Umm no nothing special - it was an honest inquiry. |
Wow. Ok. The fact is, you're making a circular argument. Nobody denies that addicts start out taking drugs because it feels good, and then thereafter lack the willpower to just stop. If it didn't feel good and did not erode willpower, it wouldn't be addiction. We know that. And I don't see any evidence that there's a sudden epidemic of bad parenting (as opposed to the sudden availability of highly addictive and highly available drugs). |
Again, what does your "faulting the kid" really do here? Do you realize how ignorant you are about addiction? If it were as easy as the kid waking up and saying "I am not going to do drugs anymore," then there wouldn't be a drug problem. The personal responsibility required to kick an addiction is nothing at all like the personal responsibility required to say, study for a final. |
Completely anecdotal, but I personally know 11 young people who are/have been heroin addicts, and three were Jewish males. One recovered very nicely, one died, and one I lost track of. It would be unwise to think your ethnic group protects your child. |
Yes, well, aren't you an over-educated bookworm? I'm sure historically, opportunities to make a living/career were abound for young men, and instead they all had a death wish and signed up to get speared or shot by arrows or die of infection in the fields instead of, say, being a Medieval banker or a Dark Ages big law partner. |
And what does your "it's not the addicts' fault!" do? So much. Excuses you, the parent. Excuses your precious innocent angel. You can blame "the Government" or "Pharmaceuticals" or "Schools." You can get sympathy, money (hey, it's a disease through no fault of our own, like cancer! Give us taxpayer money/insurance money). Whether you are entitled to sympathy and money - not my interest here. But I know self-serving denial when I see it. |
You are missing the point. It is well known that teens and young adults take risks that flirt with death that older people will not. This is a desirable trait in a soldier, which is why recruitment in times of war focuses heavily on males in this age group. When the pre-frontal cortex is fully developed around age 24 or 25, people become far less likely to take these risks. You could also look at auto incident statistics by demographic. There is a reason young people pay higher premiums.
This relates to drug taking in young people--even if objectively they know there are risks they are much more likely than older people to think they can manage the risks and that the risks are overblown, as well as to fail to comprehend and/or care about longer term consequences. The people saying it's a choice are looking at it from the vantage point of a mature adult. But it is kind of like saying it's a choice if a toddler sticks his finger into a light socket. (And since you are so literal--yes I know this is an extreme analogy.) |
I just don't think this is altogether true. I took heavy, heavy narcotics for over a year when I had cancer. Numerous surgeries and procedures left me in significant pain for many, many months. I was on Oxy, Norco, Fentenyl, etc. I hated the way the drugs made me feel, but they did relieve the pain. I never felt "high". Just jumpy and irritable and angry. I had no desire to take the medication for any reason other than severe pain. My best friend was in a minor car accident and was prescribed 60 Lori-tab for pain. She became addicted almost instantly. She was a teacher with a wonderful husband and two great kids. She was arrested for forging a prescription and went to rehab for four months. I think some people have addictive personalities. I think narcotics affect different people in different ways. My son had Orthopaefic surgery several months ago. I have a medicine chest full of extra Norco that he didn't need. Like me, he hates the way it makes him feel. He won't become an addict because he doesn't get the type of high that addicts get. |
I have posted here several times--actually have a child who was an addict. Was child ill served by the medical community? Absolutely. But I am also the one who is saying it is the responsibility of the family to pull the child through and that rehabs are generally scams that will get scammier if government funding is involved. We used very minimal health insurance (visit to doctor who gave very bad advice), did at home detox and NA. |
It makes that PP feel better about themselves, for some reason. That's what it does. |
You still don't get it. This isn't a fault/no-fault issue (as far as the individual goes). I KNOW that addicts make a conscious choice to use. I'm not disputing that with you. It just gets nowhere when it comes to actually solving the problem (which you are manifestly uninterested in doing.) |
Acknowledging the personal choice/responsibility is actually crucial to stopping the drug use. You know, the whole "want to get clean" part. Obviously when the addict is a teen with parents determined to excuse (enable) him it's an additional barrier. People like you are pathetic and selfish. The whole "it's not the addicts' fault!" Is actually a self-serving defense mechanism designed to protect your feelings. |
Not disagreeing with you here on risk taking behavior by teens - but your analogy on choosing to get high vs. choosing military service was asinine. Am, however, disagreeing with the implication that risk taking behavior by teens means they are absolved of responsibility. It is still a choice, a product of poor decision making. You can talk until you are blue in the face externalizing the blame, but in the end, your prep school son or daughter went out seeking a regular high and that is what got them addicted. |
It actually does. I'm frankly sick of people blaming everyone else for their problems. Acknowledge that you raised a kid who made bad choices and is now an addict. That doesn't mean he/she doesn't deserve help, doesn't deserve to get better, but it does mean you stop living in denial and making everyone else to blame so you can feel better about yourself. |
+1. And what gets me is the parents who don't see the correlation to allowing underage drinking and looking the other way at things like pot smoking. |