Anonymous
02/17/2024 09:27
Subject: Re:Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This decision totally tracks with the increase in anti-semitism in the district. Well done MCPS.
How? Instead of making staff go in person for a mandatory all day PD day, they now made it an online PD day that will probably take a few hours.
Seems like they gave a benefit, even though non instructional days are not supposed to be solely for religious holidays.
That's nice for the teachers, but I'm talking about for the students and their families. Passover begins that evening but the hours during the day before sunset are used to clean the house and prepare. This decision is all very tone deaf.
Then, IMO, it should be an excused absence for you.
In past years, are kids always off on the day of the evening that Passover begins?
Anonymous
02/17/2024 09:12
Subject: Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Asynchronous learning at home? So it’s a day off, just with a bunch of homework?
It's a day the parents do the school's job. And if they kid doesn't have parents who will do it then that kid misses out.
Hands up, all parents and guardians who are planning to homeschool that day?
I'm personally planning to send DCs outside with their friends.
What I care about is that the families who need childcare or MCPS services that day will receive the support that they need.
I don't give a hang what 'work' is being asked for. DCs will fill it in whenever. But we're sure as heck not going to create Special Family Learning Day. Had more than enough of that during lockdown.
Anonymous
02/17/2024 08:51
Subject: Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:Asynchronous learning at home? So it’s a day off, just with a bunch of homework?
It's a day the parents do the school's job. And if they kid doesn't have parents who will do it then that kid misses out.
Anonymous
02/17/2024 08:47
Subject: Re:Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Hey, our day off just stayed a day off! As long as folks who need it have childcare and other supports, I'm totally OK with school telling DCs to do something and our family basically ignoring it until the last second. *shrug*
Anonymous
02/17/2024 08:36
Subject: Re:Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This decision totally tracks with the increase in anti-semitism in the district. Well done MCPS.
No, it's not. There are many minority faiths that have their *ONE* allowed holiday made into teacher grading days if they are lucky (Diwali, Eid, Lunar New Year,) or often just dropped from the calendar altogether. Regardless my kids almost always get hw on Diwali. What's more - a very big holiday called Vijayadashami - which is literally supposed to be a day off from learning - is never given off. I pull my kids out; I always have, and several other families we know do too. We tell the teachers and they give the kids an extra day to finish - in other words,it's excused. You can do that as well.
1 extra day to make up work is not the policy and may not even be sufficient. When a child misses a day of school, they may not have sufficient time in a single day to make up the work and do the regular work for that day!
Also, you were extremely generous in your reply about the false claim of antisemitism when you didn’t point out that students already get TWO Jewish high holidays off.
Anonymous
02/17/2024 07:39
Subject: Re:Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:This decision totally tracks with the increase in anti-semitism in the district. Well done MCPS.
No, it's not. There are many minority faiths that have their *ONE* allowed holiday made into teacher grading days if they are lucky (Diwali, Eid, Lunar New Year,) or often just dropped from the calendar altogether. Regardless my kids almost always get hw on Diwali. What's more - a very big holiday called Vijayadashami - which is literally supposed to be a day off from learning - is never given off. I pull my kids out; I always have, and several other families we know do too. We tell the teachers and they give the kids an extra day to finish - in other words,it's excused. You can do that as well.
Anonymous
02/17/2024 07:29
Subject: Re:Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This decision totally tracks with the increase in anti-semitism in the district. Well done MCPS.
How? Instead of making staff go in person for a mandatory all day PD day, they now made it an online PD day that will probably take a few hours.
Seems like they gave a benefit, even though non instructional days are not supposed to be solely for religious holidays.
That's nice for the teachers, but I'm talking about for the students and their families. Passover begins that evening but the hours during the day before sunset are used to clean the house and prepare. This decision is all very tone deaf.
It's not like the work is going to magically appear on Monday morning since it's asynchronous. I am sure most teachers will have it up way ahead, and the kids can do it on the weekend.
Anonymous
02/17/2024 01:18
Subject: Re:Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:MoCo Show has the MCEA email
https://mocoshow.com/2024/02/16/mcea-communicates-to-teachers-that-monday-april-22-will-be-the-make-up-day-asynchronous-learning-for-students/
There's no Feb 7th meeting on the board's calendar, so how were they able to discuss and approve the makeup day?
MCEA made the decision, not the school board. Illegal, yes, but no one is going to stop them.
Clearly illegal.
If this is true, it seems more a violation of the board's requirement to have open meetings.
