Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:well for certain procedures that require a decision to be made do you want your nanny making that decision for you?
Implied consent is for emergencies, In OP's case there was no need to withhold giving a child stitches.
I have been a nanny and am now a parent. If a decision has to be made regarding the care of my child I want to make it myself, even if its over the phone. My sitter can take my child to the ER and get her stitches if I cant get there. However, if a choice needs to be made that could affect my child life in the future thats my decision to make.
And if the choice had to be made right away? The child needed a risky but life saving surgery and I can't get in contact with you right away?! Then what would you propose?
Wouldn't they go ahead with any life saving surgery? If it was not immediately life threatening, then they would need consent, but if it is life saving at that moment, you will die without it, then they go ahead and do it. They have to do that for people no matter what, whether you have any insurance, whether you are awake and can give consent for yourself or unconscious and can't give consent for yourself. They legally have to do everything they can to save your life, unless you have signed a DNR.