Anonymous wrote:MB here. The vast majority of the time, the house is clean and ready for the nanny. I don't expect her to do my dishes or any other cleaning unrelated to DD. That said, I have occasionally run out in the morning and left a cereal bowl or coffee mug in the sink. I would not be bothered if it were there when I came home since it isn't the nanny's job. However, every time it has happened, the nanny has put them in the dishwasher. She has even loaded laundry because she noticed the basket was full. She looks for little ways to make my life easier and I'm always grateful when she goes above and beyond.
She almost always leaves the house clean as well, but there have been occasions when they ran out of time doing something and haven't cleaned up. I don't mind and will clean after her when necessary.
I like to think we both respect and support each other.
(Oh, and before anyone worries, she is paid well and I thank her every day.)
THIS is totally different than the OP, whose family leaves dirty dishes piled in the sink every morning, whose dishwasher always needs to be unloaded so she can load those she uses throughout the day, etc.
When you leave the house in presentable condition every day, you set the standard that they house is kept this way, which is why your nanny leaves it that way in return. And also why when you occasionally leave a bowl in the sink it's not there at the end of the day, and why when she occasionally leaves the house messier than normal you don't mind dealing with it when you get home. Sadly, you aren't the OP's nanny family. Which is why she might now be considering leaving stuff in a mess to "train" the family.... (or why she's being counseled by some to do this) and that's when things start going downhill....
same thing when a husband/wife start doing this to each other to try to "train" the other to do dishes, make the bed, etc. It almost never accomplishes what you want and always builds frustration and resentment.