|
OP, do you understand what does it mean to read on the 4th grade level?
It is not about reading, it is about understanding text which if a kid knows how to read well has no issues with. Reading comprehension is tested by having kids reading a passage and then answering few teacher's questions. Do check the 4th grade level books, they are not a rocket science for average first grader. Being with math on 5 grade in 1st grade would be a problem
but reading not so much. |
Not true. Sentences are much more complex, books are generally longer, vocabulary is richer and character motivations are much more socially complex. That being said, it’s not uncommon. |
How could 30-40% of kids test at 99% on MAP? |
MAP, with working ahead in the early years at home, is pretty easy to ge the high scores. |
Honestly everyone does that. |
...because it's not normed against the child's home school peers, or even Montgomery County. It is normed against nationwide averages, so every kid who started Kindergarten in their first English-language environment, every foster kid who has been in four schools by 1st Grade, every kid whose only enrichment before starting school was watching "the stories" with Grandma. |
This |
You think?
|
Do you understand percentiles? If 30-40 percent of kids score at 99th percentiles it’s not 99th percentile. Duh. |
DP: Huh? I took it to mean that "if you ask the child's *teacher* it will most likely be that about 35 to 40 % kids *that the teacher knows of* are at that level" which is definitely possible in this area. |
That’s fine, but I have two kids at that level and throughout their schooling their teachers and principals have told me they are outliers - they certainly have never implied that half the school is at a similar level. At a previous school we had district wide and school percentiles too which were similar to national. The staff have been surprised at their MAP scores. My kids reading was beyond OP though (4th grade level at just turned 4, reading and comprehension, as tested) but MAP scores were similar. |
The percentile is national. The 30-40 percent PP mentioned is likely for MCPS or the individual school. |
Other than Beast academy, yes. |
But the fact is there isn’t that much difference between national percentages and MCPS. There simply isn’t. |
| We supplemented with lots of free play, reading, and music lessons. |