No, because the union was involved. The teachers could have provided input on a personal basis, but the moment MCEA became involved this became an illegal negotiation.
If it was a "negotiation" what did MCEA give up for it? Or did they just ask?
They got to avoid adding back an instructional day.
So they didn't negotiate anything.
Anonymous
02/16/2024 23:25
Subject: Re:Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:MoCo Show has the MCEA email
https://mocoshow.com/2024/02/16/mcea-communicates-to-teachers-that-monday-april-22-will-be-the-make-up-day-asynchronous-learning-for-students/
There's no Feb 7th meeting on the board's calendar, so how were they able to discuss and approve the makeup day?
MCEA made the decision, not the school board. Illegal, yes, but no one is going to stop them.
Clearly illegal.
If this is true, it seems more a violation of the board's requirement to have open meetings.
No, because the union was involved. The teachers could have provided input on a personal basis, but the moment MCEA became involved this became an illegal negotiation.
If it was a "negotiation" what did MCEA give up for it? Or did they just ask?
They got to avoid adding back an instructional day.
Anonymous
02/16/2024 22:57
Subject: Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Will this mean that childcare usually provided during a no school day (before/after care provider who offers the full day of care) would not be offering a full day program that day since technically it’s now a “school day”?
Anonymous
02/16/2024 22:45
Subject: Re:Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This decision totally tracks with the increase in anti-semitism in the district. Well done MCPS.
How? Instead of making staff go in person for a mandatory all day PD day, they now made it an online PD day that will probably take a few hours.
Seems like they gave a benefit, even though non instructional days are not supposed to be solely for religious holidays.
That's nice for the teachers, but I'm talking about for the students and their families. Passover begins that evening but the hours during the day before sunset are used to clean the house and prepare. This decision is all very tone deaf.
The students' work is asynchronous. They can do it on Sunday if they would like to.
Anonymous
02/16/2024 22:18
Subject: Re:Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This decision totally tracks with the increase in anti-semitism in the district. Well done MCPS.
How? Instead of making staff go in person for a mandatory all day PD day, they now made it an online PD day that will probably take a few hours.
Seems like they gave a benefit, even though non instructional days are not supposed to be solely for religious holidays.
That's nice for the teachers, but I'm talking about for the students and their families. Passover begins that evening but the hours during the day before sunset are used to clean the house and prepare. This decision is all very tone deaf.
Anonymous
02/16/2024 20:07
Subject: Re:Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:MoCo Show has the MCEA email
https://mocoshow.com/2024/02/16/mcea-communicates-to-teachers-that-monday-april-22-will-be-the-make-up-day-asynchronous-learning-for-students/
There's no Feb 7th meeting on the board's calendar, so how were they able to discuss and approve the makeup day?
MCEA made the decision, not the school board. Illegal, yes, but no one is going to stop them.
Clearly illegal.
If this is true, it seems more a violation of the board's requirement to have open meetings.
No, because the union was involved. The teachers could have provided input on a personal basis, but the moment MCEA became involved this became an illegal negotiation.
If it was a "negotiation" what did MCEA give up for it? Or did they just ask?
Anonymous
02/16/2024 19:30
Subject: Re:Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:MoCo Show has the MCEA email
https://mocoshow.com/2024/02/16/mcea-communicates-to-teachers-that-monday-april-22-will-be-the-make-up-day-asynchronous-learning-for-students/
There's no Feb 7th meeting on the board's calendar, so how were they able to discuss and approve the makeup day?
MCEA made the decision, not the school board. Illegal, yes, but no one is going to stop them.
Clearly illegal.
If this is true, it seems more a violation of the board's requirement to have open meetings.
No, because the union was involved. The teachers could have provided input on a personal basis, but the moment MCEA became involved this became an illegal negotiation.
Depends on what the difference is between negotiation and advocacy
Don't be obtuse. MCPS leadership met privately with MCEA on at least two occasions to discuss the selection of the make-up day. That was obviously a negotiation with the union, which is clearly illegal under state law.
MCPS breaking the law? What else is new?
Anonymous
02/16/2024 18:50
Subject: Snow Make-up Day is April 22nd - Asynchronous
Anonymous wrote:One day of asynchronous learning (or even, God Forbid, no school at all) is not going to have any measurable impact. And if it does, your kid is in way more trouble than one day of in-person learning can fix.
And I say this as a parent of a magnet hs kid. If your kid can't cope without a babysitter and someone explaining every little thing for *one day* you need to rethink their future.
Elem kids should just be told to read and then play outside.
How many days off does it take to have an impact?