PS They took AMC 8 class the summer after 5th and started AoPS Algebra Part 1 and 2 and Geometry in parallel during 6th. I don't know where the other thread is... I don't even live in VA. |
And was taking the AMC 8 class without fully learning Algebra or Geometry sufficient for your kid to be competitive in Mathcounts State or National level? Didn't think so. |
|
I'll give the simple recap from an AoPS perspective. If your kid wants to do reasonably well on Mathcounts, they will need at least the information from AoPS Intro to Algebra (which is Algebra I), Intro to Geometry (high school geometry), Intro to Number Theory, and Intro to counting and Probability. The kid will also need a lot of experience with problem solving, but problem solving is covered in the AoPS books and classes. If your kid wants to do well at the National level, the kid will also need the knowledge from Intermediate Algebra, Intermediate counting and probability, intermediate number theory, and trig, as these can lead to shortcuts in some of the otherwise time consuming problems.
The AoPS competition math classes are a great review of materials already learned, and they're a great opportunity to learn new tricks for solving common problems that appear in whatever contest. They're not really a substitute for the Intro series, and they will not be sufficient for a child to do well on contests without the underlying Algebra and Geometry foundations. VA is very competitive. Kids who don't know Algebra and Geometry have no chance at earning a competitive score. |
Must have thought that was me for some reason. Funny thing, wouldn't have known it at the time was writing the post, but I actually am the previous poster. Was wondering if this person had access to server logs. To respond to that person, you don't know as much about MathCounts as you think, unless you are able to identify the champion when I went based off the details and looking at a list of champs. |
They scored 18 on the AMC 8 a few months later so I guess so. |
Well, you didn't compete within the last 20 years. For the 5th place finisher to score 20 points lower than the written champion, the CDR cutoff would need to be <= 26. That has not even come close to happening in the last 20 years. Things have changed a lot in that timeframe. I almost qualified for USAMO in 12th grade while merely taking Calc (with Algebra I in 8th). I also almost qualified for Mathcounts Nats with my 8th grade Algebra. That was ages ago. The contests have become so much harder, and the kids are so much more accelerated than they were. It would be absurd to recommend that 8th grade Algebra would suffice for USAMO qualification now, because that simply isn't the case. It is not helpful to spread outdated info. So many people are giving out bad advice for Mathcounts in the present day. That's why I thought you were the same person. In present day FCPS, a kid who doesn't take Algebra until 7th grade has no real chance of competing with the plethora of kids who are much more advanced. |
PS they had just turned 11... |
And completed the AMC 8 class at 10 |
Congrats! Was this the January 2022 test? Very few kids would absorb enough Algebra and Geometry from the AoPS AMC 8 class alone to earn that high of a score. You didn't mention how your child performed in Mathcounts, though. |
Again, great score, but you're grossly underestimating just how competitive VA is. In the latest AMC 8, VA had 4 perfect scores and another 25 kids on the DHR (scores >= 22). An 18 would not be competitive against this talent pool. |
Is there a list of schools that competed in recent years? |
I don't think you could get last year's list, but if you posted your school, someone could probably identify if they competed. |
You picked up on the right detail, but didn't quite get the significance of it. Now that I think more about it, it doesn't really narrow it down completely; I was at the last nationals where this could have realistically happened. |
| I am not convinced MathCounts has gotten harder long term. Certainly recently, but I would have to see the early contests especially the one where this kid had a near perfect score and everyone else was nowhere close. |
| There was a 4th grader in FCPS who scored over 20 on AMC 8, He does not appear in state top 80 for MathCounts, so perhaps his elementary did not compete, or he is now in a different state. |