Recommend your Virginia winery

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Agree VA reds are terrible. I had one decent Cab Franc only to learn the grapes were from CA.

But I like the atmosphere at Stone Tower. They had food and good rose/whites.

We had lunch outside with some friends on Saturday at Stone Tower (where we’re members) and it was delightful. The wood-fired pizzas are excellent and the view is amazing.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The vast majority of VA wineries/wines are mediocre - there are only a small number of exceptions. You don't have to take that comment personally or peg the person saying it as snobby. It's a simple fact that the quality of a wine is highly dependent on the climate of the region (which is why California regions such as Napa, Sonoma, Paso Robles etc produce most of the best red wines in the US).

That doesn't mean you won't find wines you like at VA wineries, and there are many VA wineries that serve good food and have beautiful scenery. But relative to the better/best wines/wine producers in the US, most VA wineries are weak.

Is Va or finger lakes wine better?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The vast majority of VA wineries/wines are mediocre - there are only a small number of exceptions. You don't have to take that comment personally or peg the person saying it as snobby. It's a simple fact that the quality of a wine is highly dependent on the climate of the region (which is why California regions such as Napa, Sonoma, Paso Robles etc produce most of the best red wines in the US).

That doesn't mean you won't find wines you like at VA wineries, and there are many VA wineries that serve good food and have beautiful scenery. But relative to the better/best wines/wine producers in the US, most VA wineries are weak.

Is Va or finger lakes wine better?

Finger Lakes is mostly Riesling, which is fine if that’s what you like. Virginia has more variety.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The vast majority of VA wineries/wines are mediocre - there are only a small number of exceptions. You don't have to take that comment personally or peg the person saying it as snobby. It's a simple fact that the quality of a wine is highly dependent on the climate of the region (which is why California regions such as Napa, Sonoma, Paso Robles etc produce most of the best red wines in the US).

That doesn't mean you won't find wines you like at VA wineries, and there are many VA wineries that serve good food and have beautiful scenery. But relative to the better/best wines/wine producers in the US, most VA wineries are weak.

Most wineries in every region are pretty weak. That’s why all major regions can churn out millions of cases of 10 dollar wine to sell on grocery store shelves.

and, prior posters didn’t say “most” were mediocre, they said all Virginia wine was bad.

I’m not taking it personally, I’m just correcting the record with facts.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The vast majority of VA wineries/wines are mediocre - there are only a small number of exceptions. You don't have to take that comment personally or peg the person saying it as snobby. It's a simple fact that the quality of a wine is highly dependent on the climate of the region (which is why California regions such as Napa, Sonoma, Paso Robles etc produce most of the best red wines in the US).

That doesn't mean you won't find wines you like at VA wineries, and there are many VA wineries that serve good food and have beautiful scenery. But relative to the better/best wines/wine producers in the US, most VA wineries are weak.

Is Va or finger lakes wine better?

Finger Lakes is mostly Riesling, which is fine if that’s what you like. Virginia has more variety.

NP. We love Riesling and enjoy the Finger Lakes from grad school days! Hermann J. Wiemer is a favorite.

[Anonymous]

I like the Viogniers we've had from Virginia wineries. I agree that most are overpriced, but that's what they need to do to stay in business and I like to support small businesses.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:None have good wine. Agree with Bluemont on scenery.

This isn’t true - it’s just something inexperienced/small minded people like to repeat to give the aura of snootiness. But many/most don’t serve food or full meals.

Early Mountain has food but you’d have to come through Afton gap and up from Cville for it to be on the way back from Hot Springs.

Glen Manor has great wine
Linden has great wine
Crimson Lane has great wine and some food (book ahead)
RdV (named something new recently) has great wine and some food (book ahead)
Capstone has good wine

Another good option closer to Hot Springs is Maude and the Bear in Staunton (not a vineyard)

Closer to the DC end of your trip: Vault and Cellar in Middletown VA… also not a vineyard.

Also, Bluemont isn’t really close to your route home.

And, pippin hill has great food and a few of their bottles are pretty good, too.

The VA Dept. of Tourism has entered the chat.

For those of us who have traveled many time to N. Calf., and have family living there (who lived previously here), the VA and MD wineries, while fun to go to, don't exactly compete on taste or views. It is not small-minded (what?) or inexperience (again, what?) to express that opinion. I enjoy going out locally, but I am not kidding myself that what I am tasting is just as good.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:None have good wine. Agree with Bluemont on scenery.

