I was willing to entertain that you folks are just blinkered idealists but unfortunately it’s clear that you’re mendacious liars. I don’t know why you want to change building codes to allow for buildings that are less safe from fires or are so intently motivated to preventing ladder trucks from saving people from fires when they do occur, but these are your beliefs. If you were honest, you would argue that all of this is overkill and unnecessary and that these codes and requirements are not needed. Instead you are just lying. This is par for the course behavior from the GGWash urbanist crowd. I am not sure who you think you’re fooling though. |
What the heck are you talking about? |
Why do you want to deregulate building codes to allow single stair buildings that are generally not allowed due to fire safety? Why do think that streets should not be designed to be wide enough for large fire trucks, including ladder trucks, and that fire departments should use smaller trucks to fight fires? These are your issues, not mine. |
Where in that article or on this thread has anyone said that streets should not be wide enough for large fire trucks? And if there is an innovation that allows for as effective trucks that are smaller and more efficient, why would you not support it? |
*sigh* So are you arguing for narrow roads and against large emergency vehicles or not? |
|
Person A: I think we should have narrower, safer roads and smaller, more effective, more efficient fire trucks.
Person B: WHY DO YOU HATE SAFETY?! |
I am for roads that accommodate effective safety vehicles. And I think it would be great if there were smaller safety vehicles so that we could make roads smaller. There is no logical inconsistency here. |
The fact that you cannot honestly articulate your view because you know it sounds so bad is why you folks are just mendacious liars. Where do ladder trucks fit in? Am I not allowed to have a ladder truck save my life in case my apartment catches fire because it’s against your aesthetic vision? Absolutely ridiculous that this is your policy platform. |
Person A: IT IS AESTHETICALLY DISPLEASING TO ME THAT CITIES REQUIRE ROADS TO BE WIDE ENOUGH TO ACCOMMODATE LADDER TRUCKS AND OTHER LARGE EMERGENCY VEHICLES. Person B: You’re insane. |
So you are just going to ignore what I actually said? |
Yes, it's lots of fun to come up with effective rebuttals to arguments you have just made up in your head. |
How is it that ladder trucks in Europe are a fraction of the size as the US but just as effective? |
Thank you for at least acknowledging your argument. But here is a tip, there are many reasons why the experienced urbanists point to Asia instead of Europe. A big one is that many European companies supply emergency vehicles in the US and as a result, German or French ladder trucks are not any smaller than their American cousins. And yes, that means that all high rise development in France and Germany also has access wide enough for these vehicles. https://rosenbaueramerica.com/ |
I’m not sure what you say is true: https://www.firerescue1.com/fire-products/fire-apparatus/articles/north-american-vs-european-fire-apparatus-breaking-down-the-differences-zsiTPu2O7PZokQVp/ |
Untrue https://www.fireapparatusmagazine.com/fire-apparatus/fire-apparatus-united-states-vs-europe/ |