I am likely older than you, but when I was in school we had frequent tests and homework. I also recall a very lengthy "term paper," with footnotes, etc. History tests, were usually short answer, multiple choice, and a couple of essay questions. Our chemistry teacher made us memorize the periodic chart in order to do equations quickly. French had vocabulary and grammar quizzes every Friday. In English, we read assigned novels with essay questions on tests. I recall Red Badge of Courage and Moby Dick my junior year, but I think there was also a lot of poetry. Senior year English was Shakespeare and Canterbury Tales, as I recall Again, lots of writing involved along with discussion in class. I do know we had frequent tests and quite a bit of homework in all classes. This was in a public school in a very red state. |
DP. Mine are in public in the Northeast and usually have more than 20 assignments per quarter. Quarters last 45ish days. |
What’s the value? I’m a private school teacher. If I were to give 20-30 assignments a quarter, many of them would have to be graded for completion. There’s no way a teacher can genuinely, thoroughly comment on 20-30 assignments a quarter. The math just doesn’t support it, unless you expect that teacher to give up all their off hours. And what’s the value? There’s such a thing as over saturation. Are all of those assignments meaningful? |
Most core subject anssignments are graded based off of accuracy, besides a few elective teachers who grade based off of completion. |
Sorry, I still don’t believe it. Even for accuracy. (And how does an English teacher quickly grade a paragraph for accuracy?) Those are completion grades. |
This is exactly the gaslighting that happens in our school, Anytime you have any sort of concern issue, etc.. |
As a math teacher I want to have 20+ assignments a quarter. Mostly low stakes short assignments every day with almost no effect to grade (40 assignments were worth only 10%) to make sure students know what skill they are missing to prepare for the quiz or test in the future. However, I am not allowed to do this anymore and if I make these same assignments ungraded the kids don’t do them or cheat even when it’s for them to know what skills that are missing. |
DP. My kid has a Way ground practice and at least one No Red Ink practice due every week in his English class and he only gets credit if he gets 100% on them. For those assignments, his teacher can quickly look at scores to award credit, but it isn't just a completion grade because it has to be accurate to receive credit. In that same class, he has a one or two paragraph written response to his reading due almost every week (it looks like he had five of those due last quarter). The teacher always leaves commentary on those responses. The teacher comments on the reading content but also on his use of the vocabulary and writing skills that have been the focus of the Wayground and No Red Ink assignments. These reading response assignments are also graded on accuracy. Then he also has 4 summative grades per quarter, two reading and two writing. Those are also graded on accuracy. |
The mandatory SEL lessons are such a waste of time. You always know when there is an SEL lesson or survey being given, because te local shopping plazas near the high school are packed with high schoolers skipping 4th period to grab lunch at Panera or Chipotle. |
My ruby red states nieces have much more rigorous education than FCPS. |
| 7 formative assignments is a lot. Many teachers create really long intense formatives which require a ton of work but then they barely count for anything. It’s awful. |
So you just listed 9 things the teacher actually has to manually grade (5 paragraphs and 4 summatives). Nowhere near 20-40. Lol. Don’t count the computer graded stuff. |
Did I say my kid had 20-40 assignments? Did you see the "DP" before my comment? My comment was to show that teachers can grade a paragraph on accuracy and that a large quantity of assignments can have meaning. My kid's reading responses integrate all the vocabulary and grammar lessons, so everything has meaning. It isn't "oversaturation." |
Yes the big problem is the county is pushing the idea that the everyone needs to get the same education in every class. Which creates a cookie cutter classroom that leaks any creativity. Teachers basically have to break rules to do something creative or really do something to help their students. It’s sad, middle school is the worst, they basically just work out of workbooks even though most good teachers hate them. All about lowering the bar and helping the worst |
DP. Then you are presenting a different scenario. Sure, a teacher can grade 5 paragraphs and 4 summatives a quarter, which is considerably below the 30ish assignments mentioned above. But a graded assignment a day, like the 30 assignments mentioned above? What’s the value? And I agree with the other poster. Online programs, like NoRedInk, have very limited value. |