The advice was from OT, worst money we ever spent! |
This last comment was not me [OP]. And I am genuinely curious here… is the latest guidance from researchers and clinicians in the SN community focused on ASD-1 to permit the child to perseverate on whatever stimuli they prefer for as long as they prefer? I am not talking about diving in and learning all about ACs, in my instance. I am talking about staring and stimming for hours at the same stimulus and not limiting it, interrupting it, or refocusing the child? |
Good question. My DD's behavior analysts always redirected her to more appropriate activities. |
Have you tried free-building kits with little battery-powered motors? https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=tgKcu_vatdo I would try to wean him off AC and into something more portable and general purpose like K'nex. K'nex is the cheapest toy of this type but there are others. If he likes robotics, First Lego League might someday be a great extracurricular for him. |
The prevailing advice from neurodiversity affirming therapists of all kinds is to let autistic children participate in their special interests, as long as they are safe. ABA-trained therapists believe in "more appropriate activities." The others don't. That's part of why there's such a backlash against ABA. Neurodiversity affirming therapists don't believe in the idea of "more appropriate activities." Children are allowed to stim and pursue their special interests as long as they are safe. |
I'm the PP. The advice would be different if his diagnosis is OCD. Therapists do recommend limiting compulsive and obsessive behavior in OCD, but I'm not familiar enough with that to give advice. I just wanted to throw that caveat out there. (And the reason the advice is different for autism vs OCD is because engaging in the compulsions with OCD makes your anxiety WORSE. Engaging in special interests with autism is socially unacceptable but doesn't harm the child. In fact, it tends to bring a lot of joy to the child.) |
Clearly you don’t understand ABA at all, as this explanation is over simplistic and over generalized. |
Ok the lightswitch thing I understand, but why is it bad otherwise? I agree don't let him do it all day, but what's the harm in using that as a break? |
Except that's the exact experience of many of us had with ABA. But since you're an expert, please elaborate. |
I’m not an expert, I just know when someone is spitting bull. Sometimes I let my kid sit in a corner and play with car wheels and sometimes that isn’t allowed. ABA has been amazing for my DC. |
I'm the PP. The advice would be different if his diagnosis is OCD. Therapists do recommend limiting compulsive and obsessive behavior in OCD, but I'm not familiar enough with that to give advice. I just wanted to throw that caveat out there. (And the reason the advice is different for autism vs OCD is because engaging in the compulsions with OCD makes your anxiety WORSE. Engaging in special interests with autism is socially unacceptable but doesn't harm the child. In fact, it tends to bring a lot of joy to the child.) |
Weird that a post about a child we've never met on DCUM is accurate but overly simplistic and generalized, and not treatment advice for an individual child. |
It’s not accurate. The PP is an idiot. |