Colleges that alums always rave about

Anonymous
In general, I'd say LACs, Catholic schools, and the Academies.
Anonymous
Middlebury and Carleton
Anonymous
Princeton, Dartmouth, Williams, Notre Dame and Michigan would be on anyone's short list. After that it's a long list with many SLACs vying for the honor.
Anonymous
Sewanee
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Princeton, Dartmouth, Williams, Notre Dame and Michigan would be on anyone's short list. After that it's a long list with many SLACs vying for the honor.


Perhaps, but Michigan is likely achieving it more through sheer numbers than the other schools you listed.

It may be a different type of loyalty, but I see a lot of loyalty at schools where the alumni have had a shared, challenging experience. This can be MIT and Caltech, but also West Point, the Naval Academy, and even schools like VMI.
Anonymous
"Perhaps, but Michigan is likely achieving it more through sheer numbers than the other schools you listed."

I don't agree. Michigan is achieving it because it is a very welcoming and fun place that still manages to produce very smart graduates. Some people get lost there but most don't and are very happy. The enthusiasm on campus is remarkable not only for its intensity but also its diversity. Whether your final two college choices were Michigan and Berkeley, Michigan and Duke, Michigan and Notre Dame, Michigan and U Chicago, Michigan and Wisconsin, Michigan and Georgia Tech, Michigan and Harvard, Michigan and NYU Tisch, Michigan and Wesleyan, or Michigan and Oberlin--and there are plenty of all of those at Michigan--you're probably going to wind up among the hundreds of thousands of alumni who annoyingly shout out "Go Blue" to every single other human being wearing a Michigan shirt on the street.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:You can keep saying that all you want but it’s well known that UVA gets only 6 percent of its operating budget from the Commonwealth. That fact is even in wiki. So until you address that figure, you’ve lost me no matter how much dividing you do. But actually I really don’t care so won’t be returning to this argument. Let it return to the real question if thus thread.


They are two different things, which should be obvious. Both can be correct. But only one speaks to how much money is received from the state per student, and that is what I provided. Appropriation per FTE is an apples to apples comparison since not all schools will have the same amount of money coming from areas like sponsored research (which largely comes from federal sources and no one expects it to be funded by the general fund). That inflates the denominator, which is how you can get to 6% of total operating budget (but note UVA's own budget summary shows a somewhat higher percentage of over 8% https://financialplanning.vpfinance.virginia.edu/sites/financialplanning.virginia.edu/files/FY2020%20Final%20Operating%20Budget%20060419.pdf )

+1 This poster is giving one of the most informative, well-sourced accounts of relative state spending on public colleges/universities in VA. That UVA has relatively inflated operating expenses per FTE student is its own issue, but they are making out fairly well compared to other state universities. JMU is the lowest, but GMU is probably the least well supported due to the high cost of living in NOVA compared to Harrisonburg.





Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:"Perhaps, but Michigan is likely achieving it more through sheer numbers than the other schools you listed."

I don't agree. Michigan is achieving it because it is a very welcoming and fun place that still manages to produce very smart graduates. Some people get lost there but most don't and are very happy. The enthusiasm on campus is remarkable not only for its intensity but also its diversity. Whether your final two college choices were Michigan and Berkeley, Michigan and Duke, Michigan and Notre Dame, Michigan and U Chicago, Michigan and Wisconsin, Michigan and Georgia Tech, Michigan and Harvard, Michigan and NYU Tisch, Michigan and Wesleyan, or Michigan and Oberlin--and there are plenty of all of those at Michigan--you're probably going to wind up among the hundreds of thousands of alumni who annoyingly shout out "Go Blue" to every single other human being wearing a Michigan shirt on the street.


More so than schools like UCLA, Cal, UNC, UVA, Texas, etc.?
Anonymous
Holy Cross. There's something besides lead in the Worcester water that makes many Crusader alums nuts about their school.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Holy Cross. There's something besides lead in the Worcester water that makes many Crusader alums nuts about their school.


