Common app essay and identity

Anonymous
Hearing many private counselors are advising not to mention anything about racial, ethic or religious identity in common app essay given current Trump admin oversight and general cautiousness in college GC office.

Do we agree?
Anonymous
I wouldn’t make a kid live by a silly rule like that. Most kids would also have to hide their first name, last name, address, high school, and/or activities list.
Anonymous
No, there is no prohibition on what the applicant wishes to share in the essay.
Anonymous
We are checking race box after we did not for prior child. Transparency is what they want …
Anonymous
As long as you have high stats, I wouldn’t worry about it. It’s an admit whether or not you write about it.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:We are checking race box after we did not for prior child. Transparency is what they want …

The race boxes don't matter. The application review portal used by AOs does not display the boxes.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:We are checking race box after we did not for prior child. Transparency is what they want …

The race boxes don't matter. The application review portal used by AOs does not display the boxes.


Exactly. The pp is an idiot.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:As long as you have high stats, I wouldn’t worry about it. It’s an admit whether or not you write about it.


It could be a reason not to admit though? If TO? And biracial?
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:As long as you have high stats, I wouldn’t worry about it. It’s an admit whether or not you write about it.


It could be a reason not to admit though? If TO? And biracial?

TO is a reason not to admit, all by itself.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:As long as you have high stats, I wouldn’t worry about it. It’s an admit whether or not you write about it.


It could be a reason not to admit though? If TO? And biracial?


TO is over if you are applying to a top school.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:We are checking race box after we did not for prior child. Transparency is what they want …

The race boxes don't matter. The application review portal used by AOs does not display the boxes.


The universities have additional race box they use for demographics, reported…

I don’t trust anything. Period
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:We are checking race box after we did not for prior child. Transparency is what they want …

The race boxes don't matter. The application review portal used by AOs does not display the boxes.


The universities have additional race box they use for demographics, reported…

I don’t trust anything. Period


+1

We were expressly told by counselor to leave it blank (on common app and school app) in 2024. If they don’t need it, can’t use it then why have a box at all ?!?!!!!
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:We are checking race box after we did not for prior child. Transparency is what they want …

The race boxes don't matter. The application review portal used by AOs does not display the boxes.


The universities have additional race box they use for demographics, reported…

I don’t trust anything. Period


+1

We were expressly told by counselor to leave it blank (on common app and school app) in 2024. If they don’t need it, can’t use it then why have a box at all ?!?!!!!

The race box is used by the university's institutional research office to report data required by the Department of Education. It is not allowed to be used by the admissions office following the US Supreme Court opinion in the SFFA case.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:We are checking race box after we did not for prior child. Transparency is what they want …

The race boxes don't matter. The application review portal used by AOs does not display the boxes.


The universities have additional race box they use for demographics, reported…

I don’t trust anything. Period


+1

We were expressly told by counselor to leave it blank (on common app and school app) in 2024. If they don’t need it, can’t use it then why have a box at all ?!?!!!!

The race box is used by the university's institutional research office to report data required by the Department of Education.* It is not allowed to be used by the admissions office following the US Supreme Court opinion in the SFFA case.

*required by the Department of Education for enrolled students and published in the college's Common Data Set.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:As long as you have high stats, I wouldn’t worry about it. It’s an admit whether or not you write about it.


It could be a reason not to admit though? If TO? And biracial?


This year TO becomes highly controversial. The TO admit has to be super strong elsewhere this year.
post reply Forum Index » College and University Discussion
Message Quick Reply
Go to: