Honestly, most people don’t know or don’t think they have a choice. The tenant protections we have now are much stronger and relatively new. The whole landscape changed in the pandemic. In my opinion, the city should do a much better job making sure no one is ever put into a situation where they feel illegal rental is an option. They simply shouldn’t exist. But let’s say, someone willingly does it anyway. It shouldn’t stop the city from coming after the landlord. Basically, to apply a reasonable rule (safe and healthy housing), you just apply it equally across the board. You have STR option. I wouldn’t even give you that. |
Asking my question again, for the third time. It took me a minute to check rental license on the property cited above. Why are tenants moving into the rental units without licenses? Can you answer, in the end? Do they plan ahead NOT to pay rent? You believe the tenants EARNED right not to pay rent but landlord without a COO did not? Why? |
Exactly. That’s a fantastic example of what should be happening for both LT and ST rentals. No less. |
This doesn’t require an answer, but one was provided earlier. It’s like asking but why can’t I torture pets? Why would you take away my molested dog? |
|
Because it’s illegal, is why.
Why is it illegal? For many excellent reasons. |
And this sounds great to me as a legit landlord who does have COO, LT, STR and VR licenses for my property. I will have more fire hazard protections and less completion from other airbnbs if they stop handing the licenses over without COOs But I do not think tenants are so naive and rent illegal units because they don't know how to check licenses. They get deep discounts and not paying for your obligations will have consequences. I would change locks and move in my relative into my basement in no time. Good luck with your free legal help and DC courts (which currently have a long wait for hearings to convict rapists and murderers!) |
| Different court buddy. But yes it will take you a long time and no eviction will happen. All they need to do is call 911, break the lock and they are back in, with your cousin sharing your bed. |
|
Agree or don’t agree with the OP but you’re trying to justify the unjustifiable.
Look at the lengths people will go to not apply for a license, including allegedly reduced income (when they have an STR option). That tells me the STR market would shun much of these illegal units; and they have massive issues that would prevent licensing. So we go in circles, because licensing is what helps ensure safety. It’s just no longer justifiable. |
|
For all the self-help evicters out there, maybe read this first:
https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/consequences-of-illegal-evictions.html Tenants, call 911. Proceed from there. |
|
DC allows treble damages and would probably reinstate the tenant.
Liability for Evicting a Tenant Illegally Courts frown on self-help evictions, and may readily award a tenant damages for an illegal removal. If a property owner illegally evicts a tenant, the tenant may sue the landlord for a wide variety of things depending on the circumstances of the eviction: Trespass Wrongful eviction Assault Battery Slander Libel Intentional infliction of emotional distress. A tenant's behavior will not shield a landlord from liability. Instead, a court may view the landlord's unlawful actions as landlord harassment. The tenant is entitled to actual money damages for the expenses resulting from the illegal eviction. This may include compensation for: Temporary housing The food that spoiled when the electricity was shut off The property that disappeared when the tenant was locked out by the landlord Some states may also allow renters to recover monetary penalties such as two or three months rent or two to three times the actual damages. A tenant may also be able to remain on the premises, receive free occupancy, or vacate the premises and collect their security deposit from the landlord. |
|
By the way, to do what’s the harm with the circuit guy. It breaks at least 2-3 tenant rights in the DC bill of rights. Plus I’m sure it’s not safe.
Finally, if your place is so great and so is the rent, why don’t you spend a few hundred bucks to fix it? Or are there other things too? |
True. In a recent DC Superior Court case (2020), the judge ordered the landlord to hand over the keys there and then to the tenant. That’s now a precedent. Look it up. |
|
It was a lock change situation. Tenant was given the keys back the day of hearing.
Why is any of this worth it, illegal “landlords”? Isn’t it easier to not be a criminal slumlord? |
Except here's the think: we don't care about potential eviction problems either. We don't bring on tenants with an eye towards evicting them. We've never had a single problem with a single tenant, ever, and nor have they with us. So you're not getting through to anyone. Bruh. |
| You will though. It’s just a matter of time. |