Strathberry Midi Tote or Coach Rogue?
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
Anonymous
| Style wise it’s the Strathberry but how hard on you on your bags? If it’s going to by a multi year daily workhorse that fiddly hardware might fail. |
Anonymous
| Much as it pains me to pay full retail for Coach, the Rogue is generally worth it. It will look good a lot longer than the strathberry bag. |
Anonymous
| I love the look of the Strathberry but wonder if the single handle that is only on one side would eventually get on my nerves. I feel like the bag would always be tilting to the side. |
Anonymous
| Whichever one that Meghan has. |
Anonymous
|
I prefer the Strathberry.
I’m hard on bags though, so I might go with a Cambridge Satchel Company music case and use the money that I save for a Mulberry at some point. https://us.cambridgesatchel.com/products/the-qest-melody-oxblood-navy-celtic-grain |
Anonymous
|
They’re both cute. The coach will likely last longer and weather better.
The strathberry is more for occasional use. Personally, I prefer Kate Spade at outlet prices: daily workhorse bag that easily lasts for a few years. |
Anonymous
| I prefer the coach. I know it’s mass market but it just looks better to me. |
Anonymous
Agree. The srathberry is too smooth and structured to be a bag for regular use. It will go downhill super quickly. That type of leather doesn’t patina well |
Anonymous
| The rogue is a very durable bag. The shape is also very classic. |
Anonymous
| Coach is awful. |
Anonymous
| rogue. |
Anonymous
| Both are old lady bags |
Anonymous
The one that you linked to fits inside the ones OP posted. |
Anonymous
Post your recommendations then. Lets see your style that's not old lady? |