Anonymous
03/06/2017 13:28
Subject: Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:I can't stand Madeline's younger daughter. She's supposed to be a 1st grader, correct?
I have a 1st grader who I and most others consider to be well-spoken and mature for her age (only child syndrome), and she's a baby compared to this character. No 6-7yo talks that way. I'd guess her more 10-11.
And NO teacher would have handled that situation that way.
Agreed, she's too precocious. It's over-the-top.
Anonymous
03/06/2017 13:27
Subject: Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:That scene in the therapists office with Nicole Kidman tonight. Just wow! Amazing.
I thought the therapist scene was a little over the top. I even remarked to my wife: "Wow, they just had 8 breakthroughs in 5 minutes of therapy. That doesn't happen in the real world!"
I get that the therapist scene is being used to push the plot forward (and establish probable cause/uncertainty for Celeste's husband as the killer....IDK if he actually is, didn't read the books or spoilers), but it was a bit hard for me to suspend disbelief in that scene.
Anonymous
03/06/2017 12:53
Subject: Big Little Lies HBO
I can't stand Madeline's younger daughter. She's supposed to be a 1st grader, correct?
I have a 1st grader who I and most others consider to be well-spoken and mature for her age (only child syndrome), and she's a baby compared to this character. No 6-7yo talks that way. I'd guess her more 10-11.
And NO teacher would have handled that situation that way.
I have a 1st grader who I and most others consider to be well-spoken and mature for her age (only child syndrome), and she's a baby compared to this character. No 6-7yo talks that way. I'd guess her more 10-11.
And NO teacher would have handled that situation that way.
Anonymous
03/06/2017 09:52
Subject: Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Madeline seems like a caricature rather than a character. It's like a chick-lit type (Hello! Fashionable woman here with a Strooooooooong personality) is plopped down in the middle of an HBO show.
Yeah but it's exactly how she's written in the book - Reese has nailed her character.
I used to be a huge Nicole Kidman fan - she's a brilliant actress and has several Oscar-worthy performances under her belt (plus I think she actually won one, right?). But her face no longer moves, and that really limits her as an actress. Though in a way it works for her character here, who is totally shut down with a flat affect and trying to maintain the perfect exterior - like a mask. But still...there's only so far she can go when she literally cannot move her face.
I disagree because the character is so different than in the book. She has a strong personality, to be sure, but she's also distinctly different than many of the other moms. Maddie and Ed are solid middle class, Ed is a journalist and doesn't make a lot of money, she probably has to work for the income. I think she feels a bit insecure about that, but is relatively fine being on the edge of the cool/rich mom crowd. Plus she's so frustrated that her daughter is turning into a mini-Bonnie (vegan, crunchy, etc).
Can't stand Nicole Kidman as Celeste. I read Celeste as being distant but warm and kind to others. Nicole as Celeste is an ice queen.
I agree that Reese Witherspoon's portrayal of Madeleine is very different. I found Madeleine much more likable in the book - yes, she is a busybody but I think the way the character is written in the miniseries is much more of a bitch.
Anonymous
03/06/2017 09:51
Subject: Re:Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I'd hold off reading the book at this point until the series is over. I mentioned above that I'm glad I read the book some time ago so I can enjoy the HBO version without the constant comparisons to the book. There's a good bit of differences.
You always have to go with book first. Always.
Your mind will create the visual images for you.
When you read the book first you are just seeing the actors/actresses and visuals presented to you in film.
I've never once found a movie or show to be better than a book.
The movie Devil Wears Prada was better than the book.
I agree!
Anonymous
03/05/2017 23:29
Subject: Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:That scene in the therapists office with Nicole Kidman tonight. Just wow! Amazing.
Yes. I agree. So real.
This scene had many critics raving. Now I see why.
Anonymous
03/05/2017 22:10
Subject: Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:That scene in the therapists office with Nicole Kidman tonight. Just wow! Amazing.
Yes. I agree. So real.
Anonymous
03/05/2017 22:09
Subject: Re:Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I loved tonight's episode. #3
All the acting was spot-on.
It was the best so far.
I loved the Gleetwood Macand Meil Young music selections.
Fleetwood Mac
Anonymous
03/05/2017 22:07
Subject: Re:Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:I loved tonight's episode. #3
All the acting was spot-on.
It was the best so far.
I loved the Gleetwood Macand Meil Young music selections.
Anonymous
03/05/2017 22:07
Subject: Big Little Lies HBO
That scene in the therapists office with Nicole Kidman tonight. Just wow! Amazing.
Anonymous
03/05/2017 22:06
Subject: Re:Big Little Lies HBO
I loved tonight's episode. #3
All the acting was spot-on.
It was the best so far.
All the acting was spot-on.
It was the best so far.
Anonymous
03/05/2017 21:03
Subject: Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anyone else read the book when it was released and now can't remember it as you watch the show? :-0
I read it when it first came out, just a random selection off the shelf I think. LOVED it. Devoured it perhaps a little too quickly because I can't remember the story and characters much at all!
I read it long enough ago that I'm really enjoying the HBO version without fussing that it's not as good or the same as the book. Win win.
I do feel that the female leads have been cast perfectly.
PP here. I tend not to fuss about whether it's the same or not anyway. I am enjoying the show, but would even if I read the book last week.
I think the KIDS are perfectly cast. Ziggy is almost exactly as I pictured.
Anonymous
03/05/2017 20:35
Subject: Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:Anyone else read the book when it was released and now can't remember it as you watch the show? :-0
I read it when it first came out, just a random selection off the shelf I think. LOVED it. Devoured it perhaps a little too quickly because I can't remember the story and characters much at all!
I read it long enough ago that I'm really enjoying the HBO version without fussing that it's not as good or the same as the book. Win win.
I do feel that the female leads have been cast perfectly.
Anonymous
03/05/2017 19:04
Subject: Re:Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I'd hold off reading the book at this point until the series is over. I mentioned above that I'm glad I read the book some time ago so I can enjoy the HBO version without the constant comparisons to the book. There's a good bit of differences.
You always have to go with book first. Always.
Your mind will create the visual images for you.
When you read the book first you are just seeing the actors/actresses and visuals presented to you in film.
I've never once found a movie or show to be better than a book.
The movie Devil Wears Prada was better than the book.
Anonymous
03/05/2017 18:57
Subject: Re:Big Little Lies HBO
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I'd hold off reading the book at this point until the series is over. I mentioned above that I'm glad I read the book some time ago so I can enjoy the HBO version without the constant comparisons to the book. There's a good bit of differences.
You always have to go with book first. Always.
Your mind will create the visual images for you.
When you read the book first you are just seeing the actors/actresses and visuals presented to you in film.
I've never once found a movie or show to be better than a book.
I wish I had watched "A Man Called Ove" before I read the book- that's about the only time I felt this way.