| You are correct to research MLS Next over ECNL. Once kids are 14 they should move from ECNL to MLS Next because the ECNL league deteriorates as the age groups get older. The opposite is true for MLS NeXT in the boys side because good players tend to move in one direction(towards MLS) and not the other. |
| ECNL will also offer nothing or very little to your son once the high school season begins because they allow their players to play high school soccer. ECNL teams barely have enough kids to hold a practice, often needing to combine age groups, once high school soccer starts. |
| Have a MLSNext Homegrown kid and it seems on the Alexandria side we are always getting kids joining them in practice. Some stayed and ended up on the team and others didn't. Get in touch with the coach and ask to come to a practice or two. Most teams aren't even practicing yet with the ice still on the fields. |
If your kid wants to play HS it is beneficial to stay ECNL as mlsnext 1 does not allow it. |
Slight caveat. Some private schools, like ours, have a sports requirement so players get waivers from this rule. |
Corrected. With MLS being way more competitive, the earlier you get in the better if your kid can make the team. |
As you can see, they just can't help themselves. Even when explained, they have to compete on an anonymous board. The only problem is that competing pre-puberty is proven to be pointless for long-term soccer development which these SYC parents don't seem to understand. They will send kids to DCU but that is it their peak. After puberty levels the playing field, the kids who learned how to play from 11-15 take over. The SYC parents and kids will enjoy their leather sleeved varsity jackets with MLS National Championships why coaching soccer in Fairfax County in 2035 while kids who have paid attention to the development process are still overseas with professional careers. |
Got it. Can the kid handle the volume of training and also take care of academics? |
|
Looking for development from your club is not going to be successful. Choose the club that gives your kid the most visibility/opportunity and is convenient for your family life. The differences between the 3 MLSN HG clubs are not massive even though everyone wants to claim one or the other is "wayyy better". It's silly. Develop your player outside of the 3x 90 min sessions a week.
Each team has big variations in age groups. There are too many variables to say who is better. |
|
“If your kid wants to play HS it is beneficial to stay ECNL as mlsnext 1 does not allow it.”
MLS has a waiver for kids who want to play high school. |
That's rhetorical best question I've ever seen on here. Wish I had the answer. We'll see is the best I can offer, for now. |
Right. They're all the same. Coaches can be different but in the end, same product, different packaging. |
uhhh not sure how "rhetorical" got in there. Please ignore. |
Over the last 10 years, you can combine SYC, Alexandria and NVA’s pro’s and I think they are less than VDA and Arlington individually. 3 x 90 minute x 40 weeks puts you way behind a coach teaching soccer IQ principles. You are just not knowledgeable enough to know the differences in why certain clubs outproduce other clubs. |
| What is the amount of time a player has to spend at a club for the club to claim that they developed the player? Example: a player spends four years with one club, then two years with another club, then goes to an academy. What makes it possible for one of the clubs, especially the middle man, to claim that they produced a pro player? |