Transgender Rules (?) - ECNL and GA

[Anonymous]

I actually can't believe someone woke up today and said - "Wow it's really cold outside and I have nothing better to do with my life, but go on DCUM and talk about trans kids in sport. My useless post will finally bring important awareness to a topic that has been beaten to death for political reasons, but has no bearing on the actual leagues. My important rant will change the discourse!"

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Does anyone know whether ECNL or GA have any rule prohibiting boys from playing in girls league? Has either league broached this subject yet?

You mean trans girls?
No they don’t
They don’t have rules against long legged girls playing or girls that run fast, or have private training, or those that can afford coaches or summer camps that help them improve.
The playing field is not level because not everyone is the same. Not built the same, not the same opportunities, etc…… get my drift?
It doesn’t matter

This is a delusional take. You clearly do not have daughters playing at a high level.

The odds of being good enough to play at a high level are very small and the odds of being trans are teeny tiny. the odds of a trans player having enough talent to actually compete at at high level are almost non existent. Find something better to do with your time and energy.

On top of that, the player would also need to have the disposable income for these pay to play leagues which is also limiting. Stop fretting about such a non problem.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I actually can't believe someone woke up today and said - "Wow it's really cold outside and I have nothing better to do with my life, but go on DCUM and talk about trans kids in sport. My useless post will finally bring important awareness to a topic that has been beaten to death for political reasons, but has no bearing on the actual leagues. My important rant will change the discourse!"

It was probably someone trying to distract from the VRSC thread.

[Anonymous]

I know of 3 GA clubs that had boys on girls teams.

One actually posted on Instagram that they're looking for trans players.

That club switched to ECNL so its their issue now.

[Anonymous]

The takes on here miss the mark. The OP did not ask about trans kids, the OP asked about rules on BOYS playing in either girls league.

It is a valid question. One likely best directed at the league administrations instead of this crazy anonymous forum.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The takes on here miss the mark. The OP did not ask about trans kids, the OP asked about rules on BOYS playing in either girls league.

It is a valid question. One likely best directed at the league administrations instead of this crazy anonymous forum.

If you can't read through the obvious intent, I don't know what to tell you.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The takes on here miss the mark. The OP did not ask about trans kids, the OP asked about rules on BOYS playing in either girls league.

It is a valid question. One likely best directed at the league administrations instead of this crazy anonymous forum.

If you can't read through the obvious intent, I don't know what to tell you.

LOL - was just responding to your post at face value, but - it's the FREAKING TITLE

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Does anyone know whether ECNL or GA have any rule prohibiting boys from playing in girls league? Has either league broached this subject yet?

You mean trans girls?
No they don’t
They don’t have rules against long legged girls playing or girls that run fast, or have private training, or those that can afford coaches or summer camps that help them improve.
The playing field is not level because not everyone is the same. Not built the same, not the same opportunities, etc…… get my drift?
It doesn’t matter

You think that "long legged girls" have the same advantage on the field as a biological teenage boy? LOL.

I am far from a conservative but this is an insane take.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I know of 3 GA clubs that had boys on girls teams.

One actually posted on Instagram that they're looking for trans players.

That club switched to ECNL so its their issue now.

What issue? It is not an issue. These are overpriced pay to play leagues for talent that has the income to join. No one can tell you anything about any of the teams or players a week after the season ends and rightly so. Find something better to do.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I know of 3 GA clubs that had boys on girls teams.

One actually posted on Instagram that they're looking for trans players.

That club switched to ECNL so its their issue now.

Yeah, you will of course see it if there are no rules against it. The pressure to win is too much and even a trans girl that was a 2nd/3rd team boy will be a top girls' team player.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I know of 3 GA clubs that had boys on girls teams.

One actually posted on Instagram that they're looking for trans players.

That club switched to ECNL so its their issue now.

Yeah, you will of course see it if there are no rules against it. The pressure to win is too much and even a trans girl that was a 2nd/3rd team boy will be a top girls' team player.

Wrong but who cares? these are businesses for paying customers. If you don't like the product, don't buy it.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I know of 3 GA clubs that had boys on girls teams.

One actually posted on Instagram that they're looking for trans players.

That club switched to ECNL so its their issue now.

Yeah, you will of course see it if there are no rules against it. The pressure to win is too much and even a trans girl that was a 2nd/3rd team boy will be a top girls' team player.

haha, good rec boys would be the top players on a girls' top team.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I know of 3 GA clubs that had boys on girls teams.

One actually posted on Instagram that they're looking for trans players.

That club switched to ECNL so its their issue now.

Yeah, you will of course see it if there are no rules against it. The pressure to win is too much and even a trans girl that was a 2nd/3rd team boy will be a top girls' team player.

Wrong but who cares? these are businesses for paying customers. If you don't like the product, don't buy it.

Errr, don't have your girls play GA or ECNL if you don't like trans girls playing isn't a great solution.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I know of 3 GA clubs that had boys on girls teams.

One actually posted on Instagram that they're looking for trans players.

That club switched to ECNL so its their issue now.

You are just making **** up, but glad it makes you feel better. You could easily share the clubs and the post, but you won't because it's BS

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I know of 3 GA clubs that had boys on girls teams.

One actually posted on Instagram that they're looking for trans players.

That club switched to ECNL so its their issue now.

Yeah, you will of course see it if there are no rules against it. The pressure to win is too much and even a trans girl that was a 2nd/3rd team boy will be a top girls' team player.

haha, good rec boys would be the top players on a girls' top team.

lol. ok rec boys go cough up the time and money to play in a girls league. that is on the list of things that is not happening.