*Actual* smudgeproof mascara!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:OP here - thank you all so much for these suggestions! I've never tried a tubing mascara. Does it remove easily with the usual eye makeup remover? Thanks!

I’m the Estée Lauder PP. I’ve tried tubing mascara before and didn’t love it. At first it is fine, even great. To remove you have to wet your lashes and gently put pressure/pull on them. This is fine on occasion, but with daily use, I was pulling lashes out. Also, seeing the plastic tubes in the sink made me think it is probably bad for the environment so be washing this into water system- like the micro beads in face wash

PP here and these are good points about the environment. I've never lost lashes with the L'Oreal product. I doubt any mascara is great when it enters the water system, unfortunately, and just manufacturing it isn't great either.