I love that she's doing this. She's a musician and this is where her musical imagination has taken her. And, obviously a lot of people love this song too. It's done quite well so far. Not sure if you noticed? |
Just listened to Texas Hold them and 16 carriages and didn’t love them. I don’t know if it’s because I’m not a country music fan or if it’s because the songs are not great. |
The Texas song is terrible. It's not even in the Country Top 40 this week. Only Beyoncé's fans are streaming this song, it's not real country. |
"Real country"tm, the temper tantrum being thrown by white country music fans over this is telling. |
Same poster coming back to modify this to say "some" white country music fans. Because I'm a country music fan, not a Beyonce fan in general, and I love Texas Hold Em and I'm not the only one. I also love the Dixie Chicks (still, they've put out good music in the last few years and mounted an awesome tour). I think a musical genre that has decided only white people can make "real" country music is ignorant of its roots, and brazenly racist. Prove me wrong. |
Um, the country music industry—like everything and everyone else—is diversifying. You are seeing more black country music artists, and you are seeing more uber-successful black country artists like Darius Rucker and Kane Brown. So please stop with the knee-jerk assumption that all country music and all country music fans are racist. It’s just not true. Ever spent time in a red state? You know what jumps out immediately: interracial couples…they are everywhere. PS - Most country music these days is pop music with more guitars and better storytelling. That’s why Beyoncé is able to slide in: country fans are used to pop hooks. |
Then, what was with the Darius Rucker slam above? I grew up in the South in a Red State. This is not a slam against either of those. Just the country music fan base and radio stations who seem to have an issue with black artists that clearly has its roots in racism. |
How can Darius and Kane be so successful and universally embraced by country music fans, radio, and the industry if it’s so racist…today? |
There's no tantrum. This song doesn't hold up. The lyrics are so incredibly stupid as if its what someone thinks a country song would be about. Hiding in the basement due to a tornado hit the basement? It's incredibly juvenile. She tried and I guess it's "countryish" but she's not cut out for the genre. |
Who says the tornado hit the basement? Person just has a ratchet basement, as do many of us, wut |
+1 yep, and her ridiculous fake twang she threw in to sound country in Texas Hold’em. Pathetic! |
The songs aren’t that great |
Pour some sugar on me! Hoedown! I’m survivin! Tornado! This shit is painfully bad. |
The lyrics sound like a bot took a bunch of random country sounding phrases and patched them together. Catchy tune though…. |
I don’t think she intended it to be real country. It’s a novelty song for her. I would love to hear her do real country. That said country top 40 is not real country either. But an artist like say … Taylor Swift… is also not winking at country in her songs. |