If your 3 year old son didn't know who Spiderman is and you said "Oh! You mean the man in the red pants and silly boots?" Well, then you ARE smug and annoying. |
Not the PP but if you don't own a TV, I think the chances that your kid won't recognize a TV character at a birthday party are pretty high. We don't have one because if we did, DH & I would never talk; once it's on, we just zone out of everything else, which clearly not everyone experiences but for those of us who do, it's not some mommy crusade, it's just a lifestyle choice. PP could very well raise her child without TV. It's not that crazy of an idea IMO. |
We don't have a TV either but my DD still has learned who the Disney princesses are, who Dora and Diego are, who the Super Friends are, who Sponge Bob is, and more. This is all from other kids. |
No, the chances aren't pretty high. Characters are on clothing, toys, valentine day cards, birthday invitations, gift bags, books at the library, glittery tattoos, hair bows, lunch boxes....It takes one person, telling a child one time, that is Dora or Spiderman and they will know it. Doesn't mean they watch the shows but they will know it is a fictional character. |
This is an EXCELLENT idea! Our version will be: drink whenever SIL mentions how much money they spent on X. Guess we will need to stay over a ILs house though because we will be loaded! |
Not if your kid goes to school. We don't have TV, and I'm not a big Disney fan, so I didn't buy a lot of character stuff, but at age 5 my kid knew, from playing with toys, and talking about who had what on their shirt, shoes, backpack and underwear (yes, underwear, no doors in preschool bathroom), and asking me to read him books at the bookstore, the names and a little bit about the characters. Maybe not as much as the kids who watched the shows a lot, but enough to know that that was Spiderman or Spongebob. If he didn't happen to know a character and asked about it, then I'd tell the truth if I knew it "That's Dora, she's a character on a TV show", or encourage him to get the information somewhere else "You know, I don't know which princess that is. I bet (birthday girl) knows, why don't you ask her?" I certainly wouldn't treat a character's name like a state secret. |
The most common crazies I meet are like you, obsessing over what other parents do and say with their children long after the moment has passed. |
sounds like a loser in the making, DD will hate public schools |
|
I am a single dad of a toddler, and there is a mother in my building that I try to avoid at all costs. Every single thing she says comes back around to my daughter not having a mother.
"Oh, look at your pretty yellow dress! Your daddy must not know all girls love pink." Then to me, "I know she doesn't have a mother so you have no way of knowing this, but pink is the way to go. Any time there's a pink option, pick that. And if a store doesn't have pink, ask." She actually believes she's helping me. Never mind that my daughter picked out her own yellow dress when we were in the store. The woman does this EVERY TIME we run into each other in the elevator. I have taken to giving my daughter piggy back rides and taking the stairs to avoid her. |
exactly. it's the same way you probably know what Breaking Bad is, or who Mindy Kaling is, even without TV-- except times 20, because Mindy Kaling isn't on lunchboxes. |
Don't let others discourage you, PP. I feel strongly that the stories that feed my child's mind should be of the highest possible caliber, so I am one of those crazy moms who limits media consumption and "characters." I agree it is impossible for most families, because if you stick your kid in daycare then preschool, then public, you lose control over what they are exposed to from friends and from classroom materials. I kept mine with a like-minded nanny, then sent them to a character-free preschool, and they are about to start a character-free elementary program. I know others who have stayed home partly for this reason. I may seem like a silly priority for some, but if you want to, you can make it work. When my then-3-year-old saw Dora at the white House Egg Roll 2 years ago, she yelled, "Look! It's the girl from my pull-ups!" Only assocition for her. She is now 5 and in the princess phase, but the only Disney princess she knows is Merida (an intentional choice on my part). Other than that, we look for stories about princesses and queens who display bravery, sacrifice, leadership, and--most importantly--ownership of their choices. Her peer group is friends from her school and we have had only one princess birthday party so far. Her brother is right there too. You can think this is a stupid or wasteful priority, but if you think it's impossible, you're wrong. |
Well, yeah, it IS actually possible to avoid Dora and other mass marketed characters. And in some countries marketing to children is actually, gasp!, restricted! |
|
Apparently, OP has met my sister. Ugh.
How is she smug? Let me count the ways; Encourages her now 8 year old DS to only have girl friends, as girls are much better behaved and clean and quiet. Thinks school conferences should be longer than 15 minutes - wants to hear more about her child. She volunteers in his class so she can get more info and observe him in all of his glory. And, the most recent: had to leave a family gathering with my screaming toddler, mid melt down. She watched the whole thing and then called me telling that she's never seen such a display and that perhaps my kid was having a medical issue. Suggested I seek help for him. She is in general, smug. These are but a few examples. She's even smug about her DH. |
SAH Smug Mom does that, as well. Incorporates how great it is to be a SAHM into EVERY single conversation. "I'm soo glad that I'm a SAHM, we can have a dog!" "I'm soo glad that I'm a SAHM, I give homemade gifts, they are soo much more thoughtful." "I'm soo glad that I'm a SAHM, it doesn't matter what time the cable guy shows up!" Blah, blah, blah.
|
LOL. DD has been in school for 3 years and she's a total social butterfly personality. And oh yeah, we don't go to public school. |