Putting the high needs kids together means that we can staff those schools with trained people and we don’t need to have people trained for all sorts of specialized issues in every single school. That is definitely cheaper than having special IEPs and 1:1 aides and stopping classes all the time for disruptions. That’s not even considering the teachers leaving that we now need to figure out how to replace. |
Wouldn't that be glorious. Schools giving kids what they need including 1:1 aides. --parent of an autistic child who has been waiting for MONTHS for the school to provide the IEP dictated 1:1 'support person (dropped that it has to be an actual aide, but now just a random available adult) |
Hi parent, I am so sorry your child isn't getting the Aide he/she needs. Today I had to tell my superintendent that maybe they could get TA's if they paid more. He looked at me like he'd never considered that before. I was like OMG. Public education is a shit show and I don't see it getting better anytime, ever. I have a number of children with autism who function and learn just fine (on top of being wonderful little people) without an aide, and had one kid last year who was just fine with an aide. This year, he has no aide (we cannot find anyone at all to take the job). Thus why I suggested we might have to pay more. Schools need the funds to give children what they need. There's no way our current taxes fund schools anywhere close to where they need to be funded. It's a national disgrace. |
ok, but that would require changes to decades of legal precedent. I mean, if that's what you're arguing for, and you think that laws such as the Individuals with Disabilities Act should be repealed, then ok. but I'm can't tell if you understand what you're actually arguing for. |
Well, thank you for actually grading. My kid receives zero writing feedback. This is going to come back & bite these kids in a big way when the are older. |
Counties can't fill teacher positions, IA positions, or 1:1 positions-people don't want to deal with the stress and anxiety of working with constant behaviors all day. It's just the truth-the money just isn't worth it. |
I’m a school psychologist and unfortunately no one wants to be a 1:1 aide anymore. It’s too bad for the kids. They do need it. |
ROFL. Do you know how little those aides are paid? Building and staffing even ONE of these fictional schools you want is a multi, multimillion dollar process. No, the money will not “work out” — not even close — but hey, keep dreaming. |
| I was a 1:1 aide working with behaviorally challenged students for many years then I retired. I loved working with the kids, it was the rest of the bull that tipped the scales for me. |
PP this is unsustainable. You are burning out. Tell your supervisors all this. Cut back, yes make assessments 5 questions, ask for an assistant, refuse to do sub duties, don't do extras like preparing work for students who will be out. |
I’m a DP and a teacher. Yes, the PP is burning out. Most of us are. Well, the teachers who actually grade and plan are. Unfortunately, the Math teacher above can’t limit tests to just 5 questions because that isn’t going to be an accurate enough assessment of skills. She also can’t ask for an assistant because there are none. Teachers don’t get assistants, nor is there anyone who wants to make even less than we do to do similar work. We can’t refuse sub duties because “other duties as assigned” is written into most contracts. We’re also required to prepare work for students who are out. (I GROAN when I hear a student is going to be on a sports trip for a week and needs individual work. That can take me an hour or more to prep.) The PP has the solutions listen above, but they won’t happen either. So we are burning out and quitting. |
Call me a pessimist, but I think this has a good chance of becoming a “separate but equal” situation. I know you have good intentions, but chances are high that such schools would become understaffed and underfunded. The average politician largely doesn’t care about special needs kids and won’t put in the extra effort needed to support such a school. Also, special needs kids might want to be around normal kids too. Are you going to segregate them against their will? |
+1. The school in the article was “all the high needs kids put together”. Teachers are expected to not only handle the behavior side but also get these students to pass reading and math assessments for the princely amount of $39,000 per year. No wonder they can’t hire anyone. I hate to say it but it’s too late for most of the students at that school. I hope there’s a follow up article in five years’ time that proves me wrong. |
A significant part of the AP Math tests are multiple choice tests, right? So yes, I would make your tests primarily multiple choice. Then have 2 constructed response items that will only take a minute to grade, instead of 4 minutes. That should cut grading time to 1-2 hours instead of 6-8 hours. Or do 4 constructed response questions in class, and tell the students that you will only grade 1, but they don't know which 1 (it will be random). Have students grade each others responses. Then you collect them and spot check them, and score 1 question as a grade. Is this the best assessment and instruction possible? Absolutely not. But you don't have to do the best with your volunteer hours. You have to just do the minimum. |
| My school lost a veteran special ed teacher due to burnout. She’s gone to work for a company that sells special education materials. On FB, she seems much happier. Her resignation is devastating to her department. The RTSE can’t find a replacement so there are daily subs and a lot of coverage. |