting rid of the exam almost guarantees our FSOs will be garden variety civil servants. Think about that for a moment. Just imagine your typical paper pusher hiking all over a foreign country the week after a catastrophic earthquake looking for injured (or dead) Americans. I couldn't even get the lady at the DMV to stand up and walk to the printer last week. |
Like Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, Head Start, ACA, safe food, safe water, worker safety standards? Stuff like that? What policies do YOU think that US voters want? I mean, over and above the millions who voted for Harris? |
So what do you think went wrong? |