| My BIL did this, OP, and reports very similar to you. |
| I have my blood pressure meds to the dog. |
| Maybe she doesn't have ADD. I would explore other avenues. |
I really think you are oversimplifying. The focusing effect might be more dramatic on someone who is unfocused, and the resulting change in behavior larger, but they have the same effect focusing on everyone, which is why they are abused on college campuses all the time, especially around exam time. And as for the other side effects, don't we all know how variable and individualized these are? My child, who most certainly has ADHD, simply cannot handle the side effects of stimulants so we aren't medicating, at least not at this point. No one ever questioned the diagnosis due to the side effects. For what it's worth, OP, my child has severe anxiety and all of us were very wary about even trying a stimulant and the psychiatrist was quick to pull the plug (on all stimulants) when she saw how it was affecting him. I thought she would suggest trying a different stimulant but she immediately suggested a non-stimulant route. |
OP here. She most definitely does. Suggested by school-I thought they were nuts. I was in the "ADD is over diagnosed" camp. Had a private neuropsych eval and it's definitive. |
Yes this was my exact experience too. |
One time vs reoccurring is different. If you take them for a while the body adjusts and compensates for the speedy parts. |
Do we know this or do we assume this? Clearly the OP"s child is reporting some of these feelings. |
Here's someone with ADD who reports an entirely different reaction. |
This is a myth. |
|
My thoughts based on my anecdotal experience with family members and friends with ADHD:
Since ADHD is a behavioral diagnosis, I think there are several different causes/sources of the behavior. As a result, different medicines work or don't work for different people. And why it is a hit or miss with the medications and non-drug coping strategies. I also think it is possible for one person to have more than one form/source- so some medicine help a bit but not entirely. OP- it sounds like Vyvance is not the right medication for your DC, or at least not the correct dose. Good luck in finding what will work for your DC. |
| My ADD DD said Vyvance made her crazy. She tried Concerta too. Finally settled on a generic Adderall and generic Ritalin booster when necessary (like driving at night). She finds the drugs to be a necessary evil -- doesn't love how she feels with the drugs but knows she can't plan to be productive without the drugs. |
Well it calms me down - I have ADD and I don't speed all over on those drugs. |
| i tried my kids concerts for the same reason (his complaints) and I felt absolutely nothing, |
This was the line of thinking in the 1990s regarding stimulants, but it has since been disproven. Can't site articles because I don't know where any of my old grad school stuff is and I don't have time to do a lit search. Just about everyone (ADHD or not) feels like they can accomplish more on the drugs. Those with and without ADHD report feeling hyped, yet also calmer because they can finally get things done and focus more. I read some interesting articles a few years ago about the push to make all these substances available over the counter to all, which I think would be dangerous. Back in the 90s we were taught that "It's like drinking a cup of coffee, but more efficient. It is no harder on your body and these substances are not addictive." There's a reason the government regulates stimulant prescriptions these days and yes, they can be addictive. Yes, there can be risks with not medicating too, plus there are many alternatives to stimulants. |