Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 16:39     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
My kid and several friends are EDing to Penn
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 16:30     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Anonymous wrote:Northwestern v. Vanderbilt

Wwyd


Well does your kid want to go to school in Chicago or Nashville?
My kid (who lacks opinions in most things) would be able to tell you that in about 5 seconds.
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 16:11     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Northwestern v. Vanderbilt

Wwyd
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 15:44     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
My DC *was* going to ED to VT but that is no longer an option. Doing EA and crossing all fingers and toes.
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 13:54     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Bowdoin 🤞🏼🤞🏼
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 13:52     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Penn or bust
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 13:11     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Vanderbilt
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 09:40     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I do not think Naviance reflects applications submitted. I think it reflects transcripts requested. There are very few kids at my kid’s school who apply ED. Only 35% go to a 4 year school and it’s mainly in state and then there are some each year who go out of state/to elite schools. But Brown shows something like 8 applications on Naviance, Wake Forest 6. Etc. There is no way that those kids all applied ED this year. Maybe 1 or 2 at most. So I think these are mainly RD applicants.


OK. I’ve been looking at this way too much, and I think I agree that it’s transcript requests or submissions. Initially I thought it couldn’t be that because one of the schools where my kid’s transcript had been requested and submitted wasn’t showing any 2024 applicants, but today it’s showing five (all week it was showing none), which I believe is the minimum number required before any data show. I know the counselors have been working this week on getting things submitted for Nov 1; I assume that yesterday they processed a fifth request, so today it’s showing five. They are processing all requests at once for students, not just the schools with Nov 1 deadlines, which is why the numbers are so high.

I’m now officially done reading these tea leaves.

My data point - unless it differs by school, I do not believe 5 is the number required before any data show. My DD has requested transcripts to all colleges on her list but has only applied to 3 colleges as of now. There are two colleges on her list that she still hasn't applied to but requested transcripts for - the bar chart for 2024 is showing 1 applied for each of those two schools. There is another school on her list - again, she requested the transcript but hasn't submitted the application yet - and that school is showing 0 applied for 2024.

That's my data point - if it were transcript requests, why would two schools on her list show 1 applied but another school on her list would still show 0 applied when she requested transcripts for all those schools?

If it is true applications, wow - a lot of people have been submitting applications to schools already.


I'm pretty sure the minimum threshold to show data does vary by school. I'm guessing what triggers an addition to the "applied" column does, too.
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 09:30     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I do not think Naviance reflects applications submitted. I think it reflects transcripts requested. There are very few kids at my kid’s school who apply ED. Only 35% go to a 4 year school and it’s mainly in state and then there are some each year who go out of state/to elite schools. But Brown shows something like 8 applications on Naviance, Wake Forest 6. Etc. There is no way that those kids all applied ED this year. Maybe 1 or 2 at most. So I think these are mainly RD applicants.


OK. I’ve been looking at this way too much, and I think I agree that it’s transcript requests or submissions. Initially I thought it couldn’t be that because one of the schools where my kid’s transcript had been requested and submitted wasn’t showing any 2024 applicants, but today it’s showing five (all week it was showing none), which I believe is the minimum number required before any data show. I know the counselors have been working this week on getting things submitted for Nov 1; I assume that yesterday they processed a fifth request, so today it’s showing five. They are processing all requests at once for students, not just the schools with Nov 1 deadlines, which is why the numbers are so high.

I’m now officially done reading these tea leaves.

My data point - unless it differs by school, I do not believe 5 is the number required before any data show. My DD has requested transcripts to all colleges on her list but has only applied to 3 colleges as of now. There are two colleges on her list that she still hasn't applied to but requested transcripts for - the bar chart for 2024 is showing 1 applied for each of those two schools. There is another school on her list - again, she requested the transcript but hasn't submitted the application yet - and that school is showing 0 applied for 2024.

That's my data point - if it were transcript requests, why would two schools on her list show 1 applied but another school on her list would still show 0 applied when she requested transcripts for all those schools?

If it is true applications, wow - a lot of people have been submitting applications to schools already.
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 08:27     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I guess not all ED kids are targeting UVA but that's always the first place I think of when I hear ED.


That’s weird since it doesn’t help much and very few apply ED to UVA.


why are you saying this? ED is huge bump at UVA.


UVA admissions is clear that they evaluate all rounds equally. They practically discourage ED applications.


Then why have ED? Many publics do not.



Because uva has a relatively small (remember it’s public bare bones admissions office). It can’t process 57,000 applications if they all come in at once


ED comes in at same time as EA.
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 07:34     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I guess not all ED kids are targeting UVA but that's always the first place I think of when I hear ED.


That’s weird since it doesn’t help much and very few apply ED to UVA.


why are you saying this? ED is huge bump at UVA.


UVA admissions is clear that they evaluate all rounds equally. They practically discourage ED applications.


Then why have ED? Many publics do not.



Because uva has a relatively small (remember it’s public bare bones admissions office). It can’t process 57,000 applications if they all come in at once
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 07:29     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I guess not all ED kids are targeting UVA but that's always the first place I think of when I hear ED.


That’s weird since it doesn’t help much and very few apply ED to UVA.


why are you saying this? ED is huge bump at UVA.


UVA admissions is clear that they evaluate all rounds equally. They practically discourage ED applications.


Then why have ED? Many publics do not.


I bet they eliminate it in the next few years.
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 07:22     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Northwestern extremely popular this year in our school compare to previous years.
Others doing Ed1 U Chicago, u Penn and Dartmouth.
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 00:19     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:clear advantage going ED1 to Vandy - other T20s a more modest lift


Agree, if you're going ED, Vanderbilt seems to reward the effort/commitment.


Vandy also clearly cares about rank after that leadership meltdown, so they will figure out a way to move up again.
Anonymous
Post 10/22/2023 00:18     Subject: Where are your kid or his/her friends EDing this year?
Anonymous wrote:Chicago


Interesting. I saw a number of kids apply ED2 to Chicago but didn't know any ED1 last year. Multiple applied elsewhere REA and didn't get in and then applied ED2 to Chicago.