This isn’t true - it’s just something inexperienced/small minded people like to repeat to give the aura of snootiness. But many/most don’t serve food or full meals.

Early Mountain has food but you’d have to come through Afton gap and up from Cville for it to be on the way back from Hot Springs.

Glen Manor has great wine
Linden has great wine
Crimson Lane has great wine and some food (book ahead)
RdV (named something new recently) has great wine and some food (book ahead)
Capstone has good wine

Another good option closer to Hot Springs is Maude and the Bear in Staunton (not a vineyard)

Closer to the DC end of your trip: Vault and Cellar in Middletown VA… also not a vineyard.

Also, Bluemont isn’t really close to your route home.

And, pippin hill has great food and a few of their bottles are pretty good, too.

The VA Dept. of Tourism has entered the chat.

For those of us who have traveled many time to N. Calf., and have family living there (who lived previously here), the VA and MD wineries, while fun to go to, don't exactly compete on taste or views. It is not small-minded (what?) or inexperience (again, what?) to express that opinion. I enjoy going out locally, but I am not kidding myself that what I am tasting is just as good.

What specifically do you not like about EMV, Glen Manor, Linden?

Who gives a shit about having family in Northern California?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:None have good wine. Agree with Bluemont on scenery.

This isn’t true - it’s just something inexperienced/small minded people like to repeat to give the aura of snootiness. But many/most don’t serve food or full meals.

Early Mountain has food but you’d have to come through Afton gap and up from Cville for it to be on the way back from Hot Springs.

Glen Manor has great wine
Linden has great wine
Crimson Lane has great wine and some food (book ahead)
RdV (named something new recently) has great wine and some food (book ahead)
Capstone has good wine

Another good option closer to Hot Springs is Maude and the Bear in Staunton (not a vineyard)

Closer to the DC end of your trip: Vault and Cellar in Middletown VA… also not a vineyard.

Also, Bluemont isn’t really close to your route home.

And, pippin hill has great food and a few of their bottles are pretty good, too.

The VA Dept. of Tourism has entered the chat.

For those of us who have traveled many time to N. Calf., and have family living there (who lived previously here), the VA and MD wineries, while fun to go to, don't exactly compete on taste or views. It is not small-minded (what?) or inexperience (again, what?) to express that opinion. I enjoy going out locally, but I am not kidding myself that what I am tasting is just as good.

And the CA Dept of Tourism has entered the chat.

For those of us who have traveled many times to France, Spain, Italy, Chile, and New Zealand, and have family who live in every one of those countries, the CA wineries are quaint, but don't exactly compare to the hundred-years old estates that we are used to. Because really, how can one region's wine be good when there is another region that is better? How silly to think that there might actually be one (or, gasp, two??) places in these inferior regions that might have good wine and nice views. Nah, just write off the entire state, that seems easier.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:None have good wine. Agree with Bluemont on scenery.

This isn’t true - it’s just something inexperienced/small minded people like to repeat to give the aura of snootiness. But many/most don’t serve food or full meals.

Early Mountain has food but you’d have to come through Afton gap and up from Cville for it to be on the way back from Hot Springs.

Glen Manor has great wine
Linden has great wine
Crimson Lane has great wine and some food (book ahead)
RdV (named something new recently) has great wine and some food (book ahead)
Capstone has good wine

Another good option closer to Hot Springs is Maude and the Bear in Staunton (not a vineyard)

Closer to the DC end of your trip: Vault and Cellar in Middletown VA… also not a vineyard.

Also, Bluemont isn’t really close to your route home.

And, pippin hill has great food and a few of their bottles are pretty good, too.

The VA Dept. of Tourism has entered the chat.

For those of us who have traveled many time to N. Calf., and have family living there (who lived previously here), the VA and MD wineries, while fun to go to, don't exactly compete on taste or views. It is not small-minded (what?) or inexperience (again, what?) to express that opinion. I enjoy going out locally, but I am not kidding myself that what I am tasting is just as good.

You do realize that Northern Virginia is on the same lattitude as Napa Valley, right?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:None have good wine. Agree with Bluemont on scenery.

This isn’t true - it’s just something inexperienced/small minded people like to repeat to give the aura of snootiness. But many/most don’t serve food or full meals.

Early Mountain has food but you’d have to come through Afton gap and up from Cville for it to be on the way back from Hot Springs.

