Trust me! Ask your kids it may not be a traditional workbook but everything is already planned for the teacher. Each activity is planned out and some schools are forced to use them. They are some of the worse lessons you have ever seen |
As a teacher it amazes me why these parents believe all these lies the kids tell them. You really think we are doing nothing, even one day? The honors and AP classes are really just made up of the kids actually doing the assignments and the regular classes are 50% of kids that don’t want to do anything and the other 50% do the work but want to have breaks while we help the kids who weren’t paying attention the first time or were absent. |
To be fair, it’s really always been this way but the difference between them is only increasing. And parents may not be completely at fault but they certainly are not helping with keeping their kids out of school. Especially middle school and early high school, it’s only going to get worse every year if you start this |
They really do! I have called parents to say their kid skipped class and they said “oh my child said you weren’t doing anything today.” Pardon? We did a bellringer, independent reading + response, a quick write with our vocabulary, a mini lesson and a partner speaking activity with our new skill. Your kid missed all that “nothing” and will now be utterly clueless when I give them a graph or chart with a technical text to analyze, interpret, and write about. |
Parent here. If I were you, I wouldn’t take the extra time to teach that student what they missed. If they told their parent that you weren’t doing anything today, you can tell the parent that you actually did a lot and then have the kid face the natural consequence of his decision to skip class. |
This is exactly what happened. Funny part is that parents are taking no responsibility in owning what they created. |
Hahahahaha if only we were allowed to do this! If we did this the parent would go to admin and we would be staying after school with the kid 2 days a week and the kid would still miss class. Mine you there is 5 to 6 kids like this in every class that all need different things and I would never be able to grade or even work on my lessons for next week. |
Plus, can you imagine the behavior if we didn’t have work to do? I am redirecting and keeping people on task when we have lots of work to do. If we were doing nothing it would be awful. I always have more to do with my students, even if it’s something mildly fun, because students with nothing to do equal trouble. |
I'm a middle school teacher would love to know which schools are using workbooks and for which classes. None of the core academic classes at my school use workbooks. |
YES. The last day of school isn’t even a free day in my class because 88 minutes of unstructured free time is HELL. |
I am a middle school teacher. Our lessons are not planned out for us, at least not in three of the four core subjects, World Language, and at least five of the electives. There are required standards, but that is a K-12, state-wide requirement. Standards are not lessons. |
I think some middle schools are ysing HMB this year in English. |
My child is in all honors and APs. When I say her teaching team is terrible, it doesn’t literally mean that they’re sitting around twiddling their thumbs all day long. In one case, it means that what the teacher does teach makes no sense. Then she gets mad when she asks the kids if they understand and they say no. Or the kids ask for clarification and she just yells at them for not understanding in the first place. The pacing of the class was also so off that they were done with the mandatory lessons by the end of February and moved on to optional material. In another, the teacher spends more time on stories about his time as a youth than on lessons. Then the lessons are all crammed into shorter sessions and two weeks away from the AP exam, they are not done with all the units, so there is no time to review. Other teachers have been reviewing materials and giving their kids practice for the last couple of weeks. In another, the teacher’s material is outdated and does not correlate with the syllabus. So what they learn and what they should learn are decoupled. When kids are concerned about their outcomes, he basically tells them how he screwed around all through HS and college and still turned out fine, and to not worry so much about grades. In all these classes, my child and classmates are essentially teaching themselves the materials. So after getting home from school, they’re spending hours going over YouTube videos, calling each other to see if anyone else has figured out what’s going on, and then do homework and prepare for quizzes and tests. The amount of work this piles on when compared to the one well taught class is startling. She easily spends 10x the amount of time on her poorly taught classes as the well taught one, and has worse results to show for it. |
I'm a teacher, and this is sadly accurate, but only for some schools and some departments. Unfortunately, in fcps it's pretty hit or miss. |
Different district. I let my kid stay home at times to work/catch up. He tells me that the smartest, most accelerated kids are sicking out, leaving school mid-day to avoid tests they are not prepared for, etc. Exactly what the teacher above reports. My kid is smart enough to do AP work...has been getting 4s and 5s but he is overloaded with school and ECs both (just a few ECs, but time intensive choices). One way in which he is specifically overloaded is the amount of busywork he is required to do for grades. Busywork that takes hours, that college students do not have to do, that means the difference between an A and a B. For example turning in lengthy handwritten outline notes for textbooks in AP History classes. This takes a lot of time and is low value for people in my family because we have very strong reading comprehension and retention skills. I am not presumptuous. I know that some kids need this kind of notetaking to absorb the material. The teacher is also a fine teacher. This is also true of honors math where all the homework must be done and turned in in order to allow extra credit to be pursued. It's just simply low value for my student but unavoidable. In high school the kids usually have more classes than in college and more frequent exams. Sometimes inconveniently stacked up. Taking less rigorous classes is not a good option because they've mainstreamed them full of C students who don't like school at all. I'll admit that since things have gotten so Wild West and there's nothing I can do to better the school environment I just allow sicking out. My kid is usually beaming at the end of the day and is fully caught up on all his work. I am concerned for his mental health because he doesn't actually like school even though his grades have been good. I need to keep his mental health on track so he goes straight to college instead of burning out. We've looked into "the trades". Where I am, becoming a union electrician takes 5 years. It's not an easy out. |