OP here- this is really interesting and not something that I have heard before. |
I even know a Dartmouth grad that did well. |
Does my nephew owning a boat larger than my home constitute doing well? |
Not on your part. |
OP here! Guess I should have pushed basketball harder ![]() |
No, this is a pathetic take...if your child had the chops athletically and academically you wouldn't have to ask the question. Stop being the quintessential club sport loser parent, it may be an anonymous board but YOU still have to look at yourself in the mirror and evaluate if your child is happy or not. |
That is lame. |
If my kid had taken an easier course load could have competed at a higher level in basketball but we told him to dial back as pressure with school was too intense. |
"People skills" was only ever enough to become a mediocre lower/middle-management type. And in today's highly technical world, its not even enough to be lower-middle management, as management is expected to keep up technically with the staff. The overwhelming number of CEOs and executive suite, even moreso today, tend to be those that excelled in an academic environment from an early age, went to magnet schools, etc. The trope of B-students managing A-students is essentially a trope for dummies to feel good about themselves. As for athletes in Ivy League schools, these students are more than capable of doing well, especially with the rampant grade inflation at the Ivies where failing a class is impossible. They get tutors, generally come from wealth because sports tend to cost a fortune, went to prep schools and thus have familial connections. Being an athlete can be an advantage for business schools (MBA), and recruiters look highly upon athletes as they know the student is dedicated and is able to manage time. Note that the vast majority of Ivy sports are esoteric sports that the vast majority of US population doesn't participate in i.e. equestrian, rowing, skiing, etc., not football, basketball, etc. |
George H.W. Bush? |
I think Princeton did a study that athletes did better overall in terms salary and donations. It’s not all about test scores. |
Country club sports do exceed regular admissions on donations. |
These are sports like equestrian and polo, sports that require the student to be excessively wealthy to begin with. No doubt they will do well and donate more after college. Let's compare the salaries and donations from collegiate basketball and football athletes that are recruited from poor schools. |
I know an Ivy full Financial Aid kid who is now working for McKinsey. He was recruited for a sport. I'd say he's doing well. |
Recruits’ minimal requirements are 3.5 HS gpa and 1250 SAT. They do as well as any 3.5 1250 students. |