Anonymous
10/24/2018 12:50
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Arlington and Washington Spirit are the most direct threats to McLean retention/recruiting.
Arlington maybe, except it's a little further to get to, so I guess that's true, but Not Washington Spirit.
In some age groups, a lot more players left for Spirit than for Arlington.
Maybe this year, as I know one whole team followed each other over there, but that's hardly proof of a trend. Washington Spirit has a lot to do before it can be "established" as a talent hub. FCV and Arlington are both better options.
I would encourage everyone to do their own research. Talk to the coaches and technical directors and parents of current team members and decide for themselves what their "best option" is. Also, there are hundreds of pages of discussion on DCUM about the pros and cons of various teams/programs.
Not PP, but it all flows downstream in Mclean. Ask the parents what they think of that 2007 team and some of the parents and the new coach. I imagine players will be leaving for Arlington, or maybe Spirit if they can't make Arlington.
Anonymous
10/24/2018 11:02
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Arlington and Washington Spirit are the most direct threats to McLean retention/recruiting.
Arlington maybe, except it's a little further to get to, so I guess that's true, but Not Washington Spirit.
In some age groups, a lot more players left for Spirit than for Arlington.
Maybe this year, as I know one whole team followed each other over there, but that's hardly proof of a trend. Washington Spirit has a lot to do before it can be "established" as a talent hub. FCV and Arlington are both better options.
I would encourage everyone to do their own research. Talk to the coaches and technical directors and parents of current team members and decide for themselves what their "best option" is. Also, there are hundreds of pages of discussion on DCUM about the pros and cons of various teams/programs.
+1. You know what they say, opinions are like ...holes, everybody has one.
Best to actually speak with coaches, parents, and players.
Anonymous
10/24/2018 10:34
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Arlington and Washington Spirit are the most direct threats to McLean retention/recruiting.
Arlington maybe, except it's a little further to get to, so I guess that's true, but Not Washington Spirit.
In some age groups, a lot more players left for Spirit than for Arlington.
Maybe this year, as I know one whole team followed each other over there, but that's hardly proof of a trend. Washington Spirit has a lot to do before it can be "established" as a talent hub. FCV and Arlington are both better options.
I would encourage everyone to do their own research. Talk to the coaches and technical directors and parents of current team members and decide for themselves what their "best option" is. Also, there are hundreds of pages of discussion on DCUM about the pros and cons of various teams/programs.
Anonymous
10/23/2018 17:08
Subject: McLean ECNL
VDA girls are in ECNL and not in DA.
Anonymous
10/23/2018 16:07
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Arlington and Washington Spirit are the most direct threats to McLean retention/recruiting.
Arlington maybe, except it's a little further to get to, so I guess that's true, but Not Washington Spirit.
In some age groups, a lot more players left for Spirit than for Arlington.
Maybe this year, as I know one whole team followed each other over there, but that's hardly proof of a trend. Washington Spirit has a lot to do before it can be "established" as a talent hub. FCV and Arlington are both better options.
I agree that FVC is a better and more established option, but I am not sure about Arlington. My understanding is that Arlington does not even have girls DA beyond U15 so some parents may prefer to go to a club that offers DA in all age groups, especially those that are closer to college recruitment years.
For the 35th time, Arlington will be awarded the older age groups in the DA as the 04's progress.
Or they can just call the older teams "pre-DA" as they do with their boys teams, which were also promised expansion to older age DA groups, but it never materialized.
As US soccer has done with other clubs, like VDA, they will just add the age groups as the 04's advance. This allows Arlington time to sort things out with coaching and other issues.
Anonymous
10/23/2018 16:02
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Arlington and Washington Spirit are the most direct threats to McLean retention/recruiting.
Arlington maybe, except it's a little further to get to, so I guess that's true, but Not Washington Spirit.
In some age groups, a lot more players left for Spirit than for Arlington.
Maybe this year, as I know one whole team followed each other over there, but that's hardly proof of a trend. Washington Spirit has a lot to do before it can be "established" as a talent hub. FCV and Arlington are both better options.
