👍🏻 |
👍🏻 |
Look, if two professionals get paid 75k annually, but one of them gets 6 weeks in the summer when they don't have to work and the other professional does not, then those 6 weeks are "time off" as far as I'm concerned.
That's the point. If I make the exact same amount as a DCPS teacher with a similar level of seniority and education, but I work all year and the teacher gets a long break in the summer, that teacher can tell me "it's an UNPAID summer" all she wants, but my observation is that it's a nice perk of her job that I do not receive. Consider that teachers in this thread have complained that some people making similar salaries to them get WFH and do not have to be "on stage" as much as a teacher has to be. This is true! This is one of the perks of a job that is mostly computer based as opposed to interpersonal, as teaching is. I have a job like this and agree, it is a perk. Now, I could sit here and explain to you how being full-time WFH is actually not a perk, how I have to pay for my own computer and all my own office supplies, I have to troubleshoot my own tech issues, plus my coworkers and clients assume that because I work from home, I am available to work at all times day and night, weekday and weekend. And that's true. Being full-time remote has pluses and minuses. But it would be disingenuous to tell someone who has a rigid in person schedule that actually the perk of remote work isn't a perk and how dare you refer to it that way. Come on. Obviously it's a perk. I'm still in my pajamas and I'm posting on DCUM at 10:30 in the morning, in part because I work remotely and it offers me certain freedom I wouldn't otherwise have. Well, having summer, spring, and winter breaks as a teacher are ALSO a perk, when you are making a livable annual salary. If DCPS teachers were making 45k a year, and genuinely had no choice but to take on second jobs during these breaks in the school year, I might feel differently. They aren't. Most DCPS teachers do not have second jobs. They enjoy this perk of their jobs. Which is good! Enjoy it! But don't sit there and try to convince me that it's not real. |
I just want to point out that OP, and most of us posting in this thread never asserted that teaching is easy, or that teachers do not earn the good salaries DCPS pays them. Those are insults and attitudes that are being *assumed* by some of the teachers posting, I am guessing because you have heard them before. But that's not the gist of this thread, at all.
I also assume that some teaching jobs are worse than others, and if a teacher is being bullied or harassed at work, no amount money is going to make that acceptable. As someone who has experienced workplace bullying and harassment, I have nothing but empathy for anyone going through it. It's not about money at all, it's about human dignity, and no one should have to endure it. But that's a separate issues than: does DCPS pay teachers fairly well compared to both industry standards and compared to other public interest jobs that require a similar level of experience and education? The answer is yes. |
And somehow we are ALL STILL QUITTING. The caps are very intentional. You are looking from the outside and seeing benefits. We are actually living the job and saying it isn’t what you think it is. Hence the shortage. |
Agree with you that the pay is "fair" but DCPS teachers are not "super well paid" which is how this thread started. |
Much of the shortage is due to less people entering the profession and not only to those who are quitting. Either way, the job is clearly less attractive for those who could enter the profession and for those who are already in it. IMO, no salary is going to make up for the working conditions of teaching as it exists today especially an urban city like DC. Teaching as it exists will never have the freedom that nearly all other professional jobs are starting to have. |
I reject the idea that teachers are "ALL STILL QUITTING." My kid's Title 1 DCPS elementary has great teachers retention. I have only heard of 3 teachers leaving in the last few years, and one of them went to another Title 1 in DCPS, just in a different part of town. There are schools in DC with high turnover and they tend to have other issues -- either bad or unsteady administration, be located in parts of town that few people want to travel to for work, or have serious behavioral issues. Most non-Title 1 schools in DC have pretty steady teaching staffs, especially at the elementary level (MS and HS pose different challenges). In other words, the turnover in DCPS is not equally distributed across the district, and is not even equally distributed across Title 1 schools. There are schools in DC with leadership and cultural issues, and teaching at those schools sucks, no matter how much they pay you, because they have poor organization. But that doesn't mean that all DCPS teachers are on the verge of quitting. Most DCPS teachers I know personally (about a dozen people between 3 schools, two of which are Title 1) seem to have pretty high work satisfaction. They have their complaints about Central Office and, often, issues with facilities (which are not managed by DCPS). But otherwise I'd say they are among the happier mid-career professionals I know. I am guessing the very respectable pay, coupled with some nice fringe benefits (summers off, a schedule that is very amenable to being a parent or having other interests/hobbies), and the fact that they all seem to genuinely like the actual job of teaching (none of them would complain about having to be up in front of students every day, given that this is sort of the fundamental nature of teaching and they knew that going in). I know far more disgruntled non-profit professionals than I do teachers. I think the job security and retirement benefits coupled with the time off help a lot -- a lot of other people in DC making similar salaries in helping professions don't have that kind of security or down time, and therefore are much more likely to burn out or throw in the towel and move to a corporate job. |
I find this discussion alarming. There is so much people don't understand about the reality on the ground.
For example, did you know that a recent survey showed over half of recent entrants are thinking about at least leaving the current employer by 2027? More than a quarter in some places are thinking about leaving the profession entirely. Another data point shows over 40% of these workers are thinking about or definitely leaving their chosen field. I just don't understand how all of these arm-chair bloviators can talk about teaching is and how extreme the desire there is to leave the field without understanding all of this... |
Well played, PP. Though most people won't bother to click those links or put in the mental effort necessarily to understand the point. |
I wonder how much of the leaving is just about 20somethings and their approach to any job market. So many are preparing to make a change within 5 years.
And I’ll say unkind things too; teaching is often something younger people do who didn’t do so great academically. So if you aren’t well prepared for the workplace and you take a highly demanding job, you are probably on a short fuse. Further there are a certain number of people who are just teaching temporarily even in their own planning. And on the summer thing. Yes you don’t get paid. Your yearly salary is pretty good for 5 years out of college and you can spend two months doing something that is not your job. Appalachian trail. Pool time. It’s not within the realm of the possible for most American workers. It’s really normal if you want to take two weeks off to get looked at like a delinquent by American employers. Three weeks and they want to fire you whether you have the leave accrued or not. |
So your perception of the reality at ONE school should be used to inform a discussion about the teacher shortage generally? No ma'am. The shortage exists overall whether you see it at your school or not. Ask your school's special educators what their case loads are like. |
I don't think shortages are unique to the teaching profession. There's a lots of shortages in lots of fields right now. The unemployment rate is incredibly low. |
Yes, this. Many people are looking to change jobs/industries, especially in their 20s-30s. |
These links are about lawyers and doctors. Maybe they would have less burn out if they got summers off like teachers! |