It really just sounds like they need more practice. They get the concepts, but aren't completely confident. I'd suggest a study group and doing more problems. |
The kid is being taught fine. She's just a little shaky. Things are easier or harder for different people at different times. Learning is the student's job. |
DC says TJ math is harder than what they are used to in middle school. Apparently for a good chunk of students Calc AB is where they stop. About half of the class takes Calc BC and beyond. |
Sure, learning is the student's job. But sometimes that means asking for extra help, doing extra practice, or getting extra teaching. And that's OK. |
It's a stretch to get to Calculus BC if student enters having done Algebra 1 level as we have found it. Geometry at TJ is much more difficult than doing it at middle school. TJ math any level is tough as is, skipping a level would make the next level that much more difficult. To the person saying it's OK to get a B in math, that's being too optimistic. There are a significant number of students that get C especially in Calculus AB, and it the minimum required to graduate. |
Sort of reassuring to see nothing has changed in 20 years. This is how it was then too. |
What are you talking about? Geometry being hard doesn't make calculus harder. If anything, it makes calculus easier TJ Math 1,2,3,4,5, Calc BC (with RS1 in there somewhere) isn't skipping anything. |
skipping Calc AB, and going directly from Math 5 to Calc BC is a challenge for advanced students themselves. Quite unlikely a student entering at lowest level Math1, would skip and enroll in Calc BC. The utmost these students would take on is Calc AB, and that's a struggle by itself, but unavoidable minimum graduation requirement. |
That's not skipping. That's how the courses go. SMH |
It should be considered absolutely normal to take only Calculus BC without AB first. It's hard, but hardly insurmountable. |
In my experience, they overteach everything at TJ, then the kids get 5s on every AP exams practically doing them with their eyes closed. Same with multivariable - in my kid's time, the George Mason final for dual enrolment credit was so much easier than the TJ tests during the year. |
If you do study groups, will the honor code gods descend? |
Some teachers offer extra sessions during lunch or 8th period. Can you tutor her at home? I don't know if it's true, but I heard some kids take the math course privately in the summer preceding the school year, which may be why they already understand the concepts. One problem my kid faced was that their teacher was not one of the ones setting the tests. That teacher even voiced frustration at what their colleagues were putting in tests. Even if she gets a B at TJ, your daughter will get a 5 on the AP exam and probably an 800 on the SAT II. |
I have a junior in Calc BC at TJ. It has been brutal. Kid can’t get his hands on enough TJ test type practice problems. Said the last test was entirely hard problems (beyond what’s required for AP) and he couldn’t finish in time. Kid was recommended for this class with all As in TJ Math 4 and 5. But barely holding a B in BC at this point. Not sure he’ll have one after the final. I wish he hadn’t taken the teacher recommendedation. Oh well. |
There is no point entering TJ with basic 8th algebra 1. It's been a nightmare, remedial hasnt made a difference. If student is somewhat doing well at middle school, stay at base school for good sleep and piece of mind. |