Glen Manor has great wine
Linden has great wine
Crimson Lane has great wine and some food (book ahead)
RdV (named something new recently) has great wine and some food (book ahead)
Capstone has good wine

Another good option closer to Hot Springs is Maude and the Bear in Staunton (not a vineyard)

Closer to the DC end of your trip: Vault and Cellar in Middletown VA… also not a vineyard.

Also, Bluemont isn’t really close to your route home.

And, pippin hill has great food and a few of their bottles are pretty good, too.

The VA Dept. of Tourism has entered the chat.

For those of us who have traveled many time to N. Calf., and have family living there (who lived previously here), the VA and MD wineries, while fun to go to, don't exactly compete on taste or views. It is not small-minded (what?) or inexperience (again, what?) to express that opinion. I enjoy going out locally, but I am not kidding myself that what I am tasting is just as good.

And the CA Dept of Tourism has entered the chat.

For those of us who have traveled many times to France, Spain, Italy, Chile, and New Zealand, and have family who live in every one of those countries, the CA wineries are quaint, but don't exactly compare to the hundred-years old estates that we are used to. Because really, how can one region's wine be good when there is another region that is better? How silly to think that there might actually be one (or, gasp, two??) places in these inferior regions that might have good wine and nice views. Nah, just write off the entire state, that seems easier.

I’d venture a guess most of these posters have gone to Barrel Oak or Bluemont and never tried to find good wine. And have now concluded there’s no good wine in the entire state.

[Anonymous]

Latitude is not all there is to terroir.
Decades ago, Prince Michel was good. Closed.
Oasis when the parents had it made good sparkling. That was before 2001.

Rapahannock is ok. Rdv is okay.
Breaux is very scenic just get cheese and bread and one glass.
Barboursville is ok if you like those grapes.

[Anonymous]

Green hill has decent (overpriced) wine. I’m not a fan of most US made wines but I’ll keep trying. I do prefer my $12 Austrian, French, and Portuguese wines.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The vast majority of VA wineries/wines are mediocre - there are only a small number of exceptions. You don't have to take that comment personally or peg the person saying it as snobby. It's a simple fact that the quality of a wine is highly dependent on the climate of the region (which is why California regions such as Napa, Sonoma, Paso Robles etc produce most of the best red wines in the US).

That doesn't mean you won't find wines you like at VA wineries, and there are many VA wineries that serve good food and have beautiful scenery. But relative to the better/best wines/wine producers in the US, most VA wineries are weak.

Is Va or finger lakes wine better?

Finger Lakes is mostly Riesling, which is fine if that’s what you like. Virginia has more variety.

Finger Lakes is also home to Richards Wild Irish Rose.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:None have good wine. Agree with Bluemont on scenery.

This isn’t true - it’s just something inexperienced/small minded people like to repeat to give the aura of snootiness. But many/most don’t serve food or full meals.

Early Mountain has food but you’d have to come through Afton gap and up from Cville for it to be on the way back from Hot Springs.

Glen Manor has great wine
Linden has great wine
Crimson Lane has great wine and some food (book ahead)
RdV (named something new recently) has great wine and some food (book ahead)
Capstone has good wine

Another good option closer to Hot Springs is Maude and the Bear in Staunton (not a vineyard)

Closer to the DC end of your trip: Vault and Cellar in Middletown VA… also not a vineyard.

Also, Bluemont isn’t really close to your route home.

And, pippin hill has great food and a few of their bottles are pretty good, too.

The VA Dept. of Tourism has entered the chat.

For those of us who have traveled many time to N. Calf., and have family living there (who lived previously here), the VA and MD wineries, while fun to go to, don't exactly compete on taste or views. It is not small-minded (what?) or inexperience (again, what?) to express that opinion. I enjoy going out locally, but I am not kidding myself that what I am tasting is just as good.

And the CA Dept of Tourism has entered the chat.

For those of us who have traveled many times to France, Spain, Italy, Chile, and New Zealand, and have family who live in every one of those countries, the CA wineries are quaint, but don't exactly compare to the hundred-years old estates that we are used to. Because really, how can one region's wine be good when there is another region that is better? How silly to think that there might actually be one (or, gasp, two??) places in these inferior regions that might have good wine and nice views. Nah, just write off the entire state, that seems easier.

I’d venture a guess most of these posters have gone to Barrel Oak or Bluemont and never tried to find good wine. And have now concluded there’s no good wine in the entire state.

I'd also venture a guess that if most of these posters were given a blind taste test of better VA wines alongside other regions, they would not be able to identify the VA wine.