Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:If national team pools aren't subjective and political, can someone explain how the top rated and high performing NY Red Bulls 2009's MLS Next team doesn't have a single player going to this camp?
Also, of this isn't the kid from Achilles that made the Bundesliga, then he must already be in Germany and unavailable?
What about the kids who were too good for DCUA and went to Barca and out West to better academies etc? How come they didn't make it?
So confusing
Kid from Achilles didn't make the Bundesliga. He's in the youth academy of a Bundesliga team. Very different. International players usually don't show up in domestic camps unless there is an international tournament or competition coming up. U16s don't have that right now but even if they did, I don't think that particular player would make the cut. He's had the exposure.
Kids make a usynt camp for many reasons. Some make it due to politics like has been discussed here already. Other times, the players make it because they have built a buzz through scouts and elsewhere and the usynt coaching staff want to see them against the top players to compare. Sometimes players are that good.
Sometimes players don't make it because they have been in camps in the past and either coaches were unimpressed then or they are a known commodity and there is no need to bring them in again to evaluate so another player gets a spot. This could be the case with some of the red bulls 2009s. The camps are to evaluate as many kids as possible to get the best 20-30 kids in our country. So very few kids are going to make every camp. Every players path is different and every scout or team sees different things in players.
Players that left DCU to go elsewhere didn't make the roster because either they didn't have the right politics, timing, good enough play at the right moments, and maybe they just didn't have the talent to make it. Maybe they just weren't good enough for this player pool in this moment. Lots of good players left off. We are talking about the top 22-50 players in the USA. Not the DMV. The bar is pretty high. Doesn't mean they will never make it. Just not this time.
But what you can see from the roster is that DCU can't put any players on it because it is a dead end for high level football in this country. Again, a local club put a player on the roster before DCU did. In a scouting system that is rigged in favor of the MLS academies. If that isn't enough evidence of how little US Soccer respects what's going on at DCU I don't know what is.