Agree this was a great post (though y'all can ignore me since I'm a public school parent). |
What private school around here doesn't have appropriate HVAC mitigations by now? I think that was one of the first things that was done? Can you not afford your own masks for your kids? The risk of organ failure from long covid is less than the risk of long term neurological issues from Fifth's disease - a common childhood illness which runs rampant in daycares. Data can be skewed to prove whatever agenda you are hoping to push. |
I won't support closing schools unless as part of that you close all bars, restaurants and anything other than the grocery stores and pharmacies Why do our kids have the bear the brunt of this continually? |
Nope I don’t work there. Have a kid in middle and feel like the covid safety has been strong, minimized within community spread, and resulted in mostly in-person school which is the goal. |
Yeah, it worked well with a handful of cases last year and the early part of this year, truly. But with 40+ cases this week, they gotta step it up a notch. |
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-00007-8 https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20211222/new-studies-omicron-infections-less-severe-delta |
What do you think they should do to step it up? Those cases were all from over the break not from transmission within the school community. Beyond testing, masking, having kids eat outside when possible, and following CDC guidelines for quarantining, I’m not clear what more they could do. |
1. You think that private schools invested heavily in HVAC mitigation at the beginning of the pandemic when everyone was still yammering about droplets and hand washing? I have a bridge to sell you. According to air quality/aerosol experts I've followed, the CDC/government/schools are not addressing this topic appropriately because of fears of expense and triggering OSHA regulation scrutiny. Also, many schools are going to be reluctant to bring in fresh outside air through open windows etc during the winter. 2. My kids wear high-quality masks. Many of their classmates are still wearing cloth or surgical masks, often falling below their noses because of poor fit. Many parents simply aren't paying attention. 3. Not realistic to compare Omicron to Fifth's disease. We don't have sufficient time/data to know conclusively what the "risk" rates are. But if epidemiologists are worried, then so am I. The sheer math of Omicron transmissibility is daunting in potential harm. And my agenda is balancing safety-defined as physical AND mental health terms- with assuming practical levels of risk. I want American kids in school, but I want to adopt common sense best practices to mitigate risk as much as possible. Lately it seems that our country doesn't have the will to do anything that is hard or invites scrutiny. Our school hasn't mentioned HVAC mitigation efforts in any communications in over a year. If they were doing a lot, they would definitely want to take credit for it! I know that much. |
Another Langley parent here. We have actually been very happy with the covid protocols. Covid changes quickly and I have been happy to see how quickly Langley has adjusted. Testing every other week in the lower school was reasonable when there were so few cases - in fact, I hoped they would stop that testing for vaccinated students. But, then omicron came and Langley has to adopt again. They expanded testing to the Primary school (did you hear the number of 3 year olds crying hysterically?) and implemented a tracking dashboard. What else do you want from them? If you've got ideas, you should tell them. |
How are other schools defining and treating close contacts? My DS at Langley was in the same homeroom as a positive case so was deemed a close contact. Because he was vaccinated he was not required to quarantine at all. I'm glad for him not to miss school (though the snow took care of that) but it does seem like a lax policy. |
What else do I want? I want them to be like Stone Ridge and NCS where a n95 or double surgical mask is required. My MS child is quarantined right now bc of close contact. I doubt a cloth mask was doing much to prevent transmission. |
There are undetected people who have it now going in and out of schools who will spread it to other people. The travel/holiday churn is over. If people stay home one to two week, yes you could break the transmission chain and we could all have normal again. |
Our school says vaccinated close contacts don't have to quarantine or test |
|
Our DC private has yet to share data! I get that there is a website problem for many schools but I, for one, am interested to know!
I agree that 'close contacts' are an issue. Some folks at our school either don't understand the significance or don't care. I can't think of other rationales. |
They've heard the feedback. We can start a list here: 1. If there's active covid cases in your household, please keep your kids home from school and do virtual learning. Just because your child tested negative week and a half ago doesnt imply they're ok going to school 2. Test at least once a week. 3. If your family traveled out of the region (specifically to a hot bed), maybe require a 5 day period before testing to send kids back to school but again thats moot when certain parents think they can game the system |