I agree that FVC is a better and more established option, but I am not sure about Arlington. My understanding is that Arlington does not even have girls DA beyond U15 so some parents may prefer to go to a club that offers DA in all age groups, especially those that are closer to college recruitment years.
For the 35th time, Arlington will be awarded the older age groups in the DA as the 04's progress.
Or they can just call the older teams "pre-DA" as they do with their boys teams, which were also promised expansion to older age DA groups, but it never materialized.
Anonymous
10/23/2018 15:59
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Arlington and Washington Spirit are the most direct threats to McLean retention/recruiting.
Arlington maybe, except it's a little further to get to, so I guess that's true, but Not Washington Spirit.
In some age groups, a lot more players left for Spirit than for Arlington.
Maybe this year, as I know one whole team followed each other over there, but that's hardly proof of a trend. Washington Spirit has a lot to do before it can be "established" as a talent hub. FCV and Arlington are both better options.
I agree that FVC is a better and more established option, but I am not sure about Arlington. My understanding is that Arlington does not even have girls DA beyond U15 so some parents may prefer to go to a club that offers DA in all age groups, especially those that are closer to college recruitment years.
For the 35th time, Arlington will be awarded the older age groups in the DA as the 04's progress.
Anonymous
10/23/2018 15:54
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Arlington and Washington Spirit are the most direct threats to McLean retention/recruiting.
Arlington maybe, except it's a little further to get to, so I guess that's true, but Not Washington Spirit.
In some age groups, a lot more players left for Spirit than for Arlington.
Maybe this year, as I know one whole team followed each other over there, but that's hardly proof of a trend. Washington Spirit has a lot to do before it can be "established" as a talent hub. FCV and Arlington are both better options.
I agree that FVC is a better and more established option, but I am not sure about Arlington. My understanding is that Arlington does not even have girls DA beyond U15 so some parents may prefer to go to a club that offers DA in all age groups, especially those that are closer to college recruitment years.
Anonymous
10/23/2018 14:48
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Arlington and Washington Spirit are the most direct threats to McLean retention/recruiting.
Arlington maybe, except it's a little further to get to, so I guess that's true, but Not Washington Spirit.
In some age groups, a lot more players left for Spirit than for Arlington.
Maybe this year, as I know one whole team followed each other over there, but that's hardly proof of a trend. Washington Spirit has a lot to do before it can be "established" as a talent hub. FCV and Arlington are both better options.
Anonymous
10/23/2018 14:35
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Arlington and Washington Spirit are the most direct threats to McLean retention/recruiting.
Arlington maybe, except it's a little further to get to, so I guess that's true, but Not Washington Spirit.
In some age groups, a lot more players left for Spirit than for Arlington.
Anonymous
10/23/2018 14:31
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Arlington and Washington Spirit are the most direct threats to McLean retention/recruiting.
Arlington maybe, except it's a little further to get to, so I guess that's true, but Not Washington Spirit.
Anonymous
10/23/2018 08:48
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Arlington and Washington Spirit are the most direct threats to McLean retention/recruiting.
Anonymous
10/23/2018 05:34
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
I guess we'll see at the spring's tryouts if that's true. FCV can't take everyone.
Anonymous
10/22/2018 00:21
Subject: McLean ECNL
The magnet stopped with DA. Girls would try-out for pre-ECNL to get in a year early to make ECNL. Not a single '07 came in this year to get on Green.
Anonymous
10/19/2018 17:56
Subject: McLean ECNL
Anonymous wrote:The only info you’ll get on CW is what the PP is providing about his talent ID ability and history.
I’m not sure is talent ID is super special as his reputation has solid players coming to him, but he can confirm that players are good.
As far as passing girls up to older teams, the older girls have enough incoming talent that I might be sceptical of the connection of the 2.
By incoming talent, do you mean McLean is still having a decent turnout at tryouts? Is it still a talent magnet?