What other boards besides DCUM do you use for college info?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:is College Confidential still on?

very underrated. A lot of very experienced folks with nothing better (or worse, depending on how you look at it) to do than advise those posting.

Agreed!!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:is College Confidential still on?

very underrated. A lot of very experienced folks with nothing better (or worse, depending on how you look at it) to do than advise those posting.

I feel like a lot of their info is dated. their college kids are 28 years old

[Anonymous]

DCUM is the best among all forums. It’s particularly relevant for private school kids as there are still some private school parents staying around. It’s also an excellent place if your DCs are working towards T20 schools. At the same time, it’s diverse, having discussions on a very broad range of topics. Because it’s anonymous, we have some snarky comments but at least some are funny.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:DCUM is the best among all forums. It’s particularly relevant for private school kids as there are still some private school parents staying around. It’s also an excellent place if your DCs are working towards T20 schools. At the same time, it’s diverse, having discussions on a very broad range of topics. Because it’s anonymous, we have some snarky comments but at least some are funny.

I actually think DCUM is the worst one out there. The anonymous nature of this forum allows people to say some crazy stuff without providing good reasons/facts.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:DCUM is the best among all forums. It’s particularly relevant for private school kids as there are still some private school parents staying around. It’s also an excellent place if your DCs are working towards T20 schools. At the same time, it’s diverse, having discussions on a very broad range of topics. Because it’s anonymous, we have some snarky comments but at least some are funny.

I actually think DCUM is the worst one out there. The anonymous nature of this forum allows people to say some crazy stuff without providing good reasons/facts.

DCUM is by far the worst. It’s absolutely net negative in terms of value added. I hope no one is taking the “advices” here seriously. Otherwise you’re ruining your kids future.

[Anonymous]

Not a “board” in the traditional sense, but I found AN to be very helpful. I think the most useful thing was that the advice was vetted by a former AO. I thought I learned enough reading A2C and books, and following Yale podcasts that I was able to take the good with the bad. I’m not sure what the overall rate of elite college admissions is, but my kid did very well. I would not recommend any add-ons though. Did not use them and found that most of the value was in the “board” and the Zooms.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:DCUM is the best among all forums. It’s particularly relevant for private school kids as there are still some private school parents staying around. It’s also an excellent place if your DCs are working towards T20 schools. At the same time, it’s diverse, having discussions on a very broad range of topics. Because it’s anonymous, we have some snarky comments but at least some are funny.

Agree w/you

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:DCUM is the best among all forums. It’s particularly relevant for private school kids as there are still some private school parents staying around. It’s also an excellent place if your DCs are working towards T20 schools. At the same time, it’s diverse, having discussions on a very broad range of topics. Because it’s anonymous, we have some snarky comments but at least some are funny.

I actually think DCUM is the worst one out there. The anonymous nature of this forum allows people to say some crazy stuff without providing good reasons/facts.

DCUM is by far the worst. It’s absolutely net negative in terms of value added. I hope no one is taking the “advices” here seriously. Otherwise you’re ruining your kids future.

Question: do you also like to sit and watch bad movies so that you can confirm they are bad?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Tell me!

The "Paying for College 101" Facebook page is a WEALTH of information. Not limited to discussions on "paying".
Search any college on the page and you will get all sorts of great info about admissions results etc.

There is also "Paying for College for High-Income Families" Facebook page, but I don't find that one quite as helpful.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:DCUM is the best among all forums. It’s particularly relevant for private school kids as there are still some private school parents staying around. It’s also an excellent place if your DCs are working towards T20 schools. At the same time, it’s diverse, having discussions on a very broad range of topics. Because it’s anonymous, we have some snarky comments but at least some are funny.

I actually think DCUM is the worst one out there. The anonymous nature of this forum allows people to say some crazy stuff without providing good reasons/facts.

DCUM is by far the worst. It’s absolutely net negative in terms of value added. I hope no one is taking the “advices” here seriously. Otherwise you’re ruining your kids future.

Question: do you also like to sit and watch bad movies so that you can confirm they are bad?

I’d equate it more to “bad” reality trash tv that can also be oh so entertaining.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:DCUM is the best among all forums. It’s particularly relevant for private school kids as there are still some private school parents staying around. It’s also an excellent place if your DCs are working towards T20 schools. At the same time, it’s diverse, having discussions on a very broad range of topics. Because it’s anonymous, we have some snarky comments but at least some are funny.

I actually think DCUM is the worst one out there. The anonymous nature of this forum allows people to say some crazy stuff without providing good reasons/facts.

DCUM is by far the worst. It’s absolutely net negative in terms of value added. I hope no one is taking the “advices” here seriously. Otherwise you’re ruining your kids future.

Question: do you also like to sit and watch bad movies so that you can confirm they are bad?

I tried to entertain myself on how stupid the movies were.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:DCUM is the worst when it comes to college advising.

+1 Tread cautiously with DCUM advice.
School websites, Common Data Sets, Collegevine, USNWR

[Anonymous]

There are some good posters here and seeing more sharing that biggest predictor is your particular HS, but still many that spout of like their experience is gospel for all.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:DCUM is the best among all forums. It’s particularly relevant for private school kids as there are still some private school parents staying around. It’s also an excellent place if your DCs are working towards T20 schools. At the same time, it’s diverse, having discussions on a very broad range of topics. Because it’s anonymous, we have some snarky comments but at least some are funny.

Snarky doesn't bother me. Recently, many post just seem to be flat out wrong or just stupid. Typically goes something like this:
OP: "DS is interested in economics."
NP: "You should check out Harvard or UChicago." OR
OP: "Looking for a small, nurturing SLAC in the NE."
NP: "Have you considered Carleton or Pomona?"

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Not a “board” in the traditional sense, but I found AN to be very helpful. I think the most useful thing was that the advice was vetted by a former AO. I thought I learned enough reading A2C and books, and following Yale podcasts that I was able to take the good with the bad. I’m not sure what the overall rate of elite college admissions is, but my kid did very well. I would not recommend any add-ons though. Did not use them and found that most of the value was in the “board” and the Zooms.

I googled, but didn't find anything. What is AN? Thanks.