Have you ever read it? Incredible descriptions, details, and complexity of characters make it a book to be read, regardless of your views about the south, etc. |
I agree that I love Pat Conroy's books--such wonderfully detailed descriptions. |
Really? I don't get it. After a dozen recommendations, I finally checked it out, and was both bored and repulsed by the first 50 pages. I had zero desire to go further. Is it perhaps one of those books that doesn't get worthwhile til the second half or something? |
I am another one who didn't love other John Irving books, but who adores A Prayer for Owen Meany.
Brideshead Revisited Best trashy beach read: The Last Convertible |
I am not the poster quoted above, but I have read it. I don't argue with anyone who enjoys it or any other book. I also enjoy a lot of fiction that is certainly not literary. However, I don't think any modern critic would consider it the "American W & P" . GWTW is fine as a romantic novel, but it falsely glamorizes the Old South, slavery, and portrays the KKK as a heroic group. It is conventionally written, and cannot be considered on a par with War and Peace because it is ultimately based on a falsehood. Does any school ( high school or college) use it as part of the curriculum? Many scholars around the world still study War and Peace; nobody studies GWTW. Enjoy it a a romantic novel, but don;t compare it to great works of literature. |
Great Expectations |
I guess it is a "southern thing". His arrogance, etc. just rang with me. Speaking of southern novels, I love anything Pat Conroy. |
I'm not sure if it's my all-time favorite, but I really really love The Magician's Assistant by Ann Patchett. |
The Tale of Genji |
Bel Canto by Ann Pachett
The Kite Runner- "For you, a thousand times over". !! Animal Dreams by Barbara Kingsolver- my favorite of all her books (The Poisonwood Bible a close second) I Know This Much Is True- Wally Lamb The Shipping News- Annie Proulx- not the type of book I am usually attracted to but it was soooooo good! |
I also thought A Confederacy of Dunces was laugh out loud hilarious but I've met people who hated it. I think it's one of those books that you either love or hate. Another book I LOVED was The Brief and Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao |
The Time Traveler's Wife by Audrey Niffeneger |
Catch 22. I reread it every 10 year or so and still laugh so hard it makes me hurt. |
GWTW is no. 14 of the Best Books of the 20th Century. I would also recommend, "The Wind Done Gone," fascinating. Also, in my American Lit. class GWTW was studied and was a part of the curriculum. I went to a major private univ. in Pennsylvania. Margaret Mitchell was not glorifying slavery, KKK; she was telling a story about that era in American History. |
golden notebook
love in the time of cholera and one hundred years of solitude mrs. dalloway dubliners reminded me of many others i loved: paddy clarke ha ha ha disgrace allende's books life of pi slouching towards bethlehem my michael wild swans just read cutting for stone and liked that too |