Lol


Anonymous
Between family, friends, colleagues, and friends of my 3 kids in or graduated college and one junior; here are some of my opinions:

Duke
Villanova
Brown
Princeton
Claremont Colleges
Denison
Michigan
Northeastern
WPI
Purdue
UF
UNC
UT Austin
U of Wash
Bates
School of Mines
Boston College
Penn State
Rose-Hulman
Arizona State
Stanford
Davidson
Elon
U of Ill - Urbana
Pitt
Wisconsin
Ohio State
Vanderbilt
Tufts

The ones that I hear Alums or current students meh on:

G Tech
UChicago
NYU
Columbia
Amherst
UMD
UVA
Boston U
Georgetown
Hopkins
Swarthmore
CMU
Bowdoin
Emory
RPI
Kenyon
MIT
Rice
Rutgers
William/Mary
Northwestern
Notre Dame
Case Western
Tulane
U Mass
Wake Forest
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Between family, friends, colleagues, and friends of my 3 kids in or graduated college and one junior; here are some of my opinions:

Duke
Villanova
Brown
Princeton
Claremont Colleges
Denison
Michigan
Northeastern
WPI
Purdue
UF
UNC
UT Austin
U of Wash
Bates
School of Mines
Boston College
Penn State
Rose-Hulman
Arizona State
Stanford
Davidson
Elon
U of Ill - Urbana
Pitt
Wisconsin
Ohio State
Vanderbilt
Tufts

The ones that I hear Alums or current students meh on:

G Tech
UChicago
NYU
Columbia
Amherst
UMD
UVA
Boston U
Georgetown
Hopkins
Swarthmore
CMU
Bowdoin
Emory
RPI
Kenyon
MIT
Rice
Rutgers
William/Mary
Northwestern
Notre Dame
Case Western
Tulane
U Mass
Wake Forest


This seems extraordinarily random.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Between family, friends, colleagues, and friends of my 3 kids in or graduated college and one junior; here are some of my opinions:

Duke
Villanova
Brown
Princeton
Claremont Colleges
Denison
Michigan
Northeastern
WPI
Purdue
UF
UNC
UT Austin
U of Wash
Bates
School of Mines
Boston College
Penn State
Rose-Hulman
Arizona State
Stanford
Davidson
Elon
U of Ill - Urbana
Pitt
Wisconsin
Ohio State
Vanderbilt
Tufts

The ones that I hear Alums or current students meh on:

G Tech
UChicago
NYU
Columbia
Amherst
UMD
UVA
Boston U
Georgetown
Hopkins
Swarthmore
CMU
Bowdoin
Emory
RPI
Kenyon
MIT
Rice
Rutgers
William/Mary
Northwestern
Notre Dame
Case Western
Tulane
U Mass
Wake Forest


This seems extraordinarily random.


+1 I do t even know how you can have personal knowledge of all of these schools - even if it’s through friends as PP says.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Between family, friends, colleagues, and friends of my 3 kids in or graduated college and one junior; here are some of my opinions:

Duke
Villanova
Brown
Princeton
Claremont Colleges
Denison
Michigan
Northeastern
WPI
Purdue
UF
UNC
UT Austin
U of Wash
Bates
School of Mines
Boston College
Penn State
Rose-Hulman
Arizona State
Stanford
Davidson
Elon
U of Ill - Urbana
Pitt
Wisconsin
Ohio State
Vanderbilt
Tufts

The ones that I hear Alums or current students meh on:

G Tech
UChicago
NYU
Columbia
Amherst
UMD
UVA
Boston U
Georgetown
Hopkins
Swarthmore
CMU
Bowdoin
Emory
RPI
Kenyon
MIT
Rice
Rutgers
William/Mary
Northwestern
Notre Dame
Case Western
Tulane
U Mass
Wake Forest


This seems extraordinarily random.


+1 I do t even know how you can have personal knowledge of all of these schools - even if it’s through friends as PP says.


This list is a waste of time to even glance at. No rhyme or reason as to which school is on which list.
Anonymous
I think the best objective indicators are alumni giving rates and then graduation rates.
post reply Forum Index » College and University Discussion
Message Quick Reply
Go to: