NYT: How Rússia Wins the climate crisis
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
|
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/12/16/magazine/russia-climate-migration-crisis.html
Extremely interesting long form article from 18 months ago of strategic importance “ Its crop production is expected to be boosted by warming temperatures over the coming decades even as farm yields in the United States, Europe and India are all forecast to decrease. And whether by accident or cunning strategy or, most likely, some combination of the two, the steps its leaders have steadily taken — planting flags in the Arctic and propping up domestic grain production among them — have increasingly positioned Russia to regain its superpower mantle in a warmer world.” “ The scarcer food and other resources become on a global level, the more the ability to produce food domestically becomes a tool of power. And the more nations can keep themselves afloat in this changing world, the more they stand to benefit just by watching others sink. “It could be very tense,” Kerry said, “a really, really messy process.” All of that makes the flow of people — whether you call them climate refugees or human capital — an inseverable part of the geopolitical power struggle driven by climate. Russia has been explicit about its intention to come out ahead as the climate changes; in its national action plan on climate released in January, it called on the country to “use the advantages” of warming and listed Arctic shipping and extended growing seasons among things that would shower “additional benefits” on the nation. Russia may be no better positioned, politically speaking, to welcome large numbers of migrants than the U.S. or Canada; in fact, xenophobia is probably even more prevalent there. But how it tackles migration and its own demographic challenges will have tremendous consequences for the U.S. and the rest of the world. Russia has always wanted to populate its vast eastern lands, and the steady thawing there puts that long-sought goal within reach. Achieving it could significantly increase Russia’s prosperity and power in the process, through the opening of tens of millions of acres of land and a flourishing new agricultural economy.” “ One of the coldest and most ecologically hostile places on the planet, she found, is fast becoming pleasantly livable.” “ As Vladimir Putin himself once glibly put it, a couple of degrees of warming might not be so bad: “We could spend less on fur coats, and the grain harvest would go up.” “ Russia’s largest cities and most important military bases are also far less vulnerable to inundation from sea-level rise than those of, say, the United States, which has its largest cities on the water and will inevitably divert trillions of dollars in coming decades to fortify or relocate strategic assets. Even the savings in energy that will come from warming temperatures amounts to a mild economic stimulus.” “ Russia has already shown a new understanding of how to leverage its increasingly strong hand in agricultural exports. In 2010, when wildfires and drought conspired to ruin Russia’s grain harvests, Putin banned the exporting of wheat in order to protect his own people, then watched as global wheat prices tripled. The world reeled in response. From Pakistan to Indonesia, poverty increased. High prices rocked delicate political balances in Syria, Morocco and Egypt, where about 40 percent of daily caloric intake is from bread. The shortages poured fuel on Arab Spring uprisings, which eventually pushed millions of migrants toward Europe, with destabilizing effect — a bonus for Russian interests. And much of this turmoil began with wheat.” “ When Europe and the United States imposed sanctions on Russia after the downing of a Malaysian passenger jet over Ukraine in 2014, Russia countered by imposing sanctions on European imports. It seemed self-punishing at first, but the move was meant to give Russia’s own domestic food producers an opening and prod them to fill the supply gap. When Putin addressed his Federal Assembly the following December, he boldly proclaimed Russia would soon be “the largest world supplier” of healthful foods, referring to his goal of keeping Russian foods mostly G.M.O.-free. By 2018, Putin’s sanctions had paid enormous dividends: Since 2015, Russia’s wheat exports have jumped 100 percent, to about 44 million tons, surpassing those of the United States and Europe. Russia is now the largest wheat exporter in the world, responsible for nearly a quarter of the global market. Russia’s agricultural exports have jumped sixteenfold since 2000 and by 2018 were worth nearly $30 billion, all by relying largely on Russia’s legacy growing regions in its south and west. In Africa, Putin told attendees of the Russia-Africa Economic Forum held in Sochi last fall, “We are now exporting more agricultural products than weapons.” In the decades to come, as Russia’s grain and soy production rise as a result of climate change, its own food security will give it another wedge to drive into global geopolitics, should it wish to use it. Russia’s agricultural dominance, says Rod Schoonover, the former director of environment and natural resources at the National Intelligence Council and a former senior State Department analyst under the Obama and Trump administrations, is “an emergent national security issue” that is “underappreciated as a geopolitical threat.” “ Marshall Burke