Is graduating from a title 1 school a hook?

[Anonymous]

The advantage would be specific to Pell recipients.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Yes; it’s a hook.

Yes, but mostly in the narrow sense that the student will be top x% of the class (might be farther down top (x+y)% at a higher performing HS).

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I have a service provider whose daughter goes to a Title 1 HS in the area. She got in early to UVA with a full ride. Same grades and EC at Yorktown might have just gotten her in, if she was lucky.

The above is not an isolated result. It is a very common result, but it is not a guarantee.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I have a service provider whose daughter goes to a Title 1 HS in the area. She got in early to UVA with a full ride. Same grades and EC at Yorktown might have just gotten her in, if she was lucky.

Service provider? Like a landscaper or cleaning person? In any case, sounds like this student was indeed low income.

[Anonymous]

I teach at a title 1 school and every year the valedictorian and salutatorian seem to go to top schools. Yale, Penn, Johns Hopkins, MIT, Vanderbilt and service academies in the last few years

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:We aren’t low income as a family or first generation to attend college, but live in a low income zip code and teen attends large public title 1 school. Will graduate in top 1%, lots of DE and AP classes, expecting SAT to be above 1500 based on PSAT scores. No national awards, but some cool ECs, strong leadership, job, interesting hobby. No one, or rarely anyone, applies to college out of state. He is wanting a school in top 5-20 (which are all out of state). Does coming from a school with limited resources and no one from your high school applying give an admission boost?

Um, no. If anything, it's probably a detriment.

Do you have some cynical notion that admissions officers will look more favorably on a child who has "survived" a ... what ... ghetto environment or some shit like that?

DP.

Completely disagree.

My kids are at a Title I school that punches well above its weight in admissions. Multiple T10 admits every year, even for kids who are not FGLI or otherwise preferred.

DP and same at our school.

[Anonymous]

Zip code is a factor, yes.

[Anonymous]

yes, I'd say it helps

[Anonymous]

Another factor is that your kid probably has more leadership opportunities than they would at a "better" high school.
For example, my kid is captain of a varsity team and probably wouldn't have even made the team if they were in different school. Becoming president of Honor Society or being a officer in SGA isn't as competitive.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Another factor is that your kid probably has more leadership opportunities than they would at a "better" high school.
For example, my kid is captain of a varsity team and probably wouldn't have even made the team if they were in different school. Becoming president of Honor Society or being a officer in SGA isn't as competitive.

This! My title 1 DC was honor society president and team captain for multiple sports. Also valedictorian. In at T10

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:We aren’t low income as a family or first generation to attend college, but live in a low income zip code and teen attends large public title 1 school. Will graduate in top 1%, lots of DE and AP classes, expecting SAT to be above 1500 based on PSAT scores. No national awards, but some cool ECs, strong leadership, job, interesting hobby. No one, or rarely anyone, applies to college out of state. He is wanting a school in top 5-20 (which are all out of state). Does coming from a school with limited resources and no one from your high school applying give an admission boost?

It matters. When a kid goes to a large overcrowded Title 1 school it’s easy to just cruise no matter what family you go home to. He’s a standout and should do very well.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Another factor is that your kid probably has more leadership opportunities than they would at a "better" high school.
For example, my kid is captain of a varsity team and probably wouldn't have even made the team if they were in different school. Becoming president of Honor Society or being a officer in SGA isn't as competitive.

What sport? The only sports that anyone cares about, football, basketball, baseball, hockey have tons of talent in almost every school, depending on location.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Another factor is that your kid probably has more leadership opportunities than they would at a "better" high school.
For example, my kid is captain of a varsity team and probably wouldn't have even made the team if they were in different school. Becoming president of Honor Society or being a officer in SGA isn't as competitive.

What sport? The only sports that anyone cares about, football, basketball, baseball, hockey have tons of talent in almost every school, depending on location.

Not at our FCPS school.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:We aren’t low income as a family or first generation to attend college, but live in a low income zip code and teen attends large public title 1 school. Will graduate in top 1%, lots of DE and AP classes, expecting SAT to be above 1500 based on PSAT scores. No national awards, but some cool ECs, strong leadership, job, interesting hobby. No one, or rarely anyone, applies to college out of state. He is wanting a school in top 5-20 (which are all out of state). Does coming from a school with limited resources and no one from your high school applying give an admission boost?

It’s an advantage, maybe equivalent to non-donor legacy these days.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I have a service provider whose daughter goes to a Title 1 HS in the area. She got in early to UVA with a full ride. Same grades and EC at Yorktown might have just gotten her in, if she was lucky.

Service provider? Like a landscaper or cleaning person? In any case, sounds like this student was indeed low income.

Service providers work with students with IEPs. Examples are speech teachers, OTs, PTs, reading specialists, etc.