Is this flag a Christian nationalist flag?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is the hymn Onward Christian Soldiers about the upcoming Christian Nationalist War?

? no, that is a very old hymn. The Bible talks about how Christians are at "war" with evil in this world, that IMO, would include Christian Nationalists. Ironic, right?

Besides, it was dropped a few decades ago from the Episcopalian and maybe other hymnals because of concern it might be misinterpreted.

DP. It's actually still in the last approved primary Episcopal Church hymnal (#562 in the Hymnal 1982). The only things approved since then are supplements like Lift Every Voice and Sing and Wonder, Love, and Praise, but those don't usually duplicate what's in the Hymnal 1982 because they're supplements.

Other denominations might have gotten rid of it.

[Anonymous]

The flag itself is... controversial, as is any flag that becomes an idol.

There is no good reason to hang that flag outside a private residence. What purpose could it serve?

[Anonymous]

Must be a commander.

[Anonymous]

I went to a small Christian elementary school at a Nazarene church in the 70s and 80s and we had to say a pledge to this flag after the pledge to the US flag every morning before going into the school. I've only attended Catholic Churches as an adult so haven't seen this flag for decades.

Who knows the motivation of the person flying it. Maybe the Christian nationalists are co-opting it now.

[Anonymous]

I’ve seen it flown above a church in my (not DMV) area. And .. my preschooler pledged allegiance first to the US flag, then to the Christian flag in school. It was just one year at a private preK. I only found out when they needed me to sub one day.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Must be a commander.

A commander?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is the hymn Onward Christian Soldiers about the upcoming Christian Nationalist War?

? no, that is a very old hymn. The Bible talks about how Christians are at "war" with evil in this world, that IMO, would include Christian Nationalists. Ironic, right?

Besides, it was dropped a few decades ago from the Episcopalian and maybe other hymnals because of concern it might be misinterpreted.

It's still the 1982 hymnal. Being a military family, we've attended a LOT of churches, and they all us it. What are you using?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The flag itself is... controversial, as is any flag that becomes an idol.

There is no good reason to hang that flag outside a private residence. What purpose could it serve?

To annoy you. Sounds like it worked!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is the hymn Onward Christian Soldiers about the upcoming Christian Nationalist War?

? no, that is a very old hymn. The Bible talks about how Christians are at "war" with evil in this world, that IMO, would include Christian Nationalists. Ironic, right?

Besides, it was dropped a few decades ago from the Episcopalian and maybe other hymnals because of concern it might be misinterpreted.

It's still the 1982 hymnal. Being a military family, we've attended a LOT of churches, and they all us it. What are you using?

PP here. Sorry, I must be wrong about this. I do remember there was a discussion about dropping it when I was a teen, and my parents were basically pro dropping it although they would have regretted the loss of a tune they grew up with. Our church never, ever, sings it.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_Flag

A house in my parents neighborhood in the northeast started flying this

op, do you live in the same neighborhood as your parents?

What do they think of the flag?

[Anonymous]

I think that term was made up very recently, so I doubt there exists a flag for it.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is the hymn Onward Christian Soldiers about the upcoming Christian Nationalist War?

? no, that is a very old hymn. The Bible talks about how Christians are at "war" with evil in this world, that IMO, would include Christian Nationalists. Ironic, right?

Besides, it was dropped a few decades ago from the Episcopalian and maybe other hymnals because of concern it might be misinterpreted.

It's still the 1982 hymnal. Being a military family, we've attended a LOT of churches, and they all us it. What are you using?

PP here. Sorry, I must be wrong about this. I do remember there was a discussion about dropping it when I was a teen, and my parents were basically pro dropping it although they would have regretted the loss of a tune they grew up with. Our church never, ever, sings it.

Ok, cool. So what do you use?

[Anonymous]

I think this is just a Christian flag. The Christian nationalist flag appears to be this:
https://wisconsinexaminer.com/2023/01/13/rep-grothman-displays-christian-nationalist-flag-outside-congressional-office/

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Must be a commander.

A commander?

Not PP but I think she’s making a Handmaid’s Tale reference.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Is the hymn Onward Christian Soldiers about the upcoming Christian Nationalist War?

? no, that is a very old hymn. The Bible talks about how Christians are at "war" with evil in this world, that IMO, would include Christian Nationalists. Ironic, right?

Besides, it was dropped a few decades ago from the Episcopalian and maybe other hymnals because of concern it might be misinterpreted.

Some of the ultra liberals thought it was offensive.