projects that over the next 80 years, per capita G.D.P. in the United States will drop by 36 percent compared to what it would be in a nonwarming world, even as per capita G.D.P. in Russia will quadruple. ” “ Vladimir Putin declared in 2013 that the remaking of Russia’s East “is our national priority for the entire 21st century,” and that “the goals that have to be attained are unprecedented in their scope.” Russia needs so much labor in the east, he told me, that it has even contemplated flying workers in from India: “We think about the lower hundreds of thousands.” There is an underlying sense, though, that sooner or later there will be more human capital available than Russia knows what to do with. Asian Russia sits atop a continent with the largest global population, including not just the Chinese but also nearly two billion South Asians — from the flooding Mekong Delta and Bangladesh to the sweltering plains of India — many of whom will inevitably be pushing northward in search of space and resources as the climate gets hotter and sea levels continue to rise. Russia is “not willing to bring in too many Chinese,” Karaganov said. “But when it comes, it will come from there and Central Asia, the Caucuses. This is a problem, but it could be the greatest opportunity.” “ these deals seem to be pushing the Chinese and Russian governments closer together. The groundwork was laid in May 2015, when Chinese President Xi Jinping agreed to form a $2 billion agricultural fund for trade partnerships in Russia’s east. ” “ The U.S. has made a few historic mistakes, and I don’t think they are able to repair them,” Karaganov told me. The first was what he characterized as the rejection of Russia’s bid some two decades earlier to strengthen ties with the West. “The second was helping to bring Russia and China together.” With China’s wealth paired to Russia’s resources, and the political trajectories and climate-related interests of the two countries more or less aligned, there is nothing short of a new world order at stake — an order, Brookings Institution analysts say, based not only on economic alignment but also on the two countries’ common commitment to supplanting Western hegemony.” “ One way or another, she says, “people are going to move. Because people need to eat.” |
Anonymous
| All of the same can be said about Canada as well but in addition they also have a modern, diverse and free society. Russia loses again! |
Anonymous
| Uh, if Russia wins the climate crisis, than means the world will reach the climate change tipping point sooner. I guess we will be destined to go the route of the dinosaurs and we can make way for the subspecieis of cockroaches to take over in another few million years. |
Anonymous
|
Yes --- if there is this impact, which is quite doubtful -- Canada will be helped so there will be no real impact in US.
I would not worry too much about China and Russia. They are permanent foes -- perhaps temporary friends. Russia is a tier 3 country without nukes. What they do is of little relevance. |
Anonymous
But both lack young people. Aging populations aren’t great. |
Anonymous
Well, good thing we've got Mexico to our south (and Central America). |
Anonymous
|
This is something that global warming people preach, that colder regions will become more fertile. Nothing new here.
Why bring up something everyone knows and it was in the news in 2020? |
Anonymous
While they’re doing better, immigration has slowed and will continue to slow. We also have the millennials to thank for lessening the blow of all our boomers retiring. |
Anonymous
| Well, this is super terrifying. It makes total sense and I do think Putin and his ilk will let the rest of the world literally burn if it benefits them. It’s like watching a disaster movie in slow mo, or the start of a sci film where the premise is that a planet is destroyed because it’s elites focus on short term petty squabbles and gain while the planet becomes uninhabitable. |
Anonymous
Plenty of us will move to Canada for the health care. Almost no one, except Trumpers, will move to Russia. |
Anonymous
Uh ok. Canada hasn’t grown desperate yet. Things don’t look good for Canada. |
Anonymous
|
This isn’t a particularly good take. Russia already has unused usable Agri land which it can’t farm because it doesn’t have enough people.
If China can not feed its people, China will take over Russia’s natural resources. The big threat from climate change will be geopolitical instability not realigning Agri crops. |
Anonymous
Actually Canada is limited by suitable soils for agriculture in northern areas. The last ice age scraped the Canadian Shield bare. |
Anonymous
Please come back and let us know how it goes when you try to immigrate to Canada. I love a good fairy tale. |
Anonymous
|
There have been several recent articles on how Russia may in fact be the region of the world that suffers most from climate change. Nearly two-thirds of Russian territory is permafrost (where the ground is permanently frozen), and the melting permafrost can lead to the catastrophic collapse of structures built above it ( https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-56350953 ). Gas release with the melting permafrost can lead to the creation of explosive craters and the possible release of new diseases and bacteria. And climate change is occurring more rapidly at high latitudes.
https://hir.harvard.edu/climate-change-and-siberia-no-time-for-continued-climate-inaction/ |