Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I also don't like what they did to the relationship between Mia and Pauline in the show.
Were they lovers in the book? Again, I read it when the book came out. I don't remember.
No. They weren’t. But of course Hollywood must do everything they can to normalize it. So it has to be in every show, movie, commercial.
Anonymous wrote:Interesting to read the comments. It would be interesting to know the racial breakdown of the people who dislike the series version of Mia.
As a woman of color, I LOVE her character on the show. Yes, different from the book, but felt authentic for the class/race dynamics in the series. The Mia I imagine in the book is white. Adding the racial dimension to the series, for me, changes the perspective on how Mia deals with people, particularly privileged white people. The abortion scene with Lexie and the scene where she discusses making vs. having choices were powerful and my favorites. I feel like she spoke what many women of color feel.
I do have mixed feelings about what she did to the couple for whom she was acting as a surrogate. However, it also invites conversation about the historical use of black bodies, particularly black female bodies in this country. I especially loved that the couple was black, which adds to the discourse that abuse of black bodies can also happen at the hands of other black people.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Interesting to read the comments. It would be interesting to know the racial breakdown of the people who dislike the series version of Mia.
As a woman of color, I LOVE her character on the show. Yes, different from the book, but felt authentic for the class/race dynamics in the series. The Mia I imagine in the book is white. Adding the racial dimension to the series, for me, changes the perspective on how Mia deals with people, particularly privileged white people. The abortion scene with Lexie and the scene where she discusses making vs. having choices were powerful and my favorites. I feel like she spoke what many women of color feel.
I do have mixed feelings about what she did to the couple for whom she was acting as a surrogate. However, it also invites conversation about the historical use of black bodies, particularly black female bodies in this country. I especially loved that the couple was black, which adds to the discourse that abuse of black bodies can also happen at the hands of other black people.
I mean, yes. I do agree with all of this and it makes for good discussion and a great show. So many variables. Great writing and good points made from writers and producers.
But none of that was in the book, and they’re adding a whole other layer to an already complex story.
And I don’t like Kerry Washington’s face because she crinkles her nose and lips. Not because she’s black.
+2
I'll add that the way the younger Mia nails KW's mannerisms is fantastic.
Anonymous wrote:Interesting to read the comments. It would be interesting to know the racial breakdown of the people who dislike the series version of Mia.
As a woman of color, I LOVE her character on the show. Yes, different from the book, but felt authentic for the class/race dynamics in the series. The Mia I imagine in the book is white. Adding the racial dimension to the series, for me, changes the perspective on how Mia deals with people, particularly privileged white people. The abortion scene with Lexie and the scene where she discusses making vs. having choices were powerful and my favorites. I feel like she spoke what many women of color feel.
I do have mixed feelings about what she did to the couple for whom she was acting as a surrogate. However, it also invites conversation about the historical use of black bodies, particularly black female bodies in this country. I especially loved that the couple was black, which adds to the discourse that abuse of black bodies can also happen at the hands of other black people.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I also don't like what they did to the relationship between Mia and Pauline in the show.
Were they lovers in the book? Again, I read it when the book came out. I don't remember.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Interesting to read the comments. It would be interesting to know the racial breakdown of the people who dislike the series version of Mia.
As a woman of color, I LOVE her character on the show. Yes, different from the book, but felt authentic for the class/race dynamics in the series. The Mia I imagine in the book is white. Adding the racial dimension to the series, for me, changes the perspective on how Mia deals with people, particularly privileged white people. The abortion scene with Lexie and the scene where she discusses making vs. having choices were powerful and my favorites. I feel like she spoke what many women of color feel.
I do have mixed feelings about what she did to the couple for whom she was acting as a surrogate. However, it also invites conversation about the historical use of black bodies, particularly black female bodies in this country. I especially loved that the couple was black, which adds to the discourse that abuse of black bodies can also happen at the hands of other black people.
I mean, yes. I do agree with all of this and it makes for good discussion and a great show. So many variables. Great writing and good points made from writers and producers.
But none of that was in the book, and they’re adding a whole other layer to an already complex story.
And I don’t like Kerry Washington’s face because she crinkles her nose and lips. Not because she’s black.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I also don't like what they did to the relationship between Mia and Pauline in the show.
Were they lovers in the book? Again, I read it when the book came out. I don't remember.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Interesting to read the comments. It would be interesting to know the racial breakdown of the people who dislike the series version of Mia.
As a woman of color, I LOVE her character on the show. Yes, different from the book, but felt authentic for the class/race dynamics in the series. The Mia I imagine in the book is white. Adding the racial dimension to the series, for me, changes the perspective on how Mia deals with people, particularly privileged white people. The abortion scene with Lexie and the scene where she discusses making vs. having choices were powerful and my favorites. I feel like she spoke what many women of color feel.
I do have mixed feelings about what she did to the couple for whom she was acting as a surrogate. However, it also invites conversation about the historical use of black bodies, particularly black female bodies in this country. I especially loved that the couple was black, which adds to the discourse that abuse of black bodies can also happen at the hands of other black people.
I mean, yes. I do agree with all of this and it makes for good discussion and a great show. So many variables. Great writing and good points made from writers and producers.
But none of that was in the book, and they’re adding a whole other layer to an already complex story.
And I don’t like Kerry Washington’s face because she crinkles her nose and lips. Not because she’s black.
Anonymous wrote:Interesting to read the comments. It would be interesting to know the racial breakdown of the people who dislike the series version of Mia.
As a woman of color, I LOVE her character on the show. Yes, different from the book, but felt authentic for the class/race dynamics in the series. The Mia I imagine in the book is white. Adding the racial dimension to the series, for me, changes the perspective on how Mia deals with people, particularly privileged white people. The abortion scene with Lexie and the scene where she discusses making vs. having choices were powerful and my favorites. I feel like she spoke what many women of color feel.
I do have mixed feelings about what she did to the couple for whom she was acting as a surrogate. However, it also invites conversation about the historical use of black bodies, particularly black female bodies in this country. I especially loved that the couple was black, which adds to the discourse that abuse of black bodies can also happen at the hands of other black people.
Anonymous wrote:I also don't like what they did to the relationship between Mia and Pauline in the show.