I’d move to cursive, teach him slowly and correctly and consistently. |
I also have a 4th grader with terrible handwriting! It's the one real COVID downside that he experienced (our school is very focused on handwriting in K and 1st).
He's about to go to a school that relies heavily on writing and doesn't use screens, so I'm hoping it will improve out of necessity. Maybe we should consider OT. |
+1. If OT eval says fine motor deficit exists then that probably is the root problem to fix, and insurance likely will pay part or all of the cost. The OT likely starts with improving basic fine motor skills and then can move on specifically to handwriting. Made a big difference for our DC, but took months. |
I agree with everyone who suggested OT. My son did 2 x week OT for two years for this and his handwriting has greatly improved. It was covered by insurance. |
I think bad handwriting is the biggest COVID school issue with my 5th grader. I can barely read it! The worst part are his numbers, it's one thing to spell wrong, but another to get marked wrong on a math problem because the teacher can't tell if it's a 4 or a 9. At home I make him rewrite things, but that doesn't happen at school. |
I could have written this post a few months ago. I even bought Handwriting Without Tears workooks and tried to get my kid to do them over the summer last year (which he did, but they didn't help at all). Like others here, we ended up asking our ped for an OT recommendation. The OT eval found stuff to work on (including core and posture, as mentioned above). Have been doing OT 1x/week since January and handwriting is slowly improving. Still need to remind him to use his "OT" handwriting on schoolwork, since it isn't second nature yet, but there is hope! |
There's your answer. If he doesn't care, he won't be motivated to improve his handwriting. |
Please make sure you fix their hand posture, No one corrected me and my horrible hand posture persists after decades |
Making him re-do homework might help, but the problem is if the school doesn't mark him down for poor handwriting it's hard to enforce at home. I have 2 kids whose teachers have cared about handwriting and 1 kid whose teachers never have. Guess which kid has the incredibly poor handwriting? |
+1 Catholic schools don't mess around. Another thing that motivates some kids is teaching a younger sibling/cousin. My kids' cousins live overseas and speak English fluently but can't write it. My kids made a big production of teaching them how to write using their best handwriting that I NEVER see at home! I saved samples to remind them in the future. |
It's going to hurt him as he gets into harder math and needs to be able to read his own notes. For language and social studies he might get away with typing. |
Get the Handwriting Without Tears program and start from the beginning. |
Oh sorry. Just saw you tried HWT |
I have a 5th grader with atrocious handwriting. I realized it was having a serious impact at school. He finds handwriting so much work that he has no motivation to do school work that involves writing. It started impacting his grades so I took him to Canyon Kids in Bethesda for an assessment. They figured out the problem and he is now in OT once a week. It is finally making a difference! |
Some kids hate HWT. My kids vastly prefer Zaner Bloser style cursive, which is what they do at (public, surprisingly) school. |