I have had a couple problems with NannyChex. They weren’t major, but not worth dealing with, imo. I’d go with Homepay.

GTM Payroll Services is another one to consider. They'll do your workers' comp too if you need it (which you may not with a p/t sitter but others might).

I like homework solutions.

We are thinking about hiring a part-time sitter. We've always made do with family or preschool, so we've never needed to deal with nanny taxes etc. I'm looking for feedback on the services like Poppins Payroll, NannyChex, etc. Poppins Payroll looked like the most affordable option.

Thanks in advance!