Do you believe that our system has denied people basic civil rights based on their hair color for centuries? Has wealth accumulation, education and employment access been disproportionately skewed in favor of blondes vs red heads in law and practice? To make comparisons between using race as a factor and an arbitrary physical attribute that has not been used to discriminate is intellectually lazy and an exercise in deflection. |
Race has factored into everything since the country was founded. Historically the way it has factored in is that white people have been advantaged. It’s very telling how we (white people) respond when the conversation about race as a factor seeks to address and change this pattern. |
How can they verify residency if they don't know what ward their kids live in? Sounds like Ward 9 |
Doubt it's nefarious. More likely students without a dcps 8th grade transcript coming for private schools. Walls has always provided this onramp for families who bailed on DCPS for middle school to come back for HS, even if it's at the expense of denying qualified DCPS students. |
Funny when DCUM talks about why white kids don’t apply to Banneker many posters will say the academics are no joke and they prefer Walls because it’s not as serious. 🤷🏽♀️ |
How is at the expense of DCPS students? It's a public school and all residents that meet the criteria are eligible to apply. I've known kids that were home schooled, attended privates, etc. to attend Walls as well as Banneker. |
It's not like those families don't have other options -- they've already exercised those options. Turning away highly qualified students from their own system is a pretty big self-own. |
The main selling point to Walls is scarcity and whiteness |
How many do they turn away? Not many. |
They have about 1000 kids apply each year (I think this year it was 1200?) and they take 140. This year the waistlist moved 90 spots. So let's say they took 250 out of 1200 who wanted the school. |
So, your argument is that families that did not have a viable middle school option that chose to stay in DC by sending their child to private knowing that there are more options in high school is less worthy than a child that went through DCPS middle school? It is a public school that should be available to all residents. Should families with kids in daycare or private preschool be excluded from the pre-K lottery? Should families that have a current seat in a DCPS or charter school be precluded from using the lottery to change schools (aka trade up) since "they have options" already? |
They normally offer a test a field that reduces the eligible field significantly. This year they used a low bar for GPA and weighted heavily on a short perfunctory zoom interview. There were many kids who never got off the waitlist who were far more qualified than many of those selected or with enough lottery luck. The whole process was random and haphazard. |
+1 |
Agreed. Many of the most impressive kids I know at Deal (the real outliers) did not get in. Others did. It was just random and did not screen for the best and brightest at all. They will be fine (some at Wilson and some at the top privates) but a random/haphazard process is never good. |
No one says that. 😞 |