Forum Index
»
Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)
| I heard a rumor that they would announce test to return, but logistically see no way for them to actually do this, unless they lucky to virtual until they get enough tests. |
My vote is for mitigation measures that sound nice but are not really put into practice, like in August when they put out that lovely note about safety, but everyone went back in as usual and PTAs were buying picnic tables for outdoor lunch. And thanks OP for the laugh! |
| Hogan has a COVID announcement scheduled for tomorrow at 10am. I wonder if it is related. |
I would think that if the Hogan announcement is about schools, NCPS would wait until after that for their press conference. |
The county should be getting 300,000 tests any day now, so I guess they could. I think it would be a disaster, though. |
There's no way they could do in person this week if that's true. We'd be lucky if they could do it next week. |
That sounds logIcal, but as a family new to MCPS, we have seen such a cluster that it would not surprise me if they screwed this up as well. |
I would also like all that, but feel like 87% of what you're describing is due to the existence of a deadly pandemic and/or the poor response of the federal government, not MCPS decisions. |
And in the meantime the school nurses would strike. There's no reasonable way to implement test-to-return without completely screwing over the nurses. You'd have thousands of students showing up on the first day of class without a test. Either you'd test them on site, or you'd have to screen them and hold them for an hour or two until staff could contact parents and get them to pick them up. To make matters worse, the kids that fail the screening would need to be isolated in some way. It would be a nightmare, and the nurses would bear the brunt of it regardless of whatever path MCPS would try to take. |
DP. Not really. The pandemic has gone pretty well considering the new Delta and Omicron variants. We've found ourselves in a situation where, at no fault of our own, the only path forward for COVID is to accept that we're all going to get it and take appropriate measures to reduce the likelihood of severe illness (mostly through vaccination/boosters). Nothing the local, state or federal government could have done would have changed that reality-- remember, Delta and Omicron didn't originate in the US. Besides their obvious primary goal of educating students, MCPS should be trying to minimize the harmful effects of the pandemic on kids. The best way they could do that would be to keep schools open. |
You mean the health techs, right? There are not nurses in every school every day, there are health techs. And it would be ridiculous for kids to come to school, get tested, and then possibly have to isolate and go back home. The testing program would be carried out in a different manner. |
The real issue is people like you minimizing Covid. A child just died in a neighboring county. That child never should have died. There is no safe way to keep schools fully in person. |
Children die of the flu every year. We don't shut down for the flu. Children die in car accidents. We don't shut down roads until new magical safety devices are invented that prevent all vehicular deaths. Schools are plenty safe for students. And they're safe for teachers that actually go out and get their vaccinations and boosters. Further, the logical mistake you're making is that your looking at the overall risk of COVID when what you should be doing is looking at how opening/closing schools changes that risk. It doesn't matter what we do with schools- COVID will remain in widespread circulation in the world, and we'll all be exposed. Probably in the very near future. For that reason, the *marginal* increase in COVID risk by keeping schools open is extremely low. But we know there is real harm to education, and development, as well as students' mental health. |
What did you think having kids was going to be? An endless round of birthday parties? Raising kids takes some effort. |
Can you stick to the topic? Covid is serious right now. Pathetic you don